Active Users:772 Time:15/11/2024 03:25:49 PM
Re: I can't believe Galad will be accepted as a ruler since he is the Lord Captain Commander DomA Send a noteboard - 28/05/2012 04:54:46 PM
I still question why he is even a Damodred and not a Mantear ... High Seat in fact given his lineage he should have been. I findit very strange that the other High Seats allowed Morgase to even raise him. Taringail was very foolish if he was behind it as Galad had a weaker claim to the Thrones of either Andor or Cairhien than Elayne would eventually have and since Taringail wasn't High Seat of Damodred Galad had a very weak claim in Cairhien ... Makes no sense in my head


Huh?

By the information in New Spring, Galad had a better claim to the Sun Throne than Elayne. By primogeniture, first of all. Only Andor excludes the males from the succession line, not Cairhien. Taringail himself was excluded because of his wedding to a foreign heir, which suggests it's most extraordinary Cairhienin decided to recognize Elayne's claim. Even much better than either Elayne's or Galad's claim is Moiraine's. Neither Galad nor Moiraine have pushed their claim forward, that's what let the door open for Elayne. If not for the desire to be lead by anyone but Rand and the knowledge Elayne is the only one he was ready to accept in this role, for the anarchy in the country and the need for a ruler, Elayne's claim would have been rejected. If a Caihrienin heir could be passed on for both the Throne and the High Seat of House Damodred (which passed to his cousin Barthanes) on the sole basis that he was married to the heir of a foreign throne, imagine where that left Elayne, who is a foreign ruler and an Aes Sedai...

Taringail did not marry into House Mantear. He remained a Damodred, until his second wedding when Morgase forced him to marry into House Trakand. Galad is not part of House Mantear either, merely tied to it by his mother. We don't know if he's officially part of House Trakand - we don't know the legal rules of Morgase's adoption. He retained his name in any case, which the other Andoran lords who marry into another House do not (the lords whose wife lead the House have her name, that's how we know this).

Why the High Seats let Morgase raise Galad? Isn't it obvious: the adopted son of the Queen of Andor had a claim to the Sun Throne, a claim Andor might be able to push forward one day if House Riatin failed. No house would have let any other but Andor's Royal House get their hands on Galad... it might have eventually given that House a power to rival Andor's.

The fact Elayne is AS and a foreign ruler wasn't enough in the current circumstances to reject her claim of the Sun Throne. I don't think the fact Galad leads the WC would be enough to prevent him from ruling in Cairhien.

I'm not saying this is likely, though. I'm just not convinced Elayne will retain both nations - and if she does she'll need help to rule both (Galad's, Moiraine's?), but the way things are going, it sounds like she may loose in the Last Battle the heart of Andor and its capital. Will Mayene stand after TG?

It's not impossible Elayne has to make Ishara's choice, when she doesn't have enough of a population after TG to justify claiming that much territory. No, I don't think Elayne would choose to relocate in Cairhien by choice. But I hardly see her relocating in Baerlon or Whitebridge either... Aringill is already a more logical choice as it stands between her two nations. But she may have to be pragmatic and relocate in her second capital if Caemlyn gets destroyed and Cairhien still stands, and by pragmatism too she may have to gather up her population.

Aviendha's unreliable vision offered very little clues. We know the Court of the Sun name exists (it appears in a Fourth Age quote), but in the vision Cairhien has fallen. Caemlyn/Andor stands, and is apparently part of a pact which name suggests it's an alliance of Perrin-Elayne originally... but weirdly it's the body of Andor's Lion and the head of the Eagle... But considering it's not what will happen, it doesn't tell us much.

