Active Users:1079 Time:19/12/2024 06:35:33 AM
It could be... DomA Send a noteboard - 21/09/2012 11:30:10 PM
I agree that it was Cyndane (who probably calls him al'Thor to try to distance herself from her ideas of Lews Therin), but my impression was that they were sending him on a suicide mission to distract Rand from something else. I'm not committed enough to what you know I believe to be a very second-rate series of books to comb through and read all the Dark Prophecy and such, but what I remember was that either you turn Rand to the Shadow, or you maneuver him into a place where he does more damage to his friends than to his enemies, or you kill him on the slopes of Shayol Ghul at the Last Battle. The Forsaken don't expect Isam to survive, but he'll distract Rand in a major way while they do something they really, really have to do (like steal Callandor or something).

Also, although the books are aesthetically a train wreck, the Isam section showed how much better the books could have been if we had seen more motivations for the evil characters earlier on. The later books have had some interesting moments like the Isam POV and the point where Ishamael/Moridin says he's tired and wants to break the cycle for that reason. Other than that, evil has just been pathetic, or a caricature, or both.


But that sort of mission, Isam would far more likely get from Moridin.

You're close about the options with Rand, but it's more deductions we made over the years than any strong statement in the series.

The "have Rand do more damages to his side" angle is from "Let the Lord of Chaos rule" theme, and the best background info we have to tie to Rand is from the "Big White Book", where we found out the Lord of Chaos/Misrule is a name from a WOT Feastday (inspired by the Lupercaliae, medieval carnival and the whole Inverted World motif) elsewhere he's called the King of Fools. It's about raising the village fool as King for a day, and letting him preside over chaotic celebrations. It's pretty obvious looking at concrete medieval examples of "inversions" that this was a major source of inspiration for Jordan.. Queens are turned into servants, an village innskeeper daughter is raised "Abbess", a farmer's son is married to an Empress who's turned for a while into a thieving servant etc. Anyway, knowing the source of inspiration for all this... it's fairly obvious the Lord of Chaos Rule saying used by the Shadow refers to that King of Fools doing more damages to his own side than good. But it wasn't stated in clear by anyone so far in the books.

The other two have been referred to but not exactly explained by Ishamael/Moridin. We still don't know for sure why Moridin and the DO want Rand alive, to die in specific circumstances. It's clear the Shadow would have preferred to turn Rand to their side. Having him die in specific circumstances and (as Ishamael once said) "serve in death" seems to have been once the plan B.

I agree with you that Jordan didn't do all that well with his villains. He didn't find a good balance between stretching suspense over such a long series and developping his villains in interesting ways. Oh for sure that kept us theorizing all these years amd he wanted to give us the feeling the world was vast and no one understands nearly all of what's going on, but the closer we get to the ending, the more obvious it is that what RJ developped and had happened behind the scene with the Forsaken is a lot more interesting than the hard to puzzle out tidbits shown on-screen. He seriously underused his villains through most of the series, kept their motivations way too hidden. Perhaps there are many revelations about what went on earlier coming that will make the early books more interesting (and perhaps more clever than they appear now), but I'm sceptical.

And mind you, making each one an icon of an aspect of human nature Jordan loathed wasn't exactly the way to end up with very complex characters, especially not psychologically. I still kind of like Moridin and Lanfear, and Graendal when written by Jordan (ie: when she still had a superior IQ). Demandred for me is a wait and see case. I never found him all that interesting because he never had much to do, and like most of the others he's so basic: talented man in the shadow of a more talented and luckier man ruins his life by being consummed by envy. Yawn. His military genius might be interesting to see in play, but I get the fairly bad feeling that's an aspect where we'll miss the Jordan-the-military-history-buff badly (ie, whatever Jordan set up for Demandred, I doubt Sanderson even with the help of Jordan's assistant who's a military buff was be able to write a military genius all that well) - and I suspect we'll see Demandred at work mostly from the POV of his foes, without great insight into his plans from Demandred's POV. And that's too bad.

The only thing I'm highly confident about is that the pieces of the puzzle will all fit into place nicely. Jordan conceived the Last Battle before he started the series and developped the major points going from there and back to the begin backward. We've paid the price of that method often enough (as it's no doubt responsible for much of "I need to stretch X here a bit because Y isn't ready, and my hands are tied about what X and Y will do next together";), but at least with TGS/TOM we started getting the pay-off, which is that a very great deal of details we thought was more or less "fillers" turn out to quite relevant in the endgame (sending Shemerin in hiding in TV by book 5 so she'd be there to lead Siuan into the city in the finale.. now that's planning), and unlike so many finales that ended up as train wrecks due to bad planning or too much making-it-all-up-as-I-go-along writing, WOT's seems more "in control" (too much maybe, I fear a little the "not enough was irrelevant and everything fits too neatly" problem). Whatever the execution as novels, and God knows they're flawed, Jordan was certainly clever.
Reply to message
AMOL Prologue: The Town *major spoilers* - 19/09/2012 06:54:35 PM 2090 Views
Re: AMOL Prologue: The Town *major spoilers* - 19/09/2012 07:59:58 PM 1012 Views
I also lean toward Cyndane. - 19/09/2012 08:42:48 PM 809 Views
Cyndane seems to jump out first, yes - 20/09/2012 02:46:26 AM 855 Views
She says it too... - 20/09/2012 04:30:14 PM 776 Views
Red Veiled are merely Channeling Darkfriends that file their teeth. - 20/09/2012 05:19:34 AM 907 Views
Ever heard of the Mirror of Mists? - 20/09/2012 08:13:51 AM 909 Views
Yup. - 20/09/2012 04:27:28 PM 673 Views
I didn't say it did. - 20/09/2012 04:29:20 PM 792 Views
Oh Terez, - 20/09/2012 07:42:56 PM 685 Views
Are you sure? - 20/09/2012 06:48:00 PM 985 Views
I found the Isam stuff more interesting, frankly. It seems to contradict The Shadow Rising. - 20/09/2012 07:09:54 PM 1128 Views
RJ wrote the Slayer scene. - 20/09/2012 07:35:43 PM 975 Views
I think it was Cyndane, and perhaps we got there the solution to other unsolved mysteries... - 20/09/2012 07:25:38 PM 1220 Views
You don't think it was just a suicide mission? - 20/09/2012 08:23:20 PM 730 Views
It could be... - 21/09/2012 11:30:10 PM 849 Views
I haven't see a shadow theory I liked so much since the Forsaken tea party one on wotmania - 20/09/2012 10:32:52 PM 757 Views
And in the hands of Sanderson... - 20/09/2012 11:36:56 PM 723 Views
I don't think she sent the Shadowspawn though - 21/09/2012 08:08:57 AM 686 Views
It's quite possible - 21/09/2012 09:31:36 PM 966 Views
I think the Chosen was Graendal - 22/09/2012 04:04:40 AM 915 Views
Very unlikely Moridin wants Rand dead at this point - 23/09/2012 01:08:56 PM 701 Views

Reply to Message