Active Users:753 Time:03/04/2025 05:25:55 AM
My review, spoilers. AgentOrange Send a noteboard - 08/11/2009 02:02:35 PM
This book was a rush. As you can expect from a WoT boomk after a 4 year hiatus. I think Sanderson did an admirable job but I did find myself thinking how good it could have been had RJ written it. The first half read truer to me than the second half.
It's mostly characterisation issues. I first noticed it with Mat, which is understandable as humour is the most difficult thing to write. Mat turned from a guy who has a twisted funny way of looking at things to a silly wisecracker. Oh well, it's a good enough substitute considering how hard it is to be a ghost writer.
Siuan was also one character that felt off. She didn't feel like a previous Amyrlin. More like a dumb child and hardly used her boat and dockmaster's daughter thought processes. Too bad, because it made most of her scenes weak. It wouldn't matter too much except it spoiled some of Egwene's scenes too.
Egwene had very good characterisation. You can tell Brandomn put alot of effort here, though most of her better scenes were at the start of the book, like the Nature of Pain. The chapter in which she organises the novices was very good. I did find myself bewildered by her overly long acceptence speech. I would compare it with Elayne's acceptence speech from the previous book, which was better. Less is More.
Rand was also well done. In fact, my favourite part was the whole Semirhage on the loose fiasco. For a moment there I actually thought he was going to kill Min.
So, to sum up, I give it a goot 8.5/10. Some stuff was off but Egwene and Rand were well done, which was most important. I just wish all the side characters didn't all sound the same. No real difference between Merise and Siuan for example.
Reply to message
The Gathering Storm user reviews - 18/10/2009 08:39:01 AM 6729 Views
Another review from Jennifer Liang - 19/10/2009 12:27:34 AM 2117 Views
Chapter Titles - 20/10/2009 01:46:16 PM 1942 Views
Exciting - 20/10/2009 05:37:24 PM 1567 Views
Chapter 8 : P - 20/10/2009 08:00:12 PM 1451 Views
I lilke that idea *NM* - 20/10/2009 11:43:09 PM 712 Views
Yeah! it was - 17/11/2009 06:34:56 PM 1028 Views
My speculation on chapter titles - 20/10/2009 08:25:02 PM 1521 Views
I'm hoping that chapters 4-6 involve shadowspawn on the rampage. - 21/10/2009 02:11:24 AM 1204 Views
Re: My speculation on chapter titles - 21/10/2009 03:07:21 PM 1146 Views
Ch 4 might be Aviendha *NM* - 21/10/2009 03:36:52 PM 801 Views
I am most excited about... - 20/10/2009 08:30:56 PM 1502 Views
Here are the PoVs, but not matched (still, enter at own risk) - 21/10/2009 05:45:51 AM 1586 Views
Re: Here are the PoVs, but not matched (still, enter at own risk) - 21/10/2009 05:48:48 AM 1304 Views
I may be the only one who feels this way but *sigh* - 21/10/2009 06:27:29 AM 1403 Views
Re: Here are the PoVs, but not matched (still, enter at own risk) - 21/10/2009 07:00:38 AM 1208 Views
Gah! - 21/10/2009 10:20:26 AM 1316 Views
You're forgetting the prologue: Graendal, Masema, etc. *NM* - 21/10/2009 03:19:52 PM 820 Views
i said in the post "not counting the prologue" *NM* - 21/10/2009 07:31:30 PM 688 Views
Re: Here are the PoVs, but not matched (still, enter at own risk) - 21/10/2009 04:49:45 PM 1229 Views
My (spoiler-free) review - 21/10/2009 05:20:47 AM 1749 Views
Does Mat still feel like Mat? - 21/10/2009 06:32:14 AM 1317 Views
Re: My (spoiler-free) review - 21/10/2009 10:17:48 AM 1584 Views
I would say I have no clue and I disagree 100% with Pat - 21/10/2009 07:43:13 PM 1398 Views
Pat seems like a hardcore books 1-5 are amazing!!!111one and everything else stinks. - 21/10/2009 10:04:40 PM 1376 Views
Who the hell is Sleet? - 21/10/2009 11:58:13 PM 2290 Views
Sleete - 22/10/2009 03:25:19 AM 1323 Views
Re: Sleete - 22/10/2009 01:01:55 PM 1198 Views
Sparring is not determinitive of who's better, only real combat does. - 22/10/2009 03:44:58 AM 1357 Views
I wonder who that could be - 21/10/2009 05:31:46 PM 1230 Views
The only real problem I had - 21/10/2009 08:16:12 PM 1251 Views
This is not a full review, but a commentary that might give some a hint to what happens(ed) to Rand - 22/10/2009 12:14:33 AM 1687 Views
Was it well done? *NM* - 22/10/2009 03:14:25 AM 696 Views
I thought so - 22/10/2009 03:22:30 AM 1424 Views
Is it a Seanchan prophecy or is it a prophecy quoted by the Seanchan - 22/10/2009 03:47:45 AM 1358 Views
The first, but it fits the story thematically - 22/10/2009 04:01:45 AM 2020 Views
it's from a different set of prophecies - 22/10/2009 04:12:53 AM 1297 Views
Glad to hear that. - 22/10/2009 05:11:52 AM 1296 Views
Now halfway through. Unbelievable. - 22/10/2009 03:05:58 PM 1470 Views
It's midnight now, so my review can go public - 27/10/2009 03:58:46 AM 1386 Views
My full review is now up - 27/10/2009 04:07:59 AM 1482 Views
Is the url correct? *NM* - 27/10/2009 04:23:09 AM 640 Views
It is now - 27/10/2009 04:28:34 AM 1189 Views
feel free to link my reviews whenever you like *NM* - 27/10/2009 04:30:56 AM 629 Views
You need the traffic, huh? *NM* - 27/10/2009 05:19:07 AM 649 Views
not today - 27/10/2009 02:53:51 PM 999 Views
I liked your stack of books *NM* - 27/10/2009 02:29:41 PM 814 Views
Short Review/Thoughts - 29/10/2009 01:55:26 AM 1312 Views
I've been wondering the same thing. *NM* - 31/10/2009 03:53:02 PM 619 Views
My Review, very few spoilers - 02/11/2009 01:20:05 PM 1208 Views
OMFG!!! I have never felt so much! - 03/11/2009 09:50:02 AM 1275 Views
My review, spoilers. - 08/11/2009 02:02:35 PM 1129 Views
All in all, Very good. But... (spoilers!!) - 14/11/2009 07:09:13 PM 1281 Views
Very, truly happy - 24/11/2009 02:27:12 AM 1189 Views

Reply to Message