Active Users:1035 Time:18/12/2024 10:25:41 PM
There was bound to be changes of mind... DomA Send a noteboard - 13/11/2015 10:50:39 PM

Though after I saw those files, Terez and me argued quite a bit about when they were from (and it's very much open for debate, as many RJ files were partially updated only, retaining bits of outdated stuff). She tended to think it that the "plan" for Taim to be Demandred rather than being his pawn survived for some time beyond LOC before RJ finally changed his mind. I disagreed with her on that.

My opinion is that these two notes belong to the preparatory phase of LOC. They were true enough between TFOH and LOC, but were no longer his plan by the time LOC was finished. One of those quote concerns the rationale for how it ends (Rand's rescue by Taim) and the other concerns the resolution of Asmodean's murder, identifying Demandred as his killer.

I do not believe RJ stuck to that plan until the final published version of LOC, though I tend to believe he did write LOC with this in mind, then at the end he made cosmetic changes, notably to the prologue. The reason is the very same why we could easily eliminate Demandred as suspect in Asmodean's murder: in the LOC prologue, he doesn't know Asmodean is dead, it's the Dark One who reveals this to him.

The other argument is that in the final version of LOC, RJ rather set things up to send Osan'gar/Dashiva to the Black Tower, where he would oversee Taim yet would be forbidden to reveal to him that he was a Chosen and not a high rank DF (that bit in the Encyclopedia is indeed from the notes, not Harriet's interpretation or some such). That version is of course incompatible with Demandred being Taim, SH would not have sent a high ranking DF with Aginor's strength to openly "oversee" the guy Demandred portrays.

I think that RJ's original idea was for Demandred/Taim to play the role of Osan'gar, that is by having him take control of a retinue of male channelers who would eventually betray and attack Rand. I think the idea rapidly evolved in the process of plotting LOC into making Taim only Demandred's pawn at the Black Tower, but since the betrayal of Rand by his retinue was important, to introduce another player, Osan'gar, to be that traitor.

I think when RJ made that decision, many of the Taim chapters were already written, and he decided that the allusions that Taim might be Demandred he had put in there would work nicely as a red herring. In fact, I think he accentuated them even more (I would have expected Demandred to have enough self-control not to appear blatantly hateful and envious or enter pissing contests with Rand....). He did, however, polish the prologue of LOC to eliminate completely Demandred as a suspect in Asmodean's murder. Was it when he chose Graendal as the killer? We'll never know if the switch happened that early, but by the next book he began planting clues, and to eliminate other Chosen (Sammael, Semi, Mesaana) so that finally only Graendal was viable if the killer was a Forsaken.

I don't think RJ's motivation for canning Taimandred was that people "figured it out". The clues were too blatant, he had to know it would turn immediately into a popular theory. One possible motive is that he decided that he rather liked how Demandred (that he used as a character for the first time) played out in LOC as would-be leader of the survivors, the dynamic with Sem and Mesaana, and Granedal, and it's rather Sammael he would eliminate early. He opted for the best of both worlds, ie: he had Demandred pull Taim's strings instead, and that gave him the opportunity to develop Taim into a full wannabe Demandre with delusions of grandeur as to his real place in the Shadow.



Reply to message
Demandred, Taim and Asmodean - 13/11/2015 05:22:36 PM 3254 Views
Holy...SHIT! - 13/11/2015 07:12:08 PM 1833 Views
Yup...shocked, but hardly surprised. - 13/11/2015 08:12:54 PM 1377 Views
Thank you so much for revealing it - 13/11/2015 08:57:32 PM 1509 Views
I agree... - 13/11/2015 09:03:21 PM 1332 Views
Re: Holy...SHIT! - 18/11/2015 05:21:26 PM 1182 Views
Re: Demandred, Taim and Asmodean - 13/11/2015 07:15:14 PM 1455 Views
There was bound to be changes of mind... - 13/11/2015 10:50:39 PM 1978 Views
Hmmm... - 13/11/2015 11:59:41 PM 1287 Views
I just can't believe he was that lazy/sloppy in editing LOC. - 14/11/2015 12:29:47 AM 1729 Views
I thought Shara was begging to be noticed as a last minute foe. - 14/11/2015 02:46:42 AM 1482 Views
So did a lot of people. But... - 14/11/2015 05:27:27 AM 1440 Views
I still tend to think Demandred in Shara was Sanderson's creation - 16/11/2015 09:07:28 PM 1590 Views
He has pretty much admitted as much publicly. - 17/11/2015 03:14:19 AM 1404 Views
Agreed. In fact.. - 17/11/2015 03:19:20 AM 1277 Views
Re: I still tend to think Demandred in Shara was Sanderson's creation - 17/11/2015 05:08:58 PM 1174 Views
One more comment on the timing - 21/11/2015 04:29:02 PM 1353 Views
I don't get the Nynaeve note - 14/11/2015 02:32:28 AM 1624 Views
There are a lot of inexplicable notes like this. - 14/11/2015 06:33:11 AM 1487 Views
Nynaeve was one of the few who met the original Balthamel and Aginor - 17/11/2015 08:46:43 PM 1222 Views
Re: Nynaeve was one of the few who met the original Balthamel and Aginor - 17/11/2015 09:33:34 PM 1051 Views
It's interesting that stopping Taimandred coincided with the drop in series quality. - 16/11/2015 05:02:38 AM 1829 Views
Some of this could have been interesting - 16/11/2015 04:37:00 PM 1425 Views
It would take away from Verin though - 16/11/2015 05:05:41 PM 989 Views
That is a good point - 16/11/2015 08:52:37 PM 1063 Views
For the record my suggestion was not that he was a mole - 17/11/2015 01:56:41 AM 1205 Views
that was clear in your post - 19/11/2015 05:36:02 PM 1066 Views
Sanderson certainly did that - 20/11/2015 05:08:03 PM 1229 Views
I don't think I would have cared for that - 20/11/2015 06:05:19 PM 1169 Views
It didn't necessarily have to be "dark", just a bit less two-dimensional. - 20/11/2015 10:00:59 PM 1168 Views
I mostly agree - 21/11/2015 06:38:31 AM 1060 Views
This I can agree with - 23/11/2015 04:12:19 PM 1004 Views
I don't read a ton of fantasy anymore - 23/11/2015 04:29:47 PM 1360 Views

Reply to Message