That is good logic, but the flip side is: Why would RJ bother to specify that if it were minutiae?
Joel Send a noteboard - 23/05/2012 11:22:24 AM
...the walls around the grounds, and the big black stone Taim made his announcements from.
The palace is white marble (with black columns, IRRC).
Terez who asked Sanderson said he was on his guard a bit, wanting to know first why/because of what theory she asked that question (ie: it had the "could have missed anything in the books that would make it better to RAFO this?" feel).
In other words, it's probably no more than "interesting minutia". If it played any real role in AMOL, Brandon would have RAFOed this.
The palace is white marble (with black columns, IRRC).
Terez who asked Sanderson said he was on his guard a bit, wanting to know first why/because of what theory she asked that question (ie: it had the "could have missed anything in the books that would make it better to RAFO this?" feel).
In other words, it's probably no more than "interesting minutia". If it played any real role in AMOL, Brandon would have RAFOed this.
If the rock came from Shayol Ghul but it did not matter, it seems kind of odd Jordan would spend any of his precious and fleeting last moments jotting that down for Sanderson to somehow include (or not.) "I did not have time to tell Brandon how Moiraine is rescued, because I was busy letting him know the irrelevant-but-cool fact the Black Towers walls came from Shayol Ghul." It is equally hard to imagine anyone going to the trouble of obtaining that difficult-to-obtain material (how was it transported? Traveling near Shayol Ghul is known to be dicey, at best) if it were not useful for something. Maybe it is just something trivial like allowing the DO to directly observe the BT, or perhaps it does something more significant like allow him to extend the powers he has at Shayol Ghul to the BT. I cannot imagine it being completely irrelevant since it was specifically stated though.
Why Sanderson did NOT RAFO this is the bigger question to me. Unless he just thought, Well, there is no reason it could NOT be, so as of now it is, just to send them off on a wild goose chase so they do not puzzle out anything significant in the next six months. That would not be dishonest or deceptive, only misleading (which I consider legitimate when people fish for confirmations that are also spoilers) but it would also be kinda weak.
Honorbound and honored to be Bonded to Mahtaliel Sedai
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.
Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!
LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.
Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!
LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
This message last edited by Joel on 23/05/2012 at 11:23:06 AM
So apparently the palace at the Black Tower is made of Shayol Ghul stone...
23/05/2012 12:57:37 AM
- 2171 Views
Maybe Shaidar Haran's physical limitation to SG can be bypassed by moving tainted rocks elsewhere? *NM*
23/05/2012 03:10:59 AM
- 515 Views
Not the palace...
23/05/2012 03:32:59 AM
- 1184 Views
That is good logic, but the flip side is: Why would RJ bother to specify that if it were minutiae?
23/05/2012 11:22:24 AM
- 1016 Views
Wouldn't have taken any time away from creating the ending.
23/05/2012 02:58:32 PM
- 913 Views
It just seems an odd thing to mention purely as background color.
23/05/2012 08:17:45 PM
- 997 Views
Re: It just seems an odd thing to mention purely as background color.
23/05/2012 08:42:09 PM
- 1017 Views
Yeah, my bet is it is something more like that.
23/05/2012 09:14:24 PM
- 923 Views
Re: Yeah, my bet is it is something more like that.
24/05/2012 02:23:54 AM
- 956 Views
His response certainly seem to raise more questions than it answers, perhaps deliberately.
25/05/2012 01:38:30 AM
- 885 Views
Re: His response certainly seem to raise more questions than it answers, perhaps deliberately.
27/05/2012 04:32:24 PM
- 1120 Views
Re: His response certainly seem to raise more questions than it answers, perhaps deliberately.
03/06/2012 08:44:57 AM
- 821 Views
Forgive me if I missed it, but I think the most obvious points haven't been discussed:
22/06/2012 10:59:02 PM
- 1327 Views
Be'laim FTW, but technically half the Andoran nobility is Rands blood.
22/06/2012 11:15:12 PM
- 869 Views
Re: Why would RJ bother to specify that if it were minutiae?
23/05/2012 07:58:50 PM
- 929 Views
The way RJ played up everything in the Blight (especially Shayol Ghul) being subsumed in the DO...
23/05/2012 09:07:31 PM
- 892 Views
Re: So apparently the palace at the Black Tower is made of Shayol Ghul stone...
23/05/2012 05:52:12 PM
- 980 Views
Re: So apparently the palace at the Black Tower is made of Shayol Ghul stone...
23/05/2012 08:51:36 PM
- 1032 Views
If SG rocks have special properties...
28/05/2012 01:28:28 AM
- 827 Views
Blightfortress, Towers of Midnight, etc.
18/06/2012 12:31:48 PM
- 736 Views
Re: Blightfortress, Towers of Midnight, etc.
19/06/2012 05:42:21 AM
- 882 Views
Re: Blightfortress, Towers of Midnight, etc.
19/06/2012 06:51:02 AM
- 736 Views