I am not really trying to defend the vision as all that viable. My point has been more about showing that we can't simply assume that it's invalid because at the start of the vision the Aiel are still whole. There is more than one way the remnant of a remnant can happen. Rand "Saving" that remnant doesn't have to mean they are the only ones to survive TG. There is no mention of the Aiel dying during TG, only that Rand will Break them and Save the remnant. The Aiel we see in the vision go down a path and are destroyed ... We don't know anything about a possible group (say a remnant of a remnant) are still in existence following the Way...
I agree with most of you post below where you address the timing of the vision being prior to Rand's epiphany on Dragon Mount ... Although I think enlightened Rand will offer the Aiel the opportunity to become Dedicated again and some remnant may well accept that and stand aside from the fighting. The way the Prophesy is worded Rand Saving the remnant is an active statement and gives indication that he will directly do this much like he told them about their history. A direct action that opened the door to breaking them.
I've said before I find her vision highly unlikely at this point since the Aiel are very unlikely to ignore the warning in their own prophesy as many Wise Ones have spoken of doing everything they can to ensure the remnant is the largest possible group and the vision doesn't really bear that out.
I agree with most of you post below where you address the timing of the vision being prior to Rand's epiphany on Dragon Mount ... Although I think enlightened Rand will offer the Aiel the opportunity to become Dedicated again and some remnant may well accept that and stand aside from the fighting. The way the Prophesy is worded Rand Saving the remnant is an active statement and gives indication that he will directly do this much like he told them about their history. A direct action that opened the door to breaking them.
I've said before I find her vision highly unlikely at this point since the Aiel are very unlikely to ignore the warning in their own prophesy as many Wise Ones have spoken of doing everything they can to ensure the remnant is the largest possible group and the vision doesn't really bear that out.
Domani Drag Queen in the White Tower ... Aran'gar watch out!
This message last edited by darius_sedai on 18/04/2012 at 02:32:22 PM
Aviendha, the columns, and the Seanchan
03/04/2012 04:29:31 PM
- 1894 Views
The entire point, I believe, is to give Avienda the opportunity to change that future
03/04/2012 05:13:48 PM
- 1162 Views
As far as I understand it, that future is impossible anyway.
03/04/2012 07:30:52 PM
- 907 Views
Depends on how one defines Aiel
04/04/2012 04:11:11 AM
- 860 Views
There are more than there were before.
04/04/2012 07:03:27 AM
- 879 Views
But when the prophesy was made there many followers
04/04/2012 10:10:54 AM
- 784 Views
The Tuatha'an are not Aiel.
04/04/2012 06:28:47 PM
- 861 Views
Re: The Tuatha'an are not Aiel.
05/04/2012 01:41:23 AM
- 992 Views
Re: The Tuatha'an are not Aiel.
05/04/2012 07:39:04 AM
- 903 Views
Re: The Tuatha'an are not Aiel.
05/04/2012 02:14:37 PM
- 1099 Views
Yes, I was thinking of the Aiel's suicidal traditions as well.
05/04/2012 06:24:56 PM
- 780 Views
Re: Yes, I was thinking of the Aiel's suicidal traditions as well.
06/04/2012 12:20:31 AM
- 891 Views
Re: The Tuatha'an are not Aiel.
06/04/2012 10:38:24 PM
- 1066 Views
Re: The Tuatha'an are not Aiel.
07/04/2012 06:27:27 AM
- 768 Views
Re: The Tuatha'an are not Aiel.
07/04/2012 07:23:03 PM
- 733 Views
So what you're saying...
07/04/2012 10:07:59 PM
- 678 Views
What I am saying is that it's not a "pure bloodline" that makes one an Aiel
08/04/2012 12:16:10 AM
- 789 Views
I never said it was.
08/04/2012 12:43:26 AM
- 844 Views
Actually you did In your above post you speak of the Tinkers as not Aiel because they have been
08/04/2012 06:09:01 AM
- 780 Views
No...
08/04/2012 07:12:22 AM
- 899 Views
You have no evidence that the Tuath'an are mostly comprised of runaways etc
08/04/2012 05:16:54 PM
- 862 Views
Re: You have no evidence that the Tuath'an are mostly comprised of runaways etc
08/04/2012 06:43:27 PM
- 887 Views
Re: You have no evidence that the Tuath'an are mostly comprised of runaways etc
08/04/2012 07:52:10 PM
- 680 Views
Red hair is double recessive ... Doesn't take much to eliminate it from the gene pool. There could
08/04/2012 11:22:36 PM
- 826 Views
You are consistently making the same mistake.
09/04/2012 02:45:46 AM
- 669 Views
They are the same thing. The remnant of a remnant are Aiel
10/04/2012 05:04:55 AM
- 808 Views
No. They are not.
10/04/2012 05:42:29 AM
- 707 Views
Never said the remnant of the remnant was the whole of the Aiel
10/04/2012 05:45:47 PM
- 714 Views
You said that redefining the Aiel would allow Aviendha's vision to be possible.
10/04/2012 06:53:51 PM
- 892 Views
No , I said there were many ways to interpret the statement based on how one defines Aiel
10/04/2012 07:36:11 PM
- 672 Views
All of which is entirely irrelevant.
10/04/2012 07:38:29 PM
- 683 Views
Actually it states he will save a remnant of a remnant
10/04/2012 07:47:04 PM
- 763 Views
Re: Actually it states he will save a remnant of a remnant
11/04/2012 01:40:36 AM
- 744 Views
That is what I just said
14/04/2012 01:41:56 AM
- 715 Views
What is important about that?
14/04/2012 04:35:55 AM
- 691 Views
The importance is that the prophesy says that Rand
14/04/2012 06:06:31 PM
- 859 Views
So what you're saying is...
14/04/2012 09:45:36 PM
- 729 Views
That's exactly it
14/04/2012 11:21:25 PM
- 809 Views
Good.
15/04/2012 02:01:14 AM
- 827 Views
He sets it in motion, thus his actions lead to it
15/04/2012 02:55:13 PM
- 695 Views
Yes, but in that case, he is responsible for everything, ever.
15/04/2012 05:29:31 PM
- 795 Views
We are interpreting Prophesy here ... Direct v. Indirect actions are what we are discussing
15/04/2012 07:21:29 PM
- 694 Views
Re: We are interpreting Prophesy here ... Direct v. Indirect actions are what we are discussing
17/04/2012 04:18:32 AM
- 864 Views
Depends on how you look at the Prophesy
18/04/2012 01:45:23 PM
- 647 Views
Of course, but the point of my example was...
17/04/2012 06:08:09 PM
- 679 Views
Where are you getting this happens over thousands of years?
18/04/2012 01:47:42 PM
- 679 Views