This message last edited by DomA on 28/05/2012 at 04:58:28 PM
Reply to message
aMoL UK cover and Blurb (SPOILERS!!!!!!!!!) - 21/05/2012 06:44:26 PM 2692 Views
Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 06:46:41 PM 1203 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 08:04:29 PM 1127 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 08:45:41 PM 1033 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 09:04:09 PM 1235 Views
*nods in agreement* *NM* - 21/05/2012 10:46:48 PM 403 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 11:08:50 PM 1076 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 22/05/2012 01:02:16 AM 1060 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 21/05/2012 09:35:29 PM 1133 Views
Mat and the madness... - 21/05/2012 10:30:09 PM 1077 Views
Nynaeve's revelation may make the AS even more worried of Rand being mad - 21/05/2012 10:58:37 PM 1100 Views
Not Egwene though... - 21/05/2012 11:02:41 PM 906 Views
Maybe, maybe not ... Nynaeve just gave everyone proof of the extent of his possible madness - 21/05/2012 11:26:41 PM 902 Views
Fair enough. - 21/05/2012 11:31:10 PM 919 Views
Agreed that it's an odd blurb - 21/05/2012 11:45:03 PM 960 Views
Re: Maybe, maybe not ... Nynaeve just gave everyone proof of the extent of his possible madness - 22/05/2012 01:14:05 AM 973 Views
I was thinking about that... - 22/05/2012 02:35:25 AM 870 Views
Re: I was thinking about that... - 22/05/2012 03:41:48 AM 948 Views
Re: Mat and the madness... - 22/05/2012 02:29:31 AM 1023 Views
Rand's dreams... - 22/05/2012 02:42:36 AM 942 Views
She assumes he's mad just like most people assume a 19 year old boy is horney - 22/05/2012 03:47:49 AM 1098 Views
I'd like some evidence for this. - 22/05/2012 04:14:27 AM 900 Views
It's still ingrained in the society - 22/05/2012 01:28:05 PM 1003 Views
Moridin and the link - 28/05/2012 01:45:43 AM 834 Views
Re: Thoughts... - 23/05/2012 01:06:10 PM 874 Views
What caught my eye there was "Trollocs seize Caemlyn." - 22/05/2012 02:12:25 PM 972 Views
As much as I would love Moiraine to go with him to Ebou Dar - 22/05/2012 07:20:40 PM 1044 Views
At this stage, all roads lead to Rand. - 22/05/2012 09:08:42 PM 888 Views
Re: At this stage, all roads lead to Rand. - 23/05/2012 08:07:56 PM 927 Views
Well, like I say, there is no reason they could not ALL meet up with Tuon. - 23/05/2012 08:53:53 PM 910 Views
Re: Well, like I say, there is no reason they could not ALL meet up with Tuon. - 24/05/2012 02:41:55 PM 1039 Views
Aviendha's visions from Rhuidean indicate he will kneel... - 24/05/2012 07:04:02 PM 1304 Views
Re: Aviendha's visions from Rhuidean indicate he will kneel... - 26/05/2012 09:42:20 PM 1445 Views
Agreed... - 26/05/2012 09:57:06 PM 1002 Views
I think you are extrapolating some of his actions into more than he intends - 26/05/2012 10:37:44 PM 881 Views
Re: Agreed... - 27/05/2012 04:26:15 AM 948 Views
I think you're both wrong... - 27/05/2012 08:41:50 AM 952 Views
Re: I think you're both wrong... - 27/05/2012 07:10:08 PM 955 Views
I can't believe Galad will be accepted as a ruler since he is the Lord Captain Commander - 28/05/2012 02:48:26 AM 961 Views
Re: I can't believe Galad will be accepted as a ruler since he is the Lord Captain Commander - 28/05/2012 04:54:46 PM 887 Views
That makes no sense - 28/05/2012 05:50:16 PM 929 Views
Taringail was Laman's heir... - 28/05/2012 07:20:07 PM 875 Views
You are answering the wrong question - 29/05/2012 02:19:48 PM 862 Views
No. I've answered the exact question. You seem to have missed it. - 29/05/2012 04:40:17 PM 915 Views
Yet not one of these things actually happened - 29/05/2012 10:13:35 PM 904 Views
You're being absurd... - 30/05/2012 01:04:36 AM 857 Views
Explain why Taringail didn't become King after Laman's death then - 30/05/2012 05:48:48 AM 829 Views
- 30/05/2012 06:11:02 AM 828 Views
Why then would Taringail, an ambitious man, renounce a Throne? - 30/05/2012 06:22:08 AM 981 Views
We don't fully know... - 30/05/2012 06:43:30 AM 738 Views
You just flipped your last statement - 30/05/2012 06:55:36 AM 974 Views
You seem extremely confused... - 30/05/2012 09:56:30 AM 900 Views
Not confused, simply not satisfied with the information we have - 30/05/2012 12:15:59 PM 868 Views
Re: Not confused, simply not satisfied with the information we have - 30/05/2012 03:34:06 PM 1033 Views
I am not contesting the information we have - 30/05/2012 04:48:08 PM 970 Views
You're impossible... - 30/05/2012 10:02:59 PM 896 Views
Wow ... Not sure what is bringing out the aggression - 30/05/2012 10:19:18 PM 819 Views
*sigh* - 30/05/2012 11:45:28 PM 885 Views
DomA swore *NM* - 31/05/2012 03:39:24 PM 990 Views
Re: That makes no sense - 29/05/2012 04:39:45 PM 1033 Views
Only one other thing... - 29/05/2012 04:53:29 PM 765 Views
Re: Only one other thing... - 30/05/2012 12:32:58 PM 840 Views
Bryne was Captain General not First Prince and Taringail was Prince Consort not FP - 30/05/2012 06:07:48 AM 879 Views
Bryne was First Prince Regent. - 30/05/2012 06:19:33 AM 851 Views
Fair enough ... Thanks for providing a quote - 30/05/2012 06:22:52 AM 1039 Views
Re: Fair enough ... Thanks for providing a quote - 30/05/2012 04:38:29 PM 899 Views
No he wasn't - 30/05/2012 04:16:02 PM 834 Views
No Forsaken will go near that Ter'angreal - 26/05/2012 10:33:20 PM 795 Views
Re: No Forsaken will go near that Ter'angreal - 27/05/2012 03:23:12 AM 876 Views
Aviendha reprogrammed the ter'angreal - 27/05/2012 01:50:19 PM 842 Views
Re: Aviendha reprogrammed the ter'angreal - 27/05/2012 06:44:41 PM 989 Views
I'd have to re-read to be 100% certain, but the way I read the passage - 28/05/2012 02:10:14 AM 952 Views
He might not literally kneel before the ter'angreal, but almost certainly must meet with Tuon soon. - 25/05/2012 03:40:54 AM 1179 Views
Soon might be relative... - 27/05/2012 02:08:53 AM 1371 Views
Sul'dam - 27/05/2012 09:03:57 AM 1225 Views
Re: Sul'dam - 27/05/2012 05:54:57 PM 961 Views
Right, then; here we go.... - 03/06/2012 08:45:20 AM 834 Views
Re: As much as I would love Moiraine to go with him to Ebou Dar - 23/05/2012 05:28:17 PM 890 Views
I think I read a fan fiction like that once *NM* - 23/05/2012 08:04:42 PM 470 Views

Reply to Message