Active Users:1062 Time:23/12/2024 05:27:47 PM
It was a little fast, yes, but I think the basic psychological idea of it was sound. Legolas Send a noteboard - 31/10/2009 06:52:28 PM
The fact that she broke down so quickly and immediately was, I felt, completely unrealistic. If Semirhage's strength really lied in the fact that others viewed her inhuman, she would have never risen to her status in the first place. By using this method, one makes insignificant the fact that she was (I presume) a genius, incredibly powerful in the One Power and one of the foremost leaders in understanding human physiology--with an evil twist. If all that matters is how others view her, then Semirhage had no substance beneath her veil of power. And what I think the actual case is that the Forsaken are not simply veils of power: they are the cream of the crop, the pinnacle of cunning, power, and brutality. They have real power and skills.

This scene demonstrated that Semirhage is not the cream of the crop--that she's in fact a pathetic weakling who only finds strength in others' opinion of her. Such a character would never actually reach her status in the Wheel of Time.


It doesn't demonstrate any such thing. Let's not forget the constant keeping her awake and all that Cadsuane had been using prior to that point for a while, which will take its toll even on the most mentally stable people. There might also have been a factor of fearing the price of failure she'd pay eventually to the DO.

Other than that, it makes perfect sense that a high-achieving, ambitious person like Semirhage, with her ego only strengthened by her turning to the Shadow and the long imprisonment, would have pushed herself so far partially - of course only partially - because of the awe and respect (and later fear) of those around her. People like that have to have a theater to play for, much like politicians or high-level businessmen nowadays. By attacking her on that and treating her like a child, like someone less than most people instead of more, I think Cadsuane hit the nail on the head. The speed of it happening (keeping in mind however what preceded it) and the lack of subtlety in Sanderson's writing, well, there I could agree with you.
Reply to message
"Questions Of Control", pages 278-280 - 27/10/2009 05:26:53 PM 1133 Views
I was conflicted by it - 27/10/2009 06:48:09 PM 788 Views
Remind me what the paragraph was about? The spanking? *NM* - 27/10/2009 07:08:26 PM 306 Views
That be it. *NM* - 27/10/2009 07:09:39 PM 286 Views
I didn't find it funny... - 27/10/2009 07:28:16 PM 684 Views
It wasn't all that funny. I thought it rather obvious. *NM* - 28/10/2009 01:25:13 AM 287 Views
Totally agreed. The most disappointing scene I've read so far. *NM* - 28/10/2009 05:22:35 PM 268 Views
I actually hated this scene, I thought it was utterly unrealistic - 28/10/2009 05:20:29 PM 681 Views
Re: I actually hated this scene, I thought it was utterly unrealistic - 28/10/2009 07:35:48 PM 725 Views
IMO, you've simplified it a bit too much - 28/10/2009 08:24:33 PM 658 Views
I understand the reasons why Semi broke down - 28/10/2009 09:35:16 PM 603 Views
Actually... - 29/10/2009 05:37:53 PM 575 Views
It was a little fast, yes, but I think the basic psychological idea of it was sound. - 31/10/2009 06:52:28 PM 596 Views
I disagree. Semirhage has been famous her whole life.... - 15/11/2009 12:16:34 PM 586 Views
Good, but ENTIRELY too rushed. - 15/11/2009 12:26:03 PM 608 Views

Reply to Message