I think RJ would have indeed prepared this twist at least a bit more in the books, not just in the Guide and in interviews.
Also Graendal says that the battlefield are the Westlands. All other Forsaken were active there. Therefore I doubt that Demandred has the Land of the Madmen or Shara under his thumb.
Besides that, if Demandred controlled so many channelers, he would have the resources the rescue Semirhage. But in TGS, prologue, he apparently doesn't have them.
In my view, the Shadow doesn't even need that many channelers, because the DO's growing powers will basically counter the Lightside armies pretty easily (turn weapons or armor into wax & water into blood, spoil food, randomly kill people or boost their "evil" character traits, maybe eventually blocking the access to the OP, etc.).
I still think the best solution is that Demandred controlled the Dragonsworn (especially Masema, maybe also those in Tarabon) and since PoD or WH additonally controls Murandy.
Also Graendal says that the battlefield are the Westlands. All other Forsaken were active there. Therefore I doubt that Demandred has the Land of the Madmen or Shara under his thumb.
Besides that, if Demandred controlled so many channelers, he would have the resources the rescue Semirhage. But in TGS, prologue, he apparently doesn't have them.
In my view, the Shadow doesn't even need that many channelers, because the DO's growing powers will basically counter the Lightside armies pretty easily (turn weapons or armor into wax & water into blood, spoil food, randomly kill people or boost their "evil" character traits, maybe eventually blocking the access to the OP, etc.).
I still think the best solution is that Demandred controlled the Dragonsworn (especially Masema, maybe also those in Tarabon) and since PoD or WH additonally controls Murandy.
Demandred and the far, far South...
16/11/2009 10:08:35 PM
- 1023 Views
Land of Madmen could be intro'd easily, but incorporated awkwardly
16/11/2009 11:36:17 PM
- 644 Views
The Land of Madmen was already introduced in TGS, silly
17/11/2009 03:49:42 AM
- 610 Views
I thought it was mentioned in TGS.
17/11/2009 05:08:55 AM
- 502 Views
You can hardly describe a continent that size as a "barren isle". *NM*
17/11/2009 09:06:31 AM
- 241 Views
no, but it was briefly mentioned by the sea folk earlier in the series......can't remember when. *NM*
17/11/2009 04:42:35 PM
- 215 Views
While it would be cool in a way...
17/11/2009 04:57:45 PM
- 492 Views