Active Users:595 Time:18/12/2024 11:19:41 PM
That's very interesting Cannoli Send a noteboard - 26/08/2016 06:06:38 PM

Lews Therin Telamon: The Wifeslayer.


... When I first noticed that it was happening way back when, I thought it might actually be a clue, but book after book passed, and... Nope.


WE get it already. The man loved his wife... Clearly everyone else there at the time was merely a case of false assumptions on Ishamael's part and mistaken identity. -_-


... Seriously. If you just skipped ever reading the prologue of EotW, you might very well come to believe the idea that anyone else was even there was just an embellishment of the legend.


IIRC they were married for something like 90 years, so their kids(and maybe even grandkids, and great grandkids at that) might of very well of been adults... But that only makes the fact that we know none of their names all the worse!


... And yet somehow, I feel worse for the poor "friends"... Yeah. They totally ranked being there... Close as brothers and sisters they were...

As strained as they might of gotten at points. I'm pretty sure that if Rand had killed Mat and Perrin... It would of come up at SOME point.

Compare some of the LTT fulled conversations with the freaking Forsaken...


I part of me rightly or wrongly wants to blame it on RJ himself not having kids... But honestly, even that REALLY doesn't excuse the fact that LTT was so laser guided in his ranting. Hell, while it was BS by that point, the books went so far as for Rand to have all of LTT's memories, and... Still. Nothing.


This, I think ties in with a general disappointment I have at the promised doom and danger not coming to pass. I'm not saying Rand should have been characterized as a dark anti-hero, I just think that there should have been a more clear vision of what was going on here. In the beginning of the series, as I said, there were hints of the Dragon Reborn being an object of hate and fear, due to his actually being a bringer of chaos and destruction. As Rand grew into the role by the middle books, that hate and fear seemed to mostly fall by the wayside, leaving him mostly facing ambition, greed and envy. The chaos and destruction, and the hate and fear directed at Rand, were pretty much incidental and in the background, and largely undeserved, as his actions did little to bring that stuff about, except in reaction to worse already done (i.e. the war with Couladin). And that foreboding is all basically dropped by the end, with no real attempts to tie it in to one of the relevant themes for the series, such as misunderstandings and evolution of perceptions through removal in time and distance from the events. Everyone was all buddies at the end as well. IMO, Gawyn's attitude, however misguided and particularly moronic, should have been, if not the majority opinion, a significant sentiment on the part of the wetlanders. There should have been a lot more guys fighting for the Light with that whole "It has to be done, but I really hate that asshole who left my family to die when he abandoned Arad Domon," only with more actions like Rand's (unfortunately) temporary abandonment of the Domani. Rand should have had to do a lot more cutting of losses, and consigning people to horrible fates out of necessity. People should have had to come to him, because the horror of their experiences made it clear that there was no acceptable choice but unity in the face the Shadow, not out of gratitude for yet another last minute rescue. Being offered the crown of Illian should have been the last public moment of appreciation or recognition Rand received prior to his funeral. And maybe there SHOULD have been the death of one of his love interests. Min or Elayne would probably work the best - Elayne, because it would have poisoned the well of his relationships with the other two; or Min, because she was the closest to his "normal" human side, and to a lesser degree might have had a similar negative effect on his other relationships, Elayne, over losing Min and Aviendha being closer at the time and more put off by the circumstances of her death (I'm thinking that her dying at his hand under Semirhage's control would have probably been the best way to work that into the story as it was). The post-Dragonmount sea change in his attitude might have been better too, with a touch of appropriate mourning and loss in there, instead of the uber-Rand who didn't really seem like he could lose, no matter what he might say to try to preserve the dramatic stakes over the final two books.

Cannoli
“Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions.” GK Chesteron
Inde muagdhe Aes Sedai misain ye!
Deus Vult!
*MySmiley*
Reply to message
Dead ends and disappointments in the series - 05/08/2016 03:37:13 AM 1486 Views
Let me think about this some more, but..... - 06/08/2016 10:24:07 PM 830 Views
Sanderson might be the answer to a lot of these - 09/08/2016 12:26:22 AM 939 Views
So the question is..... - 09/08/2016 04:42:17 AM 744 Views
Re: So the question is..... - 09/08/2016 11:18:57 PM 756 Views
A day late but here I go. - 19/08/2016 06:43:31 PM 780 Views
I updated my placeholder! Read it!... if there's 30m to spare. *NM* - 20/08/2016 08:47:50 PM 355 Views
I really thought this was going to happen too! *NM* - 01/09/2016 08:28:58 PM 345 Views
Trying to think of ones to add to the list, and the main one that comes to mind... - 26/08/2016 05:25:11 AM 708 Views
That's very interesting - 26/08/2016 06:06:38 PM 822 Views
The entire series ended up being a disappointment for me - 30/08/2016 03:15:40 AM 946 Views

Reply to Message