Re: What case did Elaida present to the Hall that early? - Edit 1
Before modification by DomA at 08/11/2012 08:55:26 PM
I don't recall her having much of a case against Siuan at that time ... Elayne had only just arrived in TV and was still safe as a kitten in the Tower under the supervision of hundreds of AS.
Do you mean her case against Moiraine? If so I'm not sure the BA would have given it much thought as Moiraine and Siuan had kept their friendship at a distance for 20 years.
Do you mean her case against Moiraine? If so I'm not sure the BA would have given it much thought as Moiraine and Siuan had kept their friendship at a distance for 20 years.
Yes it's that, but remember that Sitters humiliated Siuan in the Hall by associating her to her former Ajah, as if she still was a Blue. They tried to prevent the Blue Ajah from having representatives because with Siuan and Leane they already had.
About the friendship of Moiraine and Siuan I discussed this elsewhere. The only ones in the Tower who think this friendship forgotten are Siuan and Moiraine themselves. It's been referred to a few times by other sisters, always with the mention Siuan and Moiraine seemed to have distanced themselves on purpose.
They never confronted them about it until Verin did (or since) as Aes Sedai affect to stay out of each other's business and if Siuan and Moiraine wanted to pretend they never were close friends it was their business, but it seems few sisters who've known them have forgotten their friendship, or haven't puzzled out it's because Siuan and Moiraine wanted others to forget this they affected to be distant now.
Cadsuane and Seaine are some of those who mentionned them, and of course Elaida.
In other words, Siuan's and Moiraine's little scheme to hide they were close = big fail. The obtained exactly the opposite effect, everybody thought they affected otherwise because they were scheming.
And keeping this in mind, the whole confrontation about Moiraine in the Hall, insulting Siuan by implying she was still serving her ex-Ajah etc. was all quite relevant. It was all a "what the heck are you up to with Moiraine?" attack.