Active Users:1194 Time:22/11/2024 10:39:43 PM
Not that much DomA Send a noteboard - 08/05/2012 10:07:24 PM
She would have been able to much more effectively questioned them had she Stilled them first


Not really. They would have told her nothing very useful, let alone reliable, without putting them to the question, and information you get from people you torture is always very hard to trust. The DF/BA would have given her any drivel they thought she wanted to hear to stop torturing them. She might have gotten a few gems lost in a big pile of dross.

Torture is illegal in Andor, even for the Queen.

Deceiving the BA that she was Forsaken was the most clever mean, and she got truths out of them. Elayne should just have thought about it much sooner, then deal with the women immediately. She should never have held them prisoners so long. All her experience with BA told her this would end badly, perhaps very badly.

Other than her clever deception, Elayne should have done exactly what Egwene has done: put them all to death without any more ceremony. Perhaps like Egwene she shouldn't even have bothered with putting them to the question. Elayne learned nothing Verin had not already told Mat, or written to him.

That these women were BA wasn't in question. It was already proven beyond reasonable doubt, an Amyrlin had declared these women were BA and in fact Elayne/Nynaeve were originally given carte blanche from Siuan to deal with them as they saw fit. Siuan never asked any of them to bring the BA alive to the Tower (Moiraine made that decision), she gave them a writ that even let them kill them on sight if needed, all under her authority. That authority no longer applied (and never did for Elayne, actually) but Elayne could eventually testify that all these women have broken at least one bound Oath, and that's evidence enough. Not one Sitter would have challenged that they were BA. They would have grumbled about not being able to interrogate them, but Elayne could tell them how much good that did with Ispan, and how many people Careane killed.

As long as Elayne proceeded secretely, pretending the prisoners had been sent to TV and no one in Andor but the few involved sworn to secrecy knew the Queen put AS to death, Egwene would have been all too happy to cover it all up. Even if the Hall learned, she would have gotten away with a penance at best. After the BA purge, no even with that. No more than the BA hunters did.



This message last edited by DomA on 08/05/2012 at 10:08:38 PM
Reply to message
Elayne - 02/05/2012 11:36:52 PM 1633 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 12:15:35 AM 751 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 02:36:14 PM 753 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 02:47:58 PM 900 Views
Yes, I posted a proposition with that solution years ago. - 06/05/2012 07:25:55 PM 778 Views
With the new healing technology - 07/05/2012 12:08:50 AM 773 Views
So it's better to not bother?! At least by stilling, you force them to make the effort. - 08/05/2012 06:53:17 AM 3197 Views
Although... - 08/05/2012 08:14:55 AM 657 Views
Not to mention that Elayne KNOWS that Stilling them would also have broken their Oaths - 08/05/2012 01:11:31 PM 685 Views
Tower Law is very strict - 08/05/2012 02:12:36 PM 723 Views
See DomA's thoughts below ... - 08/05/2012 11:26:43 PM 799 Views
Not that much - 08/05/2012 10:07:24 PM 720 Views
Torture in WoT - 09/05/2012 05:37:37 AM 855 Views
Huh? - 09/05/2012 03:24:25 PM 747 Views
Many times Elayne remarks on obeying the law - 07/05/2012 06:31:58 PM 702 Views
Re: Many times Elayne remarks on obeying the law - 08/05/2012 10:22:48 PM 784 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 03:38:15 PM 1039 Views
The timeline of ToM is messed up... - 03/05/2012 04:43:22 PM 829 Views
Re: Elayne - 03/05/2012 03:38:18 PM 957 Views
Yes, too bad the viewing was wrong and she died...oh, wait.... - 06/05/2012 07:34:43 PM 921 Views
I agree - 07/05/2012 02:25:06 AM 910 Views
Elayne sharing the invasion news... - 07/05/2012 03:38:57 PM 718 Views
I forgot that, thanks - 07/05/2012 05:20:25 PM 842 Views
I don't know that we agree about Elayne... - 08/05/2012 06:40:56 AM 832 Views
Actually, I think we do on most a lot of points - 08/05/2012 08:53:43 PM 723 Views
Re: Actually, I think we do on most a lot of points - 08/05/2012 09:18:01 PM 691 Views
Agree with all of that. Some points to consider... - 09/05/2012 05:45:24 AM 757 Views
Re: Agree with all of that. Some points to consider... - 09/05/2012 09:48:28 PM 813 Views

Reply to Message