Active Users:659 Time:23/12/2024 03:51:00 AM
I've been silent because the Companion is a joke and hardly worth pointing out all the errors... Shannow Send a noteboard - 19/12/2015 09:37:53 AM

To Sid, in short, no, you can't make sense of the Companion's figures because it contradicts so much in the books. The Companion in general is poorly written, and has been torn apart by many knowledgeable fans of the series. And this stretches far beyond the One Power content.

Just a small list of contradictions with RJ's work, from memory:

Aviendha says Egwene is as strong as Amys and Melaine combined. Clearly a vast contradiction of the Companion's attempt to hash together a strength list.

Cadsuane is stated to be weaker than the wondergirls in the books - again, clearly contradicts the Companion.

Siuan is less than half her former strength after being Healed - this is stated by Leane herself in the books. Again, this clearly contradicts the Companion's so called strength list.

Further information from the books that discount this, is the fact that Rand can break free from a shield held by 3 sisters - and Logain could possibly break free from a shield held by 5. Contrary to Sid's theory, a man can not in fact break free from a female shield that exceeds 100% of his strength. In fact, he cannot even break free from a shield that is less than 100% of his strength. We know this because according to the Companion itself, Logain exceeds Nynaeve's strength, and yet he could not break free from her shield on him.

The fact that 6 sisters could not defeat a False Dragon on at least two occasions in the past, further emphasises the vast gulf between a Tier 1 or 2 channeler, and the average Aes Sedai.

The idea that Egwene is at 80% of Lanfear's strength does not fit at all with the books. Just like it is reaching in the extreme to theorize that when Egwene talks about matching a Forsaken, she is talking about being able to overwhelm that Forsaken with 200% of his or her strength.

No, Egwene is talking about overwhelming the actual strength of that Forsaken. Just like Nynaeve defeated Moghedien strength for strength.

This is confirmed by the fact that Egwene speaks about Nynaeve alone in the same way as she speaks about her, Romanda and Lelaine being able to face a male Forsaken. She says that no Aes Sedai except Nynaeve could match Moghedien. There is no reason to believe that she is referring to herself, Romanda and Lelaine being able to match a male Forsaken in any other way than how Nynaeve faced Moghedien.

The list goes on and I have grown kind of bored by this, after the Companion more than proved that its contributors had very little insight into RJ's true understanding of the One Power.

In short, they botched it. And badly so.

This message last edited by Shannow on 19/12/2015 at 09:46:44 AM
Reply to message
One Power strength: let's play with numbers - 18/12/2015 01:09:06 PM 2061 Views
Actually, I largely agree - 18/12/2015 03:33:27 PM 918 Views
Yup ... note how silent he's been since the Companion came out *NM* - 18/12/2015 05:50:44 PM 496 Views
I've been silent because the Companion is a joke and hardly worth pointing out all the errors... - 19/12/2015 09:37:53 AM 976 Views
Clearly there are mistakes in the Companion - 19/12/2015 03:28:49 PM 928 Views
- 19/12/2015 05:52:29 PM 901 Views
It is easy to accept the Companion. All you have to do is reject the evidence in the books. - 19/12/2015 06:58:41 PM 931 Views
No... - 19/12/2015 08:59:58 PM 921 Views
And let's not forget Mylen - 21/12/2015 09:07:27 PM 972 Views
Splitting flows: the Great Aes Sedai mixup - 22/12/2015 01:34:54 AM 1349 Views
Re: Splitting flows: the Great Aes Sedai mixup - 22/12/2015 06:05:02 AM 1049 Views
I have a theory on why - 23/12/2015 05:26:52 PM 761 Views
Re: I have a theory on why - 24/12/2015 09:44:44 AM 800 Views
How I see Traveling... - 24/12/2015 11:35:30 PM 851 Views
Re: How I see Traveling... - 26/12/2015 10:43:13 AM 845 Views
Re: How I see Traveling... - 29/12/2015 02:34:58 AM 841 Views
Re: How I see Traveling... - 30/12/2015 07:41:43 AM 959 Views
Re: How I see Traveling... - 01/01/2016 08:33:34 PM 843 Views
Some thoughts - 20/12/2015 09:29:28 AM 886 Views
My response to your thoughts... - 20/12/2015 07:19:15 PM 931 Views
My thoughts on your thoughts - 21/12/2015 02:34:38 PM 773 Views
Re: My thoughts on your thoughts - 21/12/2015 08:55:40 PM 850 Views
Re: Some thoughts - 22/12/2015 06:21:41 PM 984 Views
No palpitations here ... I pretty much agree with all of this *NM* - 18/12/2015 05:50:08 PM 457 Views
Well this is inconvenient - 19/12/2015 07:38:30 AM 791 Views
hahaha - 19/12/2015 03:09:41 PM 839 Views
Moraine and Siuan level in NS - 30/12/2015 02:13:05 AM 731 Views
Here are my thoughts - 30/12/2015 06:29:02 AM 805 Views
They were the same strength... - 30/12/2015 06:55:18 AM 873 Views
Thanks - 30/12/2015 07:44:22 AM 742 Views
Not really strange... - 30/12/2015 08:02:04 AM 869 Views
Siuan was also a wilder, she was sent to TV when the spark manifested - 30/12/2015 03:50:17 PM 823 Views
Not sure that works - 30/12/2015 07:17:27 AM 875 Views
Part of this is also about an individual's personality - 30/12/2015 04:40:28 PM 1098 Views
Re: Part of this is also about an individual's personality - 30/12/2015 05:10:50 PM 912 Views
Re: Part of this is also about an individual's personality - 30/12/2015 05:52:41 PM 875 Views
Re: Part of this is also about an individual's personality - 30/12/2015 06:15:36 PM 998 Views
Totally - 30/12/2015 06:46:14 PM 958 Views
On Rand and Ishamael - 01/01/2016 09:20:35 PM 774 Views
Re: On Rand and Ishamael - 02/01/2016 01:18:07 AM 699 Views
True - 02/01/2016 05:39:12 AM 879 Views
Re: True - 02/01/2016 07:52:33 PM 772 Views
Re: True - 02/01/2016 10:56:39 PM 855 Views
The more I look at this the more I think you are both right and wrong - 12/01/2016 09:02:57 PM 862 Views

Reply to Message