Active Users:1121 Time:22/11/2024 03:15:55 PM
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules
Birgitte is too cautious to be better than an adequate tactician. RabidWombat Send a noteboard - 02/10/2009 04:22:45 AM
All three are pretty good military tacticians. And I imagine Tuon wouldn't be too bad either. I would imagine that there are also other female generals amongst the Seanchan, but we haven't seen them. In the westlands soldering is pretty much a male dominated occupation.

NaCl(just because we haven't seen them doesn't mean they aren't there)H2O


I disagree about Birgitte at least partially. Being a good general has three parts: leadership and morale, logistics and organization, and tactics. There is strong evidence that she is great at the first two. But her tactics are not that great.

You laud her for rescuing Elayne in another post, but she lost a lot of men doing it. A lot more then she needed. Any of the better generals would have found a way to place a number of hidden archers or kin to wipe out the BA with little or no loss. Further, Birgitte did not recognize the tactical advantage of trapping Arymilla against the gates. True, it was risky since there was another army in the field. It was a risk worth taking, though. Knowing which risks can be taken or need to be taken is what makes an average general great.

Together, Birgitte and Elayne make a formidable combination although not near the top tier. I wouldn't rate Birgitte by herself that high, though.

Like you I believe there are a number of women capable of being at least a good General. In addition to your list it would not surprise me if there were some veteran Maidens and more then a handful of Greens who could rise to the task of being a General, at least tactically, if they were called to do it. (Mat admitted that Joline knew about war for instance.) Elayne probably could be an adequate General in a pinch as well. (Although I probably should have counted her as one of those handful of Greens.)

The best chance of finding a great female general is still the Seanchen, though, as you mentioned.

