Active Users:1122 Time:22/11/2024 11:01:33 PM
Re: Let me confirm what you are suggesting, to avoid attacking any strawmen... fionwe1987 Send a noteboard - 10/09/2015 07:54:06 PM

View original post
So regarding the Siuan/Leanne situation. Are you actually proposing that Leane was referring to the numerical strength level she is now at, rather than to the amount of Power she can now channel?

In other words, when she says she is less than half as "strong" as she was before, are you trying to suggest she was not referring to absolute strength, but instead to her numerical position on a scale which only includes Aes Sedai?

It is important that you clarify this, because if this is seriously your contention then it is a position that is easily refuted. But first I want to clarify if that is indeed your argument.


Not the actual numbers of these levels. I don't think the Aes Sedai have actual numbers for these levels, but they are the people most acutely aware of them.

Now, I'm not saying the sentence cannot be read the way you read it. I'm saying, however, that since extra-textual sources (RJ's notes) are very clear the levels have a linear progression, and that therefore there is no way for Siuan (or Leane as the case is here) to lose a third of their strength in terms of bulk quantities of the Power they could use.

What we then have to do is either treat it as a mistake or interpret it with in line with the superseding information from the guide.

This seems to have always been the tension here. You have always chosen to ignore the supremacy of RJ's own statements and only use your interpretation of the text. I let my interpretation be swayed by what the author says.

Reply to message
When Elaida was made to feel like a Novice and other stories of Amyrlin Seats (SPOILERS) - 10/09/2015 03:42:07 AM 1047 Views
And here we have more proof that the Strength list is either flawed, or not a linear distributition - 10/09/2015 09:22:07 AM 790 Views
Did you not read the strength in the OP article? - 10/09/2015 02:52:33 PM 842 Views
Let me confirm what you are suggesting, to avoid attacking any strawmen... - 10/09/2015 07:17:01 PM 985 Views
Re: Let me confirm what you are suggesting, to avoid attacking any strawmen... - 10/09/2015 07:54:06 PM 663 Views
Re: Let me confirm what you are suggesting, to avoid attacking any strawmen... - 10/09/2015 09:45:40 PM 812 Views
Wasn't female linking supposed to be the equalizing factor ? - 13/09/2015 08:47:36 AM 915 Views
Re: Wasn't female linking supposed to be the equalizing factor ? - 13/09/2015 03:55:21 PM 830 Views
DP - 10/09/2015 09:22:22 AM 618 Views

Reply to Message