Semirhage's choice of punishment was severing or 'being bound against her pleasures and seeing the end of her life approach'. It seems that the Oath Rod creates a finite limit on a channeler's life. Considering almost no Aes Sedai live past 300, it fits in well with a calculable lifespan after being bound.
But, Semirhage would have "seen the end of her life approach" if all the Binder does is cut your remaining years (not your allotted lifespan) in half.
Having said that ... 3 oaths have more of an impact than 1 oath, on lifespans. Here's a quote for RJ:
If you committed a violent act, or some sort of criminal act, with a binder, someone who could channel could be constrained from ever doing that again, and the result of having three of the Oaths, is the ageless appearance. One would not produce agelessness, but even one would shorten life, and three of them put a cap on Aes Sedai’s lives, on how long they could live.
So, one oath shortens life - maybe halves? you remaining years, say, while three oaths cap it (at ~300, say, like you suggest). So, one oath wouldn't kill Mesaana, presumably, but maybe 3 would.
It's possible AoLers might develop a Binder that works that way. They may not have even known that 3 oaths would cap a life at a particular age (if that's what 3 do), because they didn't even consider the possibility that they'd have to Bind a channeler more than once.
IMO the rod cuts your life in half, and while most strong women live to about 700 years, a bound woman lives for half that. If Mesaana is 300 years old, it might have aged her instantly.
I don't think one Oath does that, but three Oaths quite possibly may.
Rise and fall, turn the Wheel,
'cause all life is
is really just a circle.
-BHT&tM
'cause all life is
is really just a circle.
-BHT&tM
Mesaana and defeating the Oath Rod
18/01/2010 04:50:29 PM
- 2569 Views
I'm think Mesaana's hand is quicker than the eye
18/01/2010 05:12:12 PM
- 1222 Views
Re: I'm think Mesaana's hand is quicker than the eye
18/01/2010 05:43:26 PM
- 1116 Views
I like that idea ...
18/01/2010 06:07:09 PM
- 998 Views
Re: I'm think Mesaana's hand is quicker than the eye
18/01/2010 05:58:44 PM
- 987 Views
I don't think Messana would have fallen over dead
18/01/2010 06:06:35 PM
- 1043 Views
I agree ...
18/01/2010 06:15:25 PM
- 922 Views
I'm not sure
18/01/2010 06:54:51 PM
- 952 Views
It didn't when Romanda retook her Oaths in TGS
18/01/2010 07:13:20 PM
- 773 Views
Hmmm ...
18/01/2010 07:24:51 PM
- 940 Views
No she unswore them and retook them
18/01/2010 07:33:30 PM
- 996 Views
Yeah, I realized that after I posted, so I editted my post (again) ...
18/01/2010 07:36:39 PM
- 961 Views
I'm not sure I follow
18/01/2010 07:41:19 PM
- 964 Views
The point I was trying to make was ...
18/01/2010 08:05:16 PM
- 753 Views
Now I get it ... seems needlessly complex for the Oath Rod though
18/01/2010 08:21:35 PM
- 752 Views
What you suggested is pretty much what I've always thought ...
18/01/2010 08:39:30 PM
- 766 Views
yup
18/01/2010 09:02:04 PM
- 653 Views
I'm with you, though ...
18/01/2010 09:27:59 PM
- 918 Views
The closest evidence we have is a Stilled/Burned out woman
18/01/2010 09:49:41 PM
- 755 Views
But if being unbound reverts you to your normal lifespan, then being bound isn't really a punishment *NM*
18/01/2010 09:52:29 PM
- 386 Views
Re: I'm not sure
18/01/2010 07:22:34 PM
- 821 Views
interesting
18/01/2010 07:46:12 PM
- 657 Views
Re: interesting
18/01/2010 08:18:11 PM
- 798 Views
The Dark Ones Mark possibly could black the oath rod? *NM*
20/01/2010 01:28:08 AM
- 371 Views
No, that can't be it, because when AS become Black Ajah ...
