Active Users:451 Time:25/12/2024 06:31:53 PM
Re: You missed my point - Edit 1

Before modification by DomA at 19/11/2012 02:21:12 PM

Daigian could well be lower than the 62.5% number RJ stated as we know the Tower has been weakening for centuries.


Daigian meets the current standards, if barely (if she didn't she would not have be allowed to pass the test for the shawl, she'd had remained an Accepted, constrained to remain in TV). RJ said only 32.5% of women are strong enough to meet them. It's possible the standards have been lowered at some point, though the AS seem to imply they did not (one of them mentioned at some point that despite the decreasing strength and the fact less and less candidates could meet the standards, they were not to lower them...) but 32,5% of women was the current state of things anyway (or RJ would have specified the number applied to a past state of things, not the current one...), and that forcibly includes Daigian at the minimal required level to be allowed to past the test.





My point being a combination of declining numbers and declining strength could easily lead to declining standards. Daigian was clearly dedicated to earning the Shawl, the AS may well have decided to lower the standard to keep numbers up. Obviously I'm in pure speculation territory, but Daigian could just as easily be an example of the decline of the WT as anything else. Ultimately it has little bearing on Bell Curves etc...


The context of the Q&A makes it very clear RJ was referring to the story's contemporary WT standards.


She lies exactly on that boundary that RJ was referring to.


I actually think she lies below this boundary. She seems to be too weak to become an AS but got through using perseverance. The fact that most AS treat her as little better than a wilder demonstrates this. I think she is significantly below the next strongest AS, whomever that is. It makes no difference though, Daigian's strength has never been a direct marker of OP strength like Lanfear or Egwene's has. She's merely a name for the weakest AS level, and whether its Daigain or Vandene or Adeleas makes no difference.


RJ said 37.5% of female channelers fall below the level required to qualify for the Shawl.

It is clearly stressed that Daigian passed this test by a hairsbreadth.

Hence, Daigian clearly falls on this boundary. Put differently, you cannot be weaker than Daigian and still pass the test.

So therefore we know to a very high degree of accuracy that Daigian falls on this 37.5% boundary, or as close to it as a living channeler can apparently be.

From that point we can extrapolate the rest, as we know the number of SD's that cover the percentage of the population between 37.5% and 50%. It is 0.32SD exactly, if I recall correctly. One third of an SD, rounded for quick reference purposes.

The rest of the formula falls into place then, proving that a normal distribution is impossible, given the strength facts we are given in the series.


It doesn't matter who the weakest AS is. I agree that she is that marker, but its also irrelevant if its someone else because Daigain doesn't appear anywhere else with proportionality e.g. "Daigian was less than half as strong as Verin". I'm merely voicing a private theory that Daigian is probably a lot weaker than the woman above her. She spent more time as a novice and accepted than anyone in living memory. It doesn't affect anyone's theories though, but I honestly believe that Aes Sedai have strengths of between 10 and 30, that the 10 is the lower limit shared by several women, and that Daigian is on 6 or 8.


I can't remember which AS (Sheriam?), but one of them clearly said they allow no one who don't meet the strength standard to risk passing their test. They have a benchmark strength, and Daigian meets it, barely. The fact they have this standard and don't alter it is partly responsible for their dwindling numbers: they reject more and more candidates. Daigian is probably exceptional for the fact it's rare for women with barely meeting the standard to persevere, not get demolished by the prejudices against her strength and eventually pass the test. Nowhere it's suggested she's exceptional for having been allowed to pass the test despite not meeting the strength benchmark.

RJ was giving a reference to an inquiring reader. It would be totally worthless on its own if it excluded anyone with the shawl. It would be debatable if an Aes Sedai mentionned it in the series where it could be subject to contextual distortion or prejudices and all, but in a Q&A from RJ there's no doubt this includes all Aes Sedai.

The purpose of Daigian was manifold: serving as reference to give us a sense of how many women the WT rejects; implying that the testing puts too much weight on the ability to channel under stress (it's a good test to determine if a woman should be let to join a battlefield, it's a terrible test to judge if a woman should get the AS status) and blocks women who would have been fully trained as AS in the AOL - not to mention the dice are loaded because low standing women like Daigian need many times the intelligence, strength of character and sheer will of any high potential women to withstand a system which will seek to demolish their self-confidence and self-esteem. Her last purpose was to show how badly the Tower taught Nynaeve. Another purpose of Daigian, her first one in the series, was to show that Cadsuane had very different criteria than the WT's to judge the worth of sisters that she'd value a lot someone like Daigian over fairly strong (in OP) AS she judges weak in personality and absolutely unfit for the shawl. It's not that she believes the OP standards are wrong, it's that she believes the Tower no longer does its job at forming the stronger candidates. She considers the women strong in the power generally weak and flawed in character because their teachers made way too much of their OP potential and didn't care enough to hone the rest. It's why she's so judgmental with Nynaeve - the way she was (not) trained and educated properly by the sisters because she outclassed everyone alive in OP potential is to her symptomatic in an extreme way of what's wrong with the way today's AS are trained: you have to be weak to deserve the full exacting training/teaching everyone has a right to get, if you're too strong they'll turn corners, with Nynaeve to the point of sheer absurdity (AS barely bothered to train or teach her at all!). Nynaeve had a high potential even by AOL standards, and her likes had not been seen in over a 1000 years, and yet she's the woman the WT invested the least efforts in training properly (and not much better for Elayne and Egwene, also let too soon off the leash)... It's not only they put too much value on raw potential, it's also that you get the sense for many strong-ish sisters training Nynaeve properly would mean giving extra advantages to a woman who will soon stand above you. It also happened with women like Siuan and Moiraine, in a less extreme way. Moiraine had it right in NS though she didn't fully grasp the implications: your training really starts only once you've gained the shawl, and by then it's self-teaching. It's as if despite claiming the opposite the AS unconscious wish the stronger women to gain the shawl with the least additional advantages beside what they can't change - your raw potential - because the way the system works, you'll enter the hierarchy standing at an high rank right away, and they fear you, fear what will happen if they give you a full training that will make you formidable fairly young. The more devious and ambitious like Elaida even seek to bully recruits with more potential and put them in her debt, knowing it might come handy one day to balance the advantages you'll have over her. No wonder the more experienced sisters resent you rather then see in you someone to train the best they can. With Nynaeve that absurdity went overboard. The Yellows were wholly uninterested in her, knowing all too well she'd come to their Ajah and would get the shawl soon enough, and when she did she'd stand ridiculously higher than any but the Ajah leaders, and this is bad enough already, they have no interest to see you also enter their Ajah with a proper education and a potential honed as perfectly as the Tower can manage (the sort they gave to Daigian...), because then you'd be way too formidable to oppose. It's a vicious circle: the more it goes on, the less well-trained women are each generation (and not only in the OP - the weaves they all learn). Now it's up to a woman with mere months of OP training to make calls on how AS should be trained (and she's about to make a very bad call with her plan to raise as many new sisters as she can... she'll end up with a whole crop of even more badly trained/educated sisters after TG... as happened after the Trolloc Wars, leading to a sharp decline phase in the Tower. Except of course the whole idea is to justify some radical changes by the end of the series, so Egwene's bad calls are necessary plot devices).

Even in Cadsuane's days it was like this, though the vicious circle logic helping, it's probably worse now. Her real training, the one the envious sisters she had for teachers denied her, she got from the toothless wilder.

It's in sharp contrast with the systems of the WO who give their best to any apprentice. The SF have somewhat the opposite flaw to the WT's system: they give all they have to their very strong but see the weakest ones as not worth such efforts.




Return to message