The answer lies in a fundamental difference between spinning and maintaining a weave...
fionwe1987 Send a noteboard - 13/11/2009 09:33:00 AM
I've never before considered that multiple sisters spinning a shield would use any other approach than a circle.
They don't. When spinning the weave, the circle is the way to go, I think. It is only when long term maintenance of a weave is needed that they unlink.
Frankly, I don't understand how a SINGLE shield can be woven by mulitple, UNLINKED channelers. I thought the whole point of Asmodean's warning about the female linking advantage, and that about a man needing to be wary around 13 sisters, is that they can link while a man cannot.
Yup. Rand's shield (our best example) was weaved by thirteen LINKED sisters. You cannot weave one shield with unlinked channelers.
And Asmodean's warning was that 13 sisters LINKED could shield any man. Not 13 sisters individually.
I'm not disputing this at all. If thirteen unlinked sisters tried to shield Rand, I doubt he would find it difficult to shrug them off. There is no way they can achieve the coordination required unlinked.
Regarding the soft and hard points in Rand's shield, those were simply the access points of the various women in the circle, I thought. Now I'm not an expert on linking so your view is certainly interesting.
Thing is, if this was a circle, wouldn't he just feel one giant soft point? A circle works so that one single sister becomes the conduit for the power of everyone in the circle. How can there be six points then?
I just have a fundamental problem understanding how UNLINKED sisters can co-ordinate their channeling sufficiently to maintain a SINGLE shield on a man. In my view, it would have to be six seperate shields, or however many women are involved in creating it.
They are merely maintaining parts of a shield. Look at it this way...
A shield on Rand needs to be made of X saidar, which can only be gotten by linking. Once made, X saidar units need to be maintained in the shield. This can be done by tying the whole shield off (direct recharging of the shield from the source). This can be worked through, so it is no option.
Another way is if the circle leader continues to maintain the weave. This will work, but is overkill.
So, they take advantage of the fact that since X saidar is already there, all they need to do is provide smaller amounts of the Power to various parts of the shield, thus maintaining it at the same strength.
This needs further exploration, because you've raised an interesting point here.
Yup. It certainly seems to be clear from that Egwene PoV, but not too many discussions have focused on it.
Semirhage's strength in the Power...
12/11/2009 06:57:37 AM
- 1084 Views
No you did not...
12/11/2009 07:27:06 AM
- 703 Views
I'll look again tonight, but I'm sure Nynaeve made a comment...
12/11/2009 07:33:29 AM
- 708 Views
Actually, Nynaeave is far stronger than Moghedian now
12/11/2009 12:30:29 PM
- 661 Views
We DON'T know that Graendal is stronger than Semirhage and Mesaana...
12/11/2009 12:48:32 PM
- 763 Views
Inconsistency?
12/11/2009 08:53:39 AM
- 636 Views
Holding a shield vs. making one...
12/11/2009 03:19:09 PM
- 600 Views
Don't they clearly say one single would suffice but they used 2 for
13/11/2009 04:57:15 AM
- 536 Views
To HOLD her. Didn't I make the distinction clear?
13/11/2009 05:04:58 AM
- 518 Views
Reducing the number of people holding the shield, reduces the strength of the shield correspondingly
13/11/2009 07:15:24 AM
- 505 Views
Not necessarily true (Plus, another possibility)...
13/11/2009 07:43:37 AM
- 501 Views
I agree about the angreal, but not the 1 woman shield part...
13/11/2009 07:50:26 AM
- 530 Views
Agree to disagree?
13/11/2009 08:07:59 AM
- 503 Views
Sure, just a couple of points...
13/11/2009 08:18:15 AM
- 590 Views
Re: Sure, just a couple of points...
13/11/2009 08:51:28 AM
- 571 Views
Interesting concept...
13/11/2009 08:59:53 AM
- 602 Views
The answer lies in a fundamental difference between spinning and maintaining a weave...
13/11/2009 09:33:00 AM
- 600 Views
Yeah, I posted on this
12/11/2009 08:53:26 PM
- 562 Views
Hmmm....
13/11/2009 12:42:37 AM
- 609 Views
Mesaana thought she matched Semirhage
13/11/2009 01:45:09 AM
- 742 Views
Re: Hmmm....
13/11/2009 06:56:56 AM
- 539 Views
I think Sanderson just doesn't have the interest and knowledge of relative strength that RJ did..
13/11/2009 07:07:45 AM
- 532 Views
Re: Hmmm....
13/11/2009 07:59:57 AM
- 595 Views
The reason behind our (certainly MY) hesitance to place Nynaeve too high, is Alivia...
13/11/2009 08:04:51 AM
- 618 Views
There is a simple answer... skill...
13/11/2009 08:21:25 AM
- 614 Views
Except that...
13/11/2009 08:49:15 AM
- 606 Views
What about Sharina?
13/11/2009 09:17:20 AM
- 517 Views
No evidence either way, but you leave a massive gap between Lanfear and the average Forsaken...
13/11/2009 09:31:27 AM
- 621 Views
I don't think it's massive
13/11/2009 09:46:27 AM
- 587 Views