20/01/2010 02:53:21 PM
- 728 Views
But Alviarin's mark is different. Perhaps the mark of a FS is too *NM*
20/01/2010 04:21:16 PM
- 350 Views
Good point. I sort of misinterpreted what Kieran was suggesting. *NM*
20/01/2010 07:19:02 PM
- 370 Views
Re: Good point. I sort of misinterpreted what Kieran was suggesting.
22/01/2010 01:52:51 AM
- 891 Views
actually it's different
22/01/2010 07:32:18 AM
- 835 Views
actually I think it's the same...
23/01/2010 01:49:19 AM
- 547 Views
Nup. Unlike the FS, her mark will not allow her to order Darkspawn (plus more). *NM*
23/01/2010 11:50:36 AM
- 384 Views
Which has nothing to do with my post regarding the Oath rod... *NM*
24/01/2010 10:44:59 PM
- 379 Views
One point...
18/01/2010 06:12:26 PM
- 954 Views
Re: Mesaana and defeating the Oath Rod
18/01/2010 09:43:34 PM
- 897 Views
I'm thinking the point of the thread is to discuss how to beat the Oath Rod, not Mesaana's disguise
18/01/2010 09:59:18 PM
- 722 Views
Right, and also ...
18/01/2010 10:17:11 PM
- 742 Views
Except that the best way to 'defeat' the Oath rod is - not to take the Oaths at all
19/01/2010 03:18:43 AM
- 652 Views
Another interesting possibility
19/01/2010 05:08:42 PM
- 743 Views
I'd say it was highly unlikely that the Binder/Oath Rod works that way. *NM*
19/01/2010 06:06:49 PM
- 319 Views
We've seen pretty weird stuff happens before
19/01/2010 06:30:12 PM
- 836 Views
Oh, I agree ...
19/01/2010 06:47:52 PM
- 609 Views
Re: Oh, I agree ... found a few tidbits ... EDIT
19/01/2010 06:55:22 PM
- 759 Views
Heh, I had just dug up that quote myself, before I saw your edit ...
19/01/2010 07:17:19 PM
- 773 Views
I agree, it seems as if Moghedien just effectively transmigrated Birgitte
19/01/2010 10:00:45 PM
- 856 Views
she could just be posing as a non-channeler.
19/01/2010 05:52:01 PM
- 721 Views
If RJ/Brandon lied about that... then maybe Demandred is Taim after all. *NM*
20/01/2010 03:20:42 AM
- 323 Views
To speak no word that is not true
19/01/2010 10:06:30 PM
- 794 Views
Could there be a true word, though?
20/01/2010 03:47:46 PM
- 1043 Views
I had a similar discussion with someone else, long ago ...
20/01/2010 04:05:03 PM
- 703 Views
Or would just be able to say "true, true. True true true, true true." etc. *NM*
21/01/2010 06:17:20 PM
- 364 Views
In going through some old RJ quotes I found this gem...
19/01/2010 10:22:03 PM
- 1062 Views
Nice find! Not sure if that is a "way to defeat the Oath Rod" exactly, but it's certainly feasible.
20/01/2010 03:19:51 AM
- 883 Views
Wow, that's great. I wonder what else can be created there, like sa'angeals, etc.
20/01/2010 03:54:01 AM
- 681 Views
Good find, I had forgotten about that quote ...
20/01/2010 02:42:55 PM
- 799 Views
Yes
20/01/2010 03:03:53 PM
- 786 Views
Oh I agree! I just thought it was funny that RJ made such a quote
20/01/2010 04:20:09 PM
- 778 Views
In the AoL...
20/01/2010 04:49:24 PM
- 865 Views
I was thinking this too
20/01/2010 07:18:19 PM
- 816 Views
I like it, mainly because it points to Mesaana being bested by Egwene in T'A'R
21/01/2010 04:26:34 PM
- 688 Views
maybe she warded herself before goin in or just set her frame of mind to beat it *NM*
21/01/2010 02:07:17 AM
- 406 Views