Active Users:482 Time:26/12/2024 01:26:08 PM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
Don't damn me, damn Graendal Abunderment Send a noteboard - 09/12/2009 12:51:18 PM
And damn you for making me defend Egwene.

It's okay. Your argument is sufficiently weak that it is no real defence. You are free of this burden, and may remove the curse.

But don't fault her for putting an end to 50 BA. She learned her lesson from Moggy's escape.

If she'd waited to collar the known BA in her own camp, it's very likely she would have lost ALL of them, and not just those in the tower.

Why "very likely"? This is a preposterous assertion.

What evidence is there that the BA plans an attack? NONE

What evidence that they could carry out an attack if they planned it? NONE

What evidence that she could protect herself in such event? GOOD

Moggy's situation was rather unusual, don't you think? Not too many parallels. Chosen, a'dam, being used as a teacher by accepted, can implicate girls as phoney AS, released by a male.

I think that fact that none of the 50 Salidar AS even twigged is actually more interesting. Shows their uselessness.

Egwene had no idea that the WT AS were going to name her Amyrlin that very day.


Because she MADE NO ATTEMPT TO FIND OUT. Had she sent spies she may well have.

Irrespective, she did not even contemplate the possibility. Which is odd, given that this was all she has been working for.

Ignorance is not generally the best of defences.

She thought Elaida was still in charge in the tower.

But a false assumption. See previous.

She had no way to know otherwise. If there were some feasible method for spying on internal tower doings, the rebels would have been doing that from day one of the siege.

Yeah right. Are you suffering Graendel compulsion?

They could travel into tower and look about. Use Accepted/kin. Use AS with a brain. The Aes Sedai have A RIGHT to be there anyway.

Travel in some smart soldiers, washerwomen etc to TV or grounds and get intelligence.

Travel to the dungeon where the BA hunters are holding prisoners and talk to guards. Unlikely they will betray anyone.

Travel into Elaida's Office and ask her.

Use T'AR to spy. (Egwene and any with the last ring)

Given that Tower AS can travel into Tower, the assumption that the Salidar AS would-have-if-they-could-have-so-thus-they-can't seems cavalier. The AS are not perfect, you know.

I'm not arguing that it wouldn't have been better if she'd waited and enacted her plan after the tower was united, but she had to act on the information and situation she was facing AT THE TIME. She did not have access to our omniscient reader's POV, or the advantage of hindsight.

My point was that Egwene is not perfect because her command decisions were sub-optimal.

Yes, she had to guess. As do all commanders. And hers were (in hindsight) poor. There is no other way to judge such things, but in hindsight!!! The Allies won WWII. We still say "in hindsight, appeasing Hitler was a mistake". We still say "Churchill was a lone voice in opposing appeasement". In hindsight, was Chamberlain right? Or Churchill? Surely they can't both be?

Egwene's deadlines were her own. She was not compelled to reveal her BA knowledge. She was not compelled to march on tower. These were CHOICES.

As readers we are not omniscient. If we were, this site would be irrelevant. We have but snippets of information.

Most readers seem to think BA were about to attack or flee en masse. Why?

Most readers seem to think marching on Tower made sense. Why?

The fact that Siuan made a mistake in "saving" Egwene seems to be also accepted. Why?

These are my 3 examples of Egwene being a sub-optimal leader. Thus showing she is not "perfect" but flawed - no less so than, say, Rand. Just because RJ/BS fawn over EaV does not mean we have to.