RabidWombat
Reply to message
Are women really bad generals? Sidious - 01/10/2009 07:05:03 PM 1447 Views
I think that all we can conclude from this... Rand al'Thor - 01/10/2009 07:39:49 PM 742 Views
No. RugbyPlayingAshaman - 01/10/2009 07:41:35 PM 860 Views
Or RJ just loves stacking ridiculously unfavourable odds against the male Forsaken generals... Shannow - 01/10/2009 08:40:47 PM 961 Views
Lol... too true Sidious - 01/10/2009 09:32:29 PM 857 Views
And you guys whine about the lameness of RJ's villains? fionwe1987 - 01/10/2009 09:41:54 PM 846 Views
I still haven't seen proof of Demandred or Ishamael's "brilliance". RugbyPlayingAshaman - 01/10/2009 09:56:41 PM 698 Views
Ishamael's destroyed Civilization twice Rurouni_Kenshin - 02/10/2009 04:25:37 AM 669 Views
Re: Ishamael's destroyed Civilization twice RugbyPlayingAshaman - 02/10/2009 03:48:13 PM 594 Views
but you are difficult to please Sidious - 02/10/2009 05:10:13 AM 652 Views
Re: but you are difficult to please RugbyPlayingAshaman - 02/10/2009 03:46:56 PM 589 Views
Re: but you are difficult to please Sidious - 03/10/2009 06:17:21 AM 608 Views
But they are lame... they've done minimal damage to the Light Sidious - 02/10/2009 05:06:05 AM 599 Views
You can't have it both ways.... fionwe1987 - 02/10/2009 06:47:21 AM 680 Views
Why not? Sidious - 02/10/2009 08:45:35 AM 641 Views
Re: Why not? fionwe1987 - 02/10/2009 04:27:00 PM 540 Views
Re: Why not? Sidious - 03/10/2009 06:34:16 AM 677 Views
Re: Why not? fionwe1987 - 03/10/2009 07:40:16 AM 612 Views
Re: Why not? Sidious - 03/10/2009 05:07:51 PM 583 Views
Yeah Etzel - 01/10/2009 09:57:01 PM 627 Views
Re: Yeah nossy - 01/10/2009 10:40:28 PM 658 Views
I thought the same in the past... Etzel - 02/10/2009 07:01:18 AM 651 Views
Gah! Hate! nossy - 02/10/2009 04:11:49 PM 658 Views
Ah, come on... Etzel - 02/10/2009 04:41:37 PM 625 Views
No no, I was just being pouty that I haven't read the new stuff yet. nossy - 02/10/2009 05:01:15 PM 627 Views
Yeah, I can understand that! Etzel - 03/10/2009 12:23:25 PM 507 Views
Unless... Fanatic-Templar - 01/10/2009 10:49:55 PM 700 Views
Re: Unless... Sidious - 02/10/2009 05:07:14 AM 729 Views
Well, it's entirely hypothetical, Fanatic-Templar - 02/10/2009 06:31:32 AM 605 Views
Re: Or RJ just loves stacking ridiculously unfavourable odds against the male Forsaken generals... RugbyPlayingAshaman - 01/10/2009 09:51:30 PM 724 Views
What about Mat and Ituralde? Rurouni_Kenshin - 02/10/2009 04:28:49 AM 667 Views
Re: What about Mat and Ituralde? RugbyPlayingAshaman - 02/10/2009 03:52:24 PM 622 Views
Good points! Also, these "generals" haven't actually fielded any troops beetnemesis - 01/10/2009 11:23:40 PM 603 Views
Further... RugbyPlayingAshaman - 02/10/2009 12:14:44 AM 637 Views
But as individuals they are meant to be deadly too Sidious - 02/10/2009 05:09:21 AM 594 Views
Just one point ^_^ RugbyPlayingAshaman - 03/10/2009 12:51:50 AM 609 Views
Well, yeah. They're knowledgable and deadly in person. Generalship doesn't come into it. beetnemesis - 04/10/2009 12:09:50 AM 569 Views
nope nossy - 01/10/2009 08:06:57 PM 752 Views
Re: nope Sidious - 01/10/2009 09:32:38 PM 816 Views
Tylee Kirgan, Birgitte, and one other, Egeanin NaClH2O - 01/10/2009 09:47:00 PM 1023 Views
Birgitte's not a soldier though. Darth_Katie - 01/10/2009 10:10:50 PM 611 Views
She says she's not, but so does Mat. nossy - 01/10/2009 10:34:04 PM 535 Views
Mat's not a soldier, either - he's a general RugbyPlayingAshaman - 01/10/2009 10:51:29 PM 680 Views
Right, which was what we were discussing at first. nossy - 02/10/2009 04:13:43 PM 606 Views
Yeah, I'm supporting your point about them both being generals RugbyPlayingAshaman - 02/10/2009 06:10:31 PM 625 Views
true, but she does pretty good NaClH2O - 02/10/2009 01:06:03 AM 678 Views
Oooh I forgot she's in charge of Elayne's lady guards. Darth_Katie - 02/10/2009 03:22:57 AM 551 Views
Egeanin or Leilwin nossy - 01/10/2009 10:35:53 PM 747 Views
A ship captain is like a calvary general NaClH2O - 02/10/2009 01:24:37 AM 613 Views
Right. Cannoli - 02/10/2009 01:36:59 AM 596 Views
Well said. (And its short and to the point.) RabidWombat - 02/10/2009 03:54:23 AM 734 Views
Birgitte is too cautious to be better than an adequate tactician. RabidWombat - 02/10/2009 04:22:45 AM 661 Views
Isn't this more of an outgrowth or her respective specialty? RugbyPlayingAshaman - 07/10/2009 08:40:46 PM 567 Views
My opinion Cannoli - 02/10/2009 01:30:12 AM 1034 Views
That's a poor excuse rAndy aL - 02/10/2009 11:59:42 AM 562 Views
That's a poor argument Cannoli - 02/10/2009 04:02:53 PM 763 Views
Re: That's a poor argument rAndy aL - 03/10/2009 04:26:55 AM 638 Views
I disagree nossy - 02/10/2009 04:26:28 PM 653 Views
Re: I disagree Cannoli - 02/10/2009 08:31:29 PM 850 Views
Oh, puh-lease. nossy - 02/10/2009 09:09:30 PM 801 Views
Re: Oh, puh-lease. Cannoli - 03/10/2009 04:52:37 PM 630 Views
Re: Oh, puh-lease. NaClH2O - 03/10/2009 08:26:27 PM 520 Views
Re: Oh, puh-lease. nossy - 05/10/2009 05:08:27 PM 3077 Views
I always know I've out-argued an idiot when they fall back on the tired old "RJ wanted it that way" Cannoli - 06/10/2009 04:42:11 AM 667 Views
And I can tell you're through when you've gotten to three+ insults per paragraph. nossy - 06/10/2009 05:46:24 PM 760 Views
um nossy - 08/10/2009 07:36:52 PM 903 Views
Monday morning quarterbacking at its worst RabidWombat - 04/10/2009 07:28:36 AM 717 Views
Men and football. nossy - 05/10/2009 04:49:35 PM 634 Views
She didn't kill anyone! Why SHOULD she feel guilty? She gave necessary orders. Cannoli - 06/10/2009 03:33:15 AM 726 Views
It's the only thing men are allowed to do in Randland CupofDice - 02/10/2009 03:09:19 AM 644 Views
My thoughts LordPerrin - 02/10/2009 03:12:46 PM 575 Views
.... Fantasy - 04/10/2009 03:38:44 AM 562 Views
Back to Messageboard Post New Thread Search Help Stats Rules

Reply to Message

Block Quote Paragraph Quote
Formatting
Smiley Codes