Graendal cannot comment later that she killed Asmodean if she is dead by balefire.
There is a theory out there that we might see Asmodean reappear in the series, based on the assumption that Graendal could have been burnt out far enough back to undo Asmodean's death.
The logic goes like this:
1. No character has yet revealed themselves as Asmodean's killer.
2. Graendal cannot reveal herself as Asmodean's killer because she died by balefire.
3. The only possible way to still implicate Graendal as Asmodean's killer is if somehow Asmodean were to reappear in the series (i.e. if Graendal were the killer and she was balefired back far enough, then Asmo might reappear)
4. Because Brandon says it is impossible to burn Graendal out that far back, it is impossible the balefiring of Graendal will cause Asmodean to reappear.
5. Graendal cannot reveal herself as Asmodean's killer directly (because she is balefired) or indirectly (by Asmodean reappearing).
Ergo, somebody else killed Asmodean, not Graendal.
There is a theory out there that we might see Asmodean reappear in the series, based on the assumption that Graendal could have been burnt out far enough back to undo Asmodean's death.
The logic goes like this:
1. No character has yet revealed themselves as Asmodean's killer.
2. Graendal cannot reveal herself as Asmodean's killer because she died by balefire.
3. The only possible way to still implicate Graendal as Asmodean's killer is if somehow Asmodean were to reappear in the series (i.e. if Graendal were the killer and she was balefired back far enough, then Asmo might reappear)
4. Because Brandon says it is impossible to burn Graendal out that far back, it is impossible the balefiring of Graendal will cause Asmodean to reappear.
5. Graendal cannot reveal herself as Asmodean's killer directly (because she is balefired) or indirectly (by Asmodean reappearing).
Ergo, somebody else killed Asmodean, not Graendal.
Sanderson eliminates a particular somebody from consideration as Asmodean's killer
- 11/11/2009 05:18:48 PM
1906 Views
He didn't say if she did or did not.
- 11/11/2009 05:27:34 PM
849 Views
Yes, Brandon did. I edited my original message to add in another quote from Brandon...see above *NM*
- 11/11/2009 05:33:27 PM
453 Views
That still doesn't say if she did or did not.
- 11/11/2009 05:39:12 PM
891 Views
It eliminates for the following
- 11/11/2009 05:44:29 PM
901 Views
That's quite a leap of logic...
- 11/11/2009 06:31:21 PM
964 Views
Re:
- 11/11/2009 07:46:15 PM
949 Views
I can't follow your logic
- 11/11/2009 06:33:41 PM
743 Views
That is a fallacious leap of logic.
- 11/11/2009 06:50:13 PM
812 Views
your interpretation is wrong
- 11/11/2009 05:47:53 PM
808 Views
I generally agree...
- 11/11/2009 06:11:46 PM
881 Views
There's nothing in those quotes that even touches on who killed Asmodean.
- 11/11/2009 06:40:31 PM
817 Views
Re: There's nothing in those quotes that even touches on who killed Asmodean.
- 11/11/2009 07:53:19 PM
718 Views
Re: There's nothing in those quotes that even touches on who killed Asmodean.
- 11/11/2009 11:31:12 PM
779 Views
Logain is just making too much of a RJ comment in which he said he'd "probably" do it that way.
- 12/11/2009 12:13:25 AM
797 Views
This logic is lacking as well
- 11/11/2009 10:17:48 PM
857 Views
Re: Sanderson eliminates a particular somebody from consideration as Asmodean's killer
- 11/11/2009 07:59:32 PM
807 Views
But do you agree that Graendal cannot reveal herself if she got balefired? *NM*
- 11/11/2009 08:07:53 PM
417 Views
Re: But do you agree that Graendal cannot reveal herself if she got balefired?
- 11/11/2009 08:15:16 PM
740 Views
Sure she can reveal herself! Even if she got Balefired!
- 11/11/2009 08:52:49 PM
850 Views
this is what happens when you get interrupted in the middle of a post *NM*
- 11/11/2009 09:28:01 PM
400 Views
What? Did you double post?
- 11/11/2009 09:49:15 PM
724 Views
Ya, got couple of phone calls and some other stuff and forgot where I was in the process
*NM*
- 11/11/2009 10:10:10 PM
373 Views
*NM*
- 11/11/2009 10:10:10 PM
373 Views
According to Etzel, this is impossible
- 12/11/2009 04:14:47 AM
772 Views
I don't say it's impossible...
- 12/11/2009 03:11:17 PM
807 Views
We can still have a pre-death PoV from her. Or another Chosen can implicate her. *NM*
- 11/11/2009 10:48:10 PM
390 Views
That did not confirm anything except her being balefired wouldn't bring him back.
- 12/11/2009 03:48:43 AM
782 Views
Uh, I read the exact opposite
- 12/11/2009 04:13:45 AM
778 Views
That is the most absurd leap in logic I have read in a LONG time.
- 12/11/2009 02:51:00 PM
722 Views
Then you must have missed the threads about Elayne, Aviendha and Min melting together. =P *NM*
- 12/11/2009 06:24:53 PM
391 Views
