Sorry, but it's not utterly incorrect. You can no more disprove it than I can prove it
muppet Send a noteboard - 31/01/2013 01:49:11 PM
While I agree that Rand's ability is an evolutionary next step in *human* use of the OP, I don't agree with you on why that is. I think the possibility has been there all along, but it took Rand's journey and enlightenment to discover it. I don't think it's simply because he's now been "knighted" by the Creator for being such a swell guy, or whatever.
There are clear limits defined by the culture of channeling, which every POV character believes are hard limits. This may or may not necessarily mean that these beliefs are true in all situations. Since we don't have an omniscient narrator anywhere in the WoT, we can't say for certain.
I disagree that simple death is equivalent to the death of one's entire world, their potential of reincarnation, and that of all of their neighbors and children. I think it's very feasible that a Light-side channeler at Shayol Gul during the Last Battle could be more stressed than Aginor at the EotW.
The "rules" have only been told to us by the characters, throughout. We don't really know what they are. What Rand did violates all of those rules, and RJ wrote that. There are also other phenomenon in Randland that RJ wrote that don't mesh with the OP, like Elyas. The POV characters write this off as "not being a thing of the OP" because it doesn't mesh, but that doesn't mean they're correct. That's the loophole you end up with when all of your narrative comes from POV characters.
There are clear limits defined by the culture of channeling, which every POV character believes are hard limits. This may or may not necessarily mean that these beliefs are true in all situations. Since we don't have an omniscient narrator anywhere in the WoT, we can't say for certain.
I disagree that simple death is equivalent to the death of one's entire world, their potential of reincarnation, and that of all of their neighbors and children. I think it's very feasible that a Light-side channeler at Shayol Gul during the Last Battle could be more stressed than Aginor at the EotW.
The "rules" have only been told to us by the characters, throughout. We don't really know what they are. What Rand did violates all of those rules, and RJ wrote that. There are also other phenomenon in Randland that RJ wrote that don't mesh with the OP, like Elyas. The POV characters write this off as "not being a thing of the OP" because it doesn't mesh, but that doesn't mean they're correct. That's the loophole you end up with when all of your narrative comes from POV characters.
The One Power: Sanderson's serious lack of understanding of the concept...
31/01/2013 08:57:24 AM
- 1607 Views
Re: The One Power: Sanderson's serious lack of understanding of the concept...
31/01/2013 01:28:07 PM
- 941 Views
That is utterly incorrect. Rand's case is an evolutionary next step which doesn't apply in general..
31/01/2013 01:42:09 PM
- 864 Views
Sorry, but it's not utterly incorrect. You can no more disprove it than I can prove it
31/01/2013 01:49:11 PM
- 917 Views
Channelers physically burn out when they exceed their limits. That's the proof.
31/01/2013 01:52:50 PM
- 693 Views
Re: Channelers physically burn out when they exceed their limits. That's the proof.
31/01/2013 01:58:17 PM
- 793 Views
Sorry. But that is simply an escape clause for Sanderson to change whatever rules he wants...
31/01/2013 01:59:29 PM
- 798 Views
Re: Sorry. But that is simply an escape clause for Sanderson to change whatever rules he wants...
31/01/2013 02:11:26 PM
- 804 Views
No, he did a crap job
31/01/2013 02:19:18 PM
- 717 Views
Re: No, he did a crap job
31/01/2013 02:20:33 PM
- 647 Views
Your level of satisfaction will inversely correlate to your depth of understanding of the nuances...
31/01/2013 02:24:09 PM
- 675 Views
LMAO
31/01/2013 02:46:11 PM
- 729 Views
As to that...
31/01/2013 02:55:14 PM
- 752 Views
Primilary because I don't necessarily see it as an inconsistency in the way that you do
31/01/2013 02:58:45 PM
- 838 Views
Also the number of times Forsaken level channelers flung protagonists around with "Air weaves"...
31/01/2013 02:18:05 PM
- 848 Views
Re: The One Power: Sanderson's serious lack of understanding of the concept...
05/02/2013 02:54:58 PM
- 799 Views