Active Users:1067 Time:22/11/2024 11:12:31 AM
WTF? Demandred fighting people with SWORDS? How utterly ludicrous is that. Shannow Send a noteboard - 31/01/2013 06:58:00 AM
Demandred was finally revealed as Bao the Wyld, a Sharan man of great power and prophecy. That said, what did you think of Demandred? Here are my thoughts...

Personally I thought Demandred was spectacular and well captured by Brandon Sanderson. People have been very cynical regarding his hidden identity and that nothing could make up for his revelation no matter who he was. I don't really agree. I felt that way prior to reading AMOL and when he was revealed he was magnificent.

As a character, I thought he was one of the most imposing of all of the Forsaken to date. I loved the way he spoke and enjoyed reading everything he had to say, especially how he dripped knowledge from the AOL and how he explained his feelings on so many issues. As expected he appeared in a fantastic suit of armour on a white steed, and was worshiped by his army as some sort of saviour/demigod.

He was set up as one of the great generals of the Shadow and didn't fail to disappoint. Only Mat could really match him, though Demandred did owe a portion of his success to the catastrophe that Graendal caused among the great captains. Brandon reflected his intelligence and cunning well. I felt you could really see why he was one of the greatest men from the AOL - I often felt that there was nothing that could defeat him, and that he could adapt to anything.

In a similar vane, I found him hugely impressive as a channeler - far more than I thought he would be after his mediocre performance at the Cleansing. Demandred must have personally killed a hundred thousand people in that battle. I loved how he utterly humiliated (and almost killed) Taim using complex weaves of the True Power, with an almost indifferent attitude and a marvelous speech while he was doing it. His duel with Logain was similarly impressive, using weaves that Logain couldn't understand or penetrate. It was fantastic. I enjoyed small things, like how he meditated to fend off the exhaustion from channeling, how he could bind a sa'angreal to him, pulling Aes Sedai out of the darkness, calling his enemies 'little people' all the time etc...

It was also good to see his skill with the sword, and how no one could surpass his skill. His duel with Gawyn was excellent because he killed the idiot, and that is a worthy accomplishment. Even the Aes Sedai were glad that he died. His battle with Galad was more impressive and I liked their banter. Brandon built Demandred up so much, that I didn't feel let down that Lan finally killed him, especially because it was plausible. Lan has always been the greatest swordsman in WoT, he's cool, he has a ter'angreal, and most importantly he went after Demandred so aggressively that he couldn't channel without dying. Lan also had to sacrifice himself to defeat Demandred.

I liked how Brandon portrayed Demandred's insanity and obsession. He was so hateful and focussed on LTT that he could barely think of anything else. Many characters remarked on it. The man was truly disabled and limited by his hatred. Rand, meanwhile, never thought about Demandred after Merrilor (even Moridin irritated him). We got a glimpse as to what a great man he would have been had he not turned i.e. leader, comrade, lover, but it was all smothered by this one singular goal that he blurted out across the battlefield with saidin. Even Mat thought he was insane.

Lastly, I enjoyed how Moghedien bounced up to replace him. She's always been a source of amusement. From when she burned his body, to her illusion to imitate him (she thus sent the 100,000 trollocs btw), was excellent - until a legion of canons fired at her through a gateway of course. Her facial expression must have been priceless, I hope the Ash'aman took a picture.

Overall, I'm not sure if it was a mistake leaving Demandred until the last book. We did see him in book 6 and 9, so we can't complain too much and he was a virulent villain in AMOL (alongside Graendal - the woman is a demon). I'd give him a solid 9/10, and I only rate Graendal above him overall in the series.


My first post after a marathon skim reading session through the night after picking up aMoL yesterday afternoon.

Verdict: I want my money back.

So Demandred's total contribution amounted to sitting on a hiltop and channeling vast amounts of the Power through a powerful sa'angreal that had magically appeared at the last minute.

Sanderson is simply an atrocious writer.

Demandred engages in no less than 3 SWORDFIGHTS with 3 blademaster equivalents, when he has NEVER alluded to any skill with a sword. Sammael was the world champion swordsman, with Be'lal the other Blademaster among the Forsaken. Demandred was a statesman, top class channeler and battle strategist.

And he ends up fighting 3 consecutive duels with 3 of the top swordsmen in Randland?

Ridiculous. Utterly ridiculous.

As for Bao the Wyld, well, that was better than him just turning out to be Roedran, but seriously, Sanderson could have written it so much better.

Demandred ended up being impressive yes, but Sanderson went about it in entirely the wrong way. He made him some kind of Palpatine figure, cackling madly as he casually anihilates huge swathes of enemies with unimaginable bursts of power.

Only to engage in one on one swordfights at random moments when he shouldn't even be able to know how to hold a sword.

In the end he turned into a slightly less insane, somewhat strategically superior version of Moridin. Another caricature of a powermad boss-villain in your standard RPG computer game.

After the big gateway that brought in the Sharans, there were no more suprises from him. Just wave upon wave of over the top awesome, repetitive waves of Power uber-badassness.

I would have powered him down significantly (ie not have given him the magically appearing sa'angreal with no explanation for its origin, unless I missed it in my skim read).

I would have had him move around more instead of sitting on a white horse mumbling insane challenges that were more appropriate for the gibbering Aginor than the measured, coldly calculating Demandred.

I understand that Sanderson wanted Demandred's secret to pay off big time in the end. And Demandred did essentially keep the entire light side and virtually all of its combined heroes busy for half the book, but the way in which it was written was just poor, poor, poor.

Like the entire rest of the book.

Reply to message
Demandred : a review - 28/01/2013 04:44:37 PM 2587 Views
I have a man crush on him - 29/01/2013 12:26:09 AM 1083 Views
Uh, no not quite - 30/01/2013 05:53:47 PM 1043 Views
He had so much potential and even showed some of it - 29/01/2013 09:37:46 PM 861 Views
It's easy to look like a great general - 30/01/2013 01:33:33 AM 865 Views
Give credit to Demandred for setting the stage - 30/01/2013 01:49:41 PM 856 Views
He didn't set the stage, Matt did. - 30/01/2013 05:59:32 PM 754 Views
Re: He didn't set the stage, Matt did. - 31/01/2013 12:09:33 AM 894 Views
I meant he set Moghedien up as a spy. And he set up the Sharan ambush. And Taim's betrayal - 31/01/2013 02:23:52 AM 750 Views
He may have been, but it was never displayed. - 31/01/2013 06:41:57 PM 783 Views
I'm not sure how much of it was really Moghedien - 30/01/2013 02:55:00 PM 851 Views
I actually have a problem with the sword fights - 30/01/2013 05:33:30 PM 912 Views
Re: I actually have a problem with the sword fights - 31/01/2013 12:15:09 AM 881 Views
Desperation can't explain it. - 31/01/2013 06:47:47 PM 731 Views
WTF? Demandred fighting people with SWORDS? How utterly ludicrous is that. - 31/01/2013 06:58:00 AM 4880 Views
It seems like many of the male Forsaken are blademasters - 31/01/2013 08:02:39 AM 1508 Views
I'm just glad that in the end he wasn't out generalled by Mat... - 31/01/2013 08:10:37 AM 1020 Views
Mat had Demandred outwitted... - 31/01/2013 08:50:59 AM 855 Views

Reply to Message