Re: I repeat that I find her "death" monumental... - Edit 1
Before modification by Sidious at 26/01/2010 07:23:45 PM
The lead up leaves me with doubts, Brandon has said those doubts aren't nonsense and that he intended to have people worrying over this, and I'm worrying over it.
Its you guys who come here dead certain that she is dead, refuse to see alternatives, and sit and explain away major logical flaws so that you can feel you are correct.
Its you guys who come here dead certain that she is dead, refuse to see alternatives, and sit and explain away major logical flaws so that you can feel you are correct.
I'm not certain about her death - I'm merely saying that it's very unlikely that she's alive. When the effects of balefire as seen it is a very strong indicator that the origin has been destroyed. Nothing is set in stone, but I'm pointing out that actually saying she's alive has no real evidence to back it up. I even disagree that thematically it is illogical. She's been a key Forsaken since TFOH, if she dies several books later it makes sense. Rand arrived in Arad Doman with Graendal in mind from the very beginning. To have him destroy her at the end of the book after a lot of soulsearching is logical.