Active Users:1092 Time:22/11/2024 11:09:13 PM
Re: Everything I've read keeps me convinced that Graendal was supposed to die. DomA Send a noteboard - 15/05/2012 10:43:30 PM
Her dying doesn't feel right, but I totally agree it feels like her next arc feels like Brandon gave her a reprieve she wasn't meant to have originally.

Her death would have undermined the whole "Rand is falling in madness" arc, her survival amplified how far gone Rand's mind was. Rand plan just wasn't rational: risking the Pattern to get rid of Graendal? Not all the Forsaken combined are worth that. Nothing should be. He was of course oblivious to his own insanity, but Graendal wasn't - he brought the bloody AK to the CK for the confrontation, it's like bringing a nuclear missile to get rid of one mouse (actually, it's even worse - its a true doomsday weapon which can destroy the world). The thing terrified LTT.

I think this was still her exit from the series, though. I'm not 100% convinced, but fairly convinced. Of course, Brandon ruined the amplification effect by moving her survival scene to TOM, but a lot of that happened as "unforeseen consequences" of the book split.


I don't know that her survival actually changed the gravitas of Rand's insanity - even if she did die, she's pretty inconsequential compared to the potential destruction of reality, which is of course exactly why Moridin told Rand how to kill her. Of course, I'm not against Graendal's survival as such, I just don't believe she was supposed to. I'm pretty sure Aran'gar was the one supposed to go after Perrin. It just seems that after all the build up with the Rebels, it feels strange for her to go away without a confrontation, and then be killed off completely casually. Also, there's that male channeler who used the Portal Stone. I don't understand why, if that was just some corrupt Asha'man, they didn't bring enough to actually participate in the battle.

Of course, I have no idea how the timelines were supposed to go. If the attack on Perrin happened before the destruction of Natrin's Barrow, then Aran'gar could have fled there after her failure and then the scene could play out as it did. But I certainly feel something was missing with Aran'gar.


I agree something was missing with Aran'gar, but I disagree on what it is.

The foreshadowing was in KOD. Aran'gar meant to use Graendal's networks to get Rand killed and put the blame on her.

That made a short-lived return in TOM, barely touched on (I might eve imagine this!).

The thing is, Brandon had most of Egwene's story mapped out for him by RJ. We got pretty much everything, it's only Alviarin,s storyline that was obviously missing, with a remnant in one scene RJ must have drafted himself. It lead nowhere.

For Rand, Brandon had many more holes, and obviously he filled them as he could. The Graendal/Aran'gar story arc, Brandon just failed to make very good use of. It's conceivable it didn't matter that much to RJ. It's Rand's progression that mattered, his whole storyline was a fall into insanity, then the Epiphany. I could well imagine RJ left the details of where we'd see interference from Aran'gar, and where we'd see hints of pawns of Graendal for later, when he crafted the details of the storylines, the plot that he would build around the character development. The details didn't matter that much, Graendal would have had a rational plan, Aran'gar would have ruined it and put Rand's life in danger, which put Graendal in dire danger from Moridin. That would have created a background of insanity and irrationality in the Shadow's actions in AD, which was the perfect background for Rand's own downfall. AD already felt like an asylum... Rj would have pushed it a bit further.

Graendal would have puzzled it out in the end, that Aran'gar betrayed her - and it would have played in her final decision to trap Aran'gar... and that would have been her downfall, as SH didn't forgive her Aran'gar's death.

But RJ needed to get Egwene's timeline set in stone first, as it determined how long Rand spent in AD. Brandon chose not to make much use of Aran'gar/Graendal - perhaps he didn't have much notes on that and didn't think of anything. There was many great things in Rand's storyline, but the lack of depth of the Forsaken plot while he was in AD was certainly pretty disappointing.

For that matter, we see the same thing in Egwene's storyline. The BA plot and Mesaana were the big disappointment, perhaps because RJ would have grafted those details later on, once he had the protagonist character's progression solidly in place. This was left to Brandon, who didn't find uses for these characters.

I very much doubt Brandon changed the fate of two Forsaken and inversed the one who was supposed to die and the one who was supposed to move on. Sanderson never lists Graendal among his favourite, and it seems obvious he's not comfortable writing a depraved character like her, not very good at getting in her mind. I'm pretty sure he would have preferred another character for this if it was left to him, but RJ killed Aran'gar in AD and Graendal just got enslaved, so that's Graendal he used.

