Why is it impossible? You can't have parallel timelines? - Edit 1
Before modification by NaClH2O at 12/11/2009 11:30:10 AM
I will follow your conditions and prove that Graendal CAN STILL REVEAL HERSELF TO BE THE KILLER!
There are several ways to do this.
1a: Off scene. Graendal talks to Cyndane and says I killed Asmo. Sometime later Cyndane says "Graendal said she killed Asmo" bingo.
1b: Same scenario but a bit different, Flash back to Cyndane meeting with Graendal. Graendal says "I have killed Asmo".
2: Even more likely in my opinion is that tGS and ToM have parallel timelines for a while. This is extremely likely in my opinion there are many things that need to be explained that have already happened (Galad meeting Perrin, Mat in Caemlyn). It would make perfect sense to have ToM cover some of the same time as tGS. In the some time frame (before Granny gets it) we see and hear Graendal saying "I killed asmo"
NaCl(many many different ways for that to happen)H2O
' />
There are several ways to do this.
1a: Off scene. Graendal talks to Cyndane and says I killed Asmo. Sometime later Cyndane says "Graendal said she killed Asmo" bingo.
1b: Same scenario but a bit different, Flash back to Cyndane meeting with Graendal. Graendal says "I have killed Asmo".
2: Even more likely in my opinion is that tGS and ToM have parallel timelines for a while. This is extremely likely in my opinion there are many things that need to be explained that have already happened (Galad meeting Perrin, Mat in Caemlyn). It would make perfect sense to have ToM cover some of the same time as tGS. In the some time frame (before Granny gets it) we see and hear Graendal saying "I killed asmo"
NaCl(many many different ways for that to happen)H2O
' />But I find it likely, and not ridiculous.