The Quickpoll today asks if Egwene will ever have a direct confrontation with a Forsaken. Of those who think she will, they say that Mesaana will be the likely choice.
I don't think this is possible. While the Forsaken always lose, RJ always has them against protagonists of equal power. Forsaken duels are almost exclusively limited to Rand and Nynaeve - both of whom can match the Forsaken in power. Other Forsaken duelists have included Alivia (who exceeds Nynaeve), circles of channelers at the cleansing, and Moiraine with balefire (the great equalizer).
Egwene has never claimed to be able to match the Forsaken, and Moiraine thought it would take Egwene and Aviendha to match one. In fact, Egwene said she would never come close to Nynaeve, and that people should know their limitations. Elayne has similar thoughts, citing that should could never have matched Moghedien like Nynaeve did. If you think about, Egwene would be instant road kill for a lethal enemy like Mesaana, if Mesaana even decided to kill her immediately. She's probably got enough skill and power to toy with Egwene.
It's possible that Egwene gets her hands on an angreal, or starts using balefire - but I don't think that will happen. My theory is that she will kill Cyndane in a duel in Tel'aran'rhiod. Egwene has spent much of the series building up her major Talent there, but hasn't had the opportunity to put it to any good use. In TAR, Egwene is a direct match for Cyndane where her skill is near to top-notch, but where she can never hope to face Cyndane in the real world. It's also possible that we'll have a mass battle with Egwene and the Wise Ones on one side, and Moridin/Cyndane/Moghedien on the other in TAR.
Anyone else support this idea?
I don't think this is possible. While the Forsaken always lose, RJ always has them against protagonists of equal power. Forsaken duels are almost exclusively limited to Rand and Nynaeve - both of whom can match the Forsaken in power. Other Forsaken duelists have included Alivia (who exceeds Nynaeve), circles of channelers at the cleansing, and Moiraine with balefire (the great equalizer).
Egwene has never claimed to be able to match the Forsaken, and Moiraine thought it would take Egwene and Aviendha to match one. In fact, Egwene said she would never come close to Nynaeve, and that people should know their limitations. Elayne has similar thoughts, citing that should could never have matched Moghedien like Nynaeve did. If you think about, Egwene would be instant road kill for a lethal enemy like Mesaana, if Mesaana even decided to kill her immediately. She's probably got enough skill and power to toy with Egwene.
It's possible that Egwene gets her hands on an angreal, or starts using balefire - but I don't think that will happen. My theory is that she will kill Cyndane in a duel in Tel'aran'rhiod. Egwene has spent much of the series building up her major Talent there, but hasn't had the opportunity to put it to any good use. In TAR, Egwene is a direct match for Cyndane where her skill is near to top-notch, but where she can never hope to face Cyndane in the real world. It's also possible that we'll have a mass battle with Egwene and the Wise Ones on one side, and Moridin/Cyndane/Moghedien on the other in TAR.
Anyone else support this idea?
I personally think this would start as a trap for Rand, with Egwene and maