I think BS did quite an amazing job of continuity in carrying the torch forward of Jordan's characters and world/tone. I was concerned a little after reading BS's writings about not trying to imitate Jordan's style, etc., but when reading, the reality turned out to be that his writing style blended smoothly.
The true test? Having read the series over and over again in print, I decided to revisit it this time in audiobook format, and listened to the entire series in order, through TGS. For those of you who haven't listened to audiobooks -- books being read aloud show flaws in a way that is often dismissible in print, particularly the dialog, character interactions, and characters' internal musings. In this format, I was amazed how smoothly Jordan's books flowed together, and then how nicely TGS fit right in, a perfectly matched piece.
My only complaints with TGS are in decisions to not picture certain events -- especially some that I was anticipating. My gut instinct is that these were editor's decisions, if only in part. There was a sense some things were rushed, compared to the later Jordan books where every little detail in plot was described. I suspect an executive decision of some kind was made that in order to get to the end, some clips would end up on the cutting-room floor. While I understand this outlook, I personally would have welcomed an extra couple scenes of Semirhage for example, and I think it was odd that the entire rooting out of the rebel aes sedai black ajah was skipped and only viewed in hindsight.
The true test? Having read the series over and over again in print, I decided to revisit it this time in audiobook format, and listened to the entire series in order, through TGS. For those of you who haven't listened to audiobooks -- books being read aloud show flaws in a way that is often dismissible in print, particularly the dialog, character interactions, and characters' internal musings. In this format, I was amazed how smoothly Jordan's books flowed together, and then how nicely TGS fit right in, a perfectly matched piece.
My only complaints with TGS are in decisions to not picture certain events -- especially some that I was anticipating. My gut instinct is that these were editor's decisions, if only in part. There was a sense some things were rushed, compared to the later Jordan books where every little detail in plot was described. I suspect an executive decision of some kind was made that in order to get to the end, some clips would end up on the cutting-room floor. While I understand this outlook, I personally would have welcomed an extra couple scenes of Semirhage for example, and I think it was odd that the entire rooting out of the rebel aes sedai black ajah was skipped and only viewed in hindsight.
Can't bring myself to re-read tGS
23/12/2009 12:01:33 PM
- 1583 Views
I think pretty much alone, yes
23/12/2009 01:39:52 PM
- 957 Views
I'm sorry you feel that way. I thought Sanderson did an outstanding job. *NM*
23/12/2009 04:30:16 PM
- 544 Views
People who post on WOT messageboards do not comprise a reprsentative sample
23/12/2009 07:01:48 PM
- 827 Views
Re: People who post on WOT messageboards do not comprise a reprsentative sample
23/12/2009 10:34:15 PM
- 914 Views
It was better than POD or COT if you ask me. It was as good as I could have asked for from BS *NM*
25/12/2009 12:10:51 AM
- 371 Views
OK, maybe the writting wasn't as good, but the story was better than the previous couple of books *NM*
29/12/2009 08:24:17 AM
- 316 Views
No, you're not. It was OK - I was more happy that the series seemed to be progressing
29/12/2009 03:43:59 PM
- 641 Views
Except for the Mat parts, it was fairly good.
30/12/2009 04:30:15 AM
- 672 Views
Yeah, CoT is one of the WoT books I don't even use as a reference. I try to forget it. *NM*
30/12/2009 03:53:25 PM
- 357 Views
The Mat parts were the only places I was jarred by the difference in writing style
14/01/2010 03:12:58 PM
- 650 Views
Sorry, but I think Jordan was not writing all that well himself anymore
14/01/2010 09:19:07 AM
- 733 Views
I couldn't disagree more.
17/01/2010 11:06:52 PM
- 703 Views