"Totally unimpressed" would be a hyperbole but...
eucatastrophe Send a noteboard - 09/01/2013 06:53:20 PM
Yeah, the book feels somewhat underwhelming. Maybe it's natural for one to feel this way: Can one book (even at 1000+ pages) provide a satisfying ending to a series spanning 13 books* with each of those tomes at 1000+ pages?
I liked the over all ideas presented in the book. Sanderson's language has never bothered/irritated me as it does some people but there were sections where the writing felt wrong. Not a huge issue for me, but still worth mentioning. The book focused way too much on the Trollocs and the war scenes - we get it, the Trolloc invasion is horrible - when the characters should have been at the heart of the matter. It's sort of like Return of the King in which the battle of the Pelennor Fields was so dragged out. The scenes in the movie were great - and Sanderson's battle scenes are enjoyable - but they felt so exhausting. No one cares for Trolloc Wars: Randland Boogaloo (well I didn't). I wanted more character interaction.
This book felt like a summer blockbuster. This has nothing to do with high-brow literature vs. pulpy crap (as some posters have implied here) and everything to do with good storytelling. AMoL left me with a lot to be desired as far as the characters went.
I'd say it was overall a good read (especially after ToM which was atrocious) but I still liked TGS better. Books 1 to 6 stand strongest.
*can't really fault Brandon Sanderson for this; ending this series was going to be a nightmare since RJ continued to spin plot after plot as far as he did. It's strange to think that he intended to tie up threads in one book when in reality, we needed TGS, ToM and AMoL to conclude the story.
PS. Oh the only thing that really felt like utter fucking shit was Moiraine. Why even bother to bring her back? What a fucking joke. Min could have fulfilled that purpose. Any random Brown sister could have. It's even more idiotic when you think about it: She addresses world leaders, Aes Sedai, Borderlanders with her little spiel (scraps found at the start of every book) - PEOPLE WHO SHOULD KNOW THIS STUFF! The Borderlanders (who pay attention to their own secret prophecies) and the Aes Sedai anyway. If they needed a "reminder" to trudge the damn plot along, any other character would have done it. It's pathetically amusing now that one looks back: so many theories on the importance of Moiraine (whom I adore btw) - that she'd uncover secret knowledge from the Finns or have a crucial keystone in the fight against the DO. She doesn't even do anything in the Pit of Doom, LOL! Is that angreal - the one that got considerable screentime in TFoH and TGS - of hers even mentioned?
Fucking waste. She should have stayed dead; what an insult to her character.
PPS. While I loved Androl's plot it felt so out of place in this book. I think this can be attested to RJ stupidly spinning myriad plots till the nth hour. It felt like KOD/TGS/ToM material to me.
I liked the over all ideas presented in the book. Sanderson's language has never bothered/irritated me as it does some people but there were sections where the writing felt wrong. Not a huge issue for me, but still worth mentioning. The book focused way too much on the Trollocs and the war scenes - we get it, the Trolloc invasion is horrible - when the characters should have been at the heart of the matter. It's sort of like Return of the King in which the battle of the Pelennor Fields was so dragged out. The scenes in the movie were great - and Sanderson's battle scenes are enjoyable - but they felt so exhausting. No one cares for Trolloc Wars: Randland Boogaloo (well I didn't). I wanted more character interaction.
This book felt like a summer blockbuster. This has nothing to do with high-brow literature vs. pulpy crap (as some posters have implied here) and everything to do with good storytelling. AMoL left me with a lot to be desired as far as the characters went.
I'd say it was overall a good read (especially after ToM which was atrocious) but I still liked TGS better. Books 1 to 6 stand strongest.
*can't really fault Brandon Sanderson for this; ending this series was going to be a nightmare since RJ continued to spin plot after plot as far as he did. It's strange to think that he intended to tie up threads in one book when in reality, we needed TGS, ToM and AMoL to conclude the story.
PS. Oh the only thing that really felt like utter fucking shit was Moiraine. Why even bother to bring her back? What a fucking joke. Min could have fulfilled that purpose. Any random Brown sister could have. It's even more idiotic when you think about it: She addresses world leaders, Aes Sedai, Borderlanders with her little spiel (scraps found at the start of every book) - PEOPLE WHO SHOULD KNOW THIS STUFF! The Borderlanders (who pay attention to their own secret prophecies) and the Aes Sedai anyway. If they needed a "reminder" to trudge the damn plot along, any other character would have done it. It's pathetically amusing now that one looks back: so many theories on the importance of Moiraine (whom I adore btw) - that she'd uncover secret knowledge from the Finns or have a crucial keystone in the fight against the DO. She doesn't even do anything in the Pit of Doom, LOL! Is that angreal - the one that got considerable screentime in TFoH and TGS - of hers even mentioned?
Fucking waste. She should have stayed dead; what an insult to her character.
PPS. While I loved Androl's plot it felt so out of place in this book. I think this can be attested to RJ stupidly spinning myriad plots till the nth hour. It felt like KOD/TGS/ToM material to me.
This message last edited by eucatastrophe on 09/01/2013 at 07:03:04 PM
Anyone else totally unimpressed?
09/01/2013 04:58:39 AM
- 2125 Views
I couldn't disagree more
09/01/2013 05:32:41 AM
- 1080 Views
I enjoyed the book as entertainment
09/01/2013 05:47:22 AM
- 1013 Views
I found the ongoing Trolloc killing a bit tedious.
09/01/2013 06:14:25 AM
- 875 Views
Re: I found the ongoing Trolloc killing a bit tedious.
29/01/2013 11:01:11 AM
- 777 Views
I had extremely low expectations, which I guess were sort of met.
09/01/2013 06:12:05 AM
- 1105 Views
Mine weren't, even with the low expectations
09/01/2013 05:04:07 PM
- 1228 Views
I don't remember you being such an arrogant prick years ago on WoTmania
11/01/2013 05:28:07 AM
- 914 Views
Pardon, but I don't even recall who you are *NM*
11/01/2013 08:39:54 AM
- 475 Views
You are a...
18/01/2013 08:21:54 AM
- 871 Views
Uh...
18/01/2013 12:19:13 PM
- 893 Views
Rather...
18/01/2013 09:11:11 PM
- 873 Views
Why does any of this matter to you?
18/01/2013 10:35:18 PM
- 950 Views
Oh sure...
19/01/2013 06:43:19 AM
- 757 Views
No, not quite
19/01/2013 08:57:47 AM
- 818 Views
LoL @ Larry
19/01/2013 09:21:13 PM
- 744 Views
Ummm....
19/01/2013 10:05:30 PM
- 808 Views
That was a dodge.
20/01/2013 01:40:59 AM
- 801 Views
Nah, more like me cutting this short.
20/01/2013 02:30:28 AM
- 798 Views
I thought it was fantastic
09/01/2013 07:46:16 AM
- 998 Views
I'm surprised you are so happy with it. It was action packed, but sloppy. Usually you dislike that
20/01/2013 01:55:17 AM
- 819 Views
"Totally unimpressed" would be a hyperbole but...
09/01/2013 06:53:20 PM
- 990 Views
I wouldn't go so far as to say TOTALLY, but I was not satisfied.
14/01/2013 06:04:30 PM
- 841 Views
I will say that the battle was well constructed in certain places
14/01/2013 06:10:54 PM
- 821 Views