As for the male channeling at the battle, I'm sure this was supposed to be a teaser announcing Demandred's arrival in the plot - that the decision he wouldn't reveal his channelers just yet was his decision. Slayer failed, Moridin immediately ordered Demandred to send in the army. But Demandred didn't want to ruin his surprise at the BT, so ordered the channelers to stay out of it.

Brandon changed that so Graendal called the army. He didn't want to get to Demandred before AMOL, except for the epilogue.

For Byar, I agree 100% with you. I'm sure it was a change, and it wasn't a good one. It ruined the character. That he wouldn't accept the decision of the LCC and let his hatred get the better of him and attempt to kill Perrin was foreshadowed since their first meeting or so. Turning that to Compulsion was a bad idea. It's just as if Jordan chose to make Aram a DF, or compelled by a Forsaken. It would have ruined this storyline. Brandon just ruined the repetition of that motif again, with Byar. It's no big deal, just a bit annoying for re reads and such, where Byar's build up through the series will feel really irrelevant (much like Alviarin's build up is now totally ruined by forgetting to use her in TGS...her involvement with Mesaana, her efforts against the BA hunters, how she started to approach Egwene.. it will all feel very "blahh" now.)








This message last edited by DomA on 15/05/2012 at 10:49:35 PM
Reply to message
Delana and compulsion - 13/05/2012 10:22:50 PM 1171 Views
It was so saidar would be detected in the compulsion... - 13/05/2012 11:21:10 PM 861 Views
Re: It was so saidar would be detected in the compulsion... - 14/05/2012 07:21:57 AM 636 Views
I think you need to re-read the passage - 14/05/2012 08:07:57 AM 608 Views
Re: I think you need to re-read the passage - 14/05/2012 11:16:26 AM 616 Views
I guess I needed to re-read the passage - 14/05/2012 03:05:03 PM 692 Views
She didn't know she'd be balefired... - 14/05/2012 08:16:06 PM 616 Views
Re: She didn't know she'd be balefired... - 14/05/2012 08:53:00 PM 747 Views
Re: She didn't know she'd be balefired... - 14/05/2012 10:20:01 PM 728 Views
You clearly read the scene, so how did you miss this? - 15/05/2012 03:33:55 AM 748 Views
Re: You clearly read the scene, so how did you miss this? - 15/05/2012 08:48:32 AM 631 Views
Re: You clearly read the scene, so how did you miss this? - 15/05/2012 02:41:15 PM 503 Views
Re: You clearly read the scene, so how did you miss this? - 15/05/2012 03:10:48 PM 700 Views
Oh, by the way... - 15/05/2012 08:55:24 AM 460 Views
That doesn't make sense... - 15/05/2012 09:47:54 PM 520 Views
Everything I've read keeps me convinced that Graendal was supposed to die. - 15/05/2012 06:46:57 AM 555 Views
I don't think she was supposed to die, but... - 15/05/2012 07:14:46 AM 683 Views
Re: Everything I've read keeps me convinced that Graendal was supposed to die. - 15/05/2012 09:58:08 AM 543 Views
In all honesty I think RJ did that on purpose - 15/05/2012 01:28:13 PM 668 Views
You misunderstand. - 15/05/2012 07:46:20 PM 660 Views
Agreed... - 15/05/2012 08:41:15 PM 479 Views
Re: Agreed... - 15/05/2012 11:07:46 PM 848 Views
Yup... - 15/05/2012 11:53:12 PM 631 Views
Re: Yup... - 16/05/2012 01:13:16 AM 695 Views
We'll have to agree to disagree on Graendal, I guess... - 16/05/2012 01:40:59 AM 805 Views
Re: We'll have to agree to disagree on Graendal, I guess... - 16/05/2012 01:46:09 AM 721 Views
Re: Everything I've read keeps me convinced that Graendal was supposed to die. - 15/05/2012 01:35:18 PM 654 Views
I don't think this is the end of Graendal's story... - 15/05/2012 02:27:10 PM 579 Views
Somethign I forgot... - 15/05/2012 04:54:40 PM 759 Views
Re: Everything I've read keeps me convinced that Graendal was supposed to die. - 15/05/2012 08:13:24 PM 619 Views
Re: Everything I've read keeps me convinced that Graendal was supposed to die. - 15/05/2012 10:43:30 PM 605 Views

Reply to Message