Of course, one could just say that SH was sloppy and didn't care about the access key, if Rand is captured.
SH says to Semirhage: "You were to capture the boy, not kill him." (Moridin states the same in the prologue) Then SH says that Semirhage has one last chance. Combining it, it's meant it is her last chance to capture Rand, and this is also how Semirhage understands SH's order; torturing Rand is just something Semirhage does, because she has the opportunity.
The problems I have with the DO's plan to force Rand to use the TP in the way you suggested are:
that Moridin likely wouldn't tell the DO anything about the bond before, because he might gain the mistrust of the DO; that Moridin couldn't know if Rand would be able to channel the TP via the bond; that Moridin couldn't know if Semirhage would really bring Rand in a situation, where he has to channel the TP, because her order simply was to capture Rand; and that the DO is a control freak, who doesn't know what will happen if the Creator's Champion channels the TP.
SH says to Semirhage: "You were to capture the boy, not kill him." (Moridin states the same in the prologue) Then SH says that Semirhage has one last chance. Combining it, it's meant it is her last chance to capture Rand, and this is also how Semirhage understands SH's order; torturing Rand is just something Semirhage does, because she has the opportunity.
The problems I have with the DO's plan to force Rand to use the TP in the way you suggested are:
that Moridin likely wouldn't tell the DO anything about the bond before, because he might gain the mistrust of the DO; that Moridin couldn't know if Rand would be able to channel the TP via the bond; that Moridin couldn't know if Semirhage would really bring Rand in a situation, where he has to channel the TP, because her order simply was to capture Rand; and that the DO is a control freak, who doesn't know what will happen if the Creator's Champion channels the TP.
Using the True Power
04/11/2009 05:54:35 PM
- 2434 Views
Very good research, but I have one big problem with your theory
04/11/2009 06:35:45 PM
- 830 Views
Good point with the access key
04/11/2009 06:56:16 PM
- 758 Views
I seriously doubt they knew Rand could or would draw on the TP. I think it was simply a fluke.
08/11/2009 09:49:36 AM
- 591 Views
you both make good points
05/11/2009 03:09:03 PM
- 593 Views
That is a good point as well...
05/11/2009 03:19:43 PM
- 534 Views
The DO definitely knows or he would not have supported the order to not kill Rand *NM*
08/11/2009 09:40:55 AM
- 350 Views