Reply to message
Semirhage and Egwene redqueen - 04/12/2009 02:31:45 PM 1675 Views
I agree with all of that. nossy - 04/12/2009 02:58:48 PM 912 Views
Re: I agree with all of that. *NM* Sidious - 04/12/2009 03:22:49 PM 438 Views
Re: I agree with all of that. nossy - 04/12/2009 03:29:46 PM 863 Views
Re: I agree with all of that. Sidious - 04/12/2009 03:33:03 PM 894 Views
Re: I agree with all of that. RugbyPlayingAshaman - 04/12/2009 04:13:55 PM 785 Views
The entire cast is full of Perfect Sues and Stuarts (I may have just made latter up) RugbyPlayingAshaman - 04/12/2009 03:14:27 PM 915 Views
If you plan to write that review before the last two books are out, you better get re-reading now. *NM* Insomdeon - 04/12/2009 03:20:31 PM 386 Views
I'm actually pretty comfortable with it! RugbyPlayingAshaman - 04/12/2009 04:12:32 PM 811 Views
Re: I'm actually pretty comfortable with it! darius_sedai - 04/12/2009 06:50:10 PM 835 Views
about Semirhage Sidious - 04/12/2009 03:21:32 PM 1227 Views
but nossy - 04/12/2009 03:26:29 PM 816 Views
Re: but Sidious - 04/12/2009 03:35:52 PM 805 Views
Re: but nossy - 04/12/2009 03:46:00 PM 850 Views
Re: but Sidious - 04/12/2009 03:51:03 PM 809 Views
Cadsuane is rather close to perfect herself. Legolas - 04/12/2009 08:37:21 PM 899 Views
Re: but TaskmasterJack - 04/12/2009 05:04:12 PM 809 Views
Re: but WAV - 04/12/2009 05:41:51 PM 827 Views
She was never THAT person. Wotmaniac Reborn - 06/12/2009 01:22:39 AM 786 Views
Never WHAT person? nossy - 06/12/2009 10:21:43 PM 821 Views
I'm not sure I agree Sidious - 08/12/2009 12:54:43 PM 681 Views
I agree! RugbyPlayingAshaman - 04/12/2009 04:31:24 PM 778 Views
Re: about Semirhage redqueen - 04/12/2009 08:16:15 PM 807 Views
Alas, Semirhage was actually an idiot Etzel - 04/12/2009 05:03:48 PM 946 Views
Re: Alas, Semirhage was actually an idiot darius_sedai - 04/12/2009 06:42:41 PM 806 Views
If one compares the characters... Etzel - 05/12/2009 11:24:16 AM 737 Views
Did I miss Rand's marriage ceremonies? I always thought the three girls only bonded him *NM* Voscaia Sedai - 05/12/2009 11:27:36 AM 383 Views
You are right... Etzel - 05/12/2009 12:21:59 PM 768 Views
I disagree darius_sedai - 05/12/2009 05:11:28 PM 768 Views
Egwene had the best mix of teachers and a desire to learn. Most believable, IMO. *NM* fionwe1987 - 04/12/2009 10:17:56 PM 407 Views
That's really nonsense Etzel - 05/12/2009 11:13:20 AM 745 Views
I think your perception is very skewed darius_sedai - 05/12/2009 05:16:46 PM 749 Views
Agreed Sidious - 05/12/2009 06:15:46 PM 773 Views
Bull! fionwe1987 - 06/12/2009 02:55:13 AM 776 Views
Rabbit! BlackAdder - 06/12/2009 04:14:10 AM 711 Views
Re: Alas, Semirhage was actually an idiot Sidious - 05/12/2009 06:11:40 PM 756 Views
Indeed darius_sedai - 05/12/2009 06:30:39 PM 815 Views
And yet Egwene is still a fool regarding Gawyn. Lord Haart - 04/12/2009 05:44:49 PM 876 Views
Gawyn is a fool all of his own redqueen - 04/12/2009 08:02:10 PM 809 Views
Re: Gawyn is a fool all of his own Lord Haart - 05/12/2009 05:54:11 AM 716 Views
Please stop - your use of logic here is sickening! BlackAdder - 06/12/2009 04:43:31 AM 781 Views
I disagree with most of that rAndy aL - 05/12/2009 10:58:12 AM 791 Views
Egwene has a long way to go ... Abunderment - 05/12/2009 06:16:31 PM 792 Views
Hardly a blunder Nameless Ashaman - 06/12/2009 01:43:54 AM 750 Views
Re: Hardly a blunder? Send Egwene back to Silviana. Abunderment - 07/12/2009 04:03:08 PM 775 Views
Or she her rescue forced her hand. She lost her advantage darius_sedai - 07/12/2009 04:47:56 PM 675 Views
She lost her advantage?!? Siuan probably saved her life Abunderment - 09/12/2009 11:57:26 AM 771 Views
darius_sedai - 09/12/2009 03:24:34 PM 794 Views
She should have attacked when they first arrived Nameless Ashaman - 07/12/2009 09:35:33 PM 700 Views
Don't damn me, damn Graendal Abunderment - 09/12/2009 12:51:18 PM 737 Views
Re: Don't damn me, damn Graendal Nameless Ashaman - 09/12/2009 06:11:53 PM 892 Views
A couple of points darius_sedai - 09/12/2009 07:11:18 PM 775 Views
Yes, the Aes Sedai need to rediscover the meaning of "servants of all" *NM* BlackAdder - 06/12/2009 05:03:19 AM 729 Views
I'm re-reading the series now for the first time in years. Egwene has always been a weak character. Master Radishes - 07/12/2009 01:12:15 AM 767 Views
LOL *NM* Sidious - 07/12/2009 04:29:56 AM 310 Views
I think you'll find few people who agree with you on both of those counts... Legolas - 07/12/2009 01:53:58 PM 720 Views
Not at all. Master Radishes - 07/12/2009 03:20:38 PM 711 Views
Irritating teen spirits ... Abunderment - 07/12/2009 04:32:51 PM 799 Views
As long as the bags were Louis Vuitton all would be fine *NM* darius_sedai - 07/12/2009 04:51:13 PM 441 Views
You must not have been reading the same series I have. Legolas - 07/12/2009 10:33:23 PM 833 Views
Re: You must not have been reading the same series I have. Abunderment - 09/12/2009 01:12:56 PM 734 Views
Re: You must not have been reading the same series I have. Legolas - 09/12/2009 02:59:04 PM 773 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes