Precious few series have been satisfactorily completed by their original authors
Isaac Send a noteboard - 02/02/2013 06:13:49 AM
I think people get unrealistic expectations of long series that don't have breaking points, as opposed to when an author spews out a book or trilogy, wraps most things up then starts over.
Anyway there aren't really that many series that suffered "Author Existence Failure" quite this way. Most wrapped the series up and had been pondering some extensions - like Douglas Adams Hitchiker's Guide, Roger Zelazny's Amber, Herbert's Dune, or Asimov's Foundation - rather than really having a series left undone, a few loose threads and teasers not really counting.
Personally I'd say it works better when the author built a big multi-character and flushed out world, because then follow up authors can simply pick a fairly secondary or new character and have original main characters show up for cameo's or mentions. Harder to do with more character driven books, especially when they center mostly on one or a small handful of main characters. I don't think anyone would have much problems writing in Niven's Known Space series for instance or McCaffrey's Pern, and there are tons of settings like Star Trek, Star Wars, Star Gate, Warhammer 40k or Doctor Who where the original author/creator isn't even universally agreed to be the 'best one', albeit none of those are famous for their quality.
So I'd say the answer is a 'kinda sort yes'
Anyway there aren't really that many series that suffered "Author Existence Failure" quite this way. Most wrapped the series up and had been pondering some extensions - like Douglas Adams Hitchiker's Guide, Roger Zelazny's Amber, Herbert's Dune, or Asimov's Foundation - rather than really having a series left undone, a few loose threads and teasers not really counting.
Personally I'd say it works better when the author built a big multi-character and flushed out world, because then follow up authors can simply pick a fairly secondary or new character and have original main characters show up for cameo's or mentions. Harder to do with more character driven books, especially when they center mostly on one or a small handful of main characters. I don't think anyone would have much problems writing in Niven's Known Space series for instance or McCaffrey's Pern, and there are tons of settings like Star Trek, Star Wars, Star Gate, Warhammer 40k or Doctor Who where the original author/creator isn't even universally agreed to be the 'best one', albeit none of those are famous for their quality.
So I'd say the answer is a 'kinda sort yes'
The intuitive mind is a sacred gift and the rational mind is a faithful servant. We have created a society that honors the servant and has forgotten the gift.
- Albert Einstein
King of Cairhien 20-7-2
Chancellor of the Landsraad, Archduke of Is'Mod
- Albert Einstein
King of Cairhien 20-7-2
Chancellor of the Landsraad, Archduke of Is'Mod
I rarely spread this sort of gossip, but this is an interesting Twitter stream from a former DM mod
29/01/2013 08:52:33 PM
- 2542 Views
What a douchebag *NM*
29/01/2013 09:09:58 PM
- 513 Views
Agreed. He hasn't treated Sanderson with anything close to the respect that Sanderson has shown him *NM*
29/01/2013 09:42:37 PM
- 488 Views
I agree with everything Luckerz says in this post (link provided)
29/01/2013 10:28:11 PM
- 1124 Views
Out of interest, has an unfinished series ever been satisfactorily completed by a surrogate writer? *NM*
01/02/2013 12:20:24 AM
- 472 Views
Precious few series have been satisfactorily completed by their original authors
02/02/2013 06:13:49 AM
- 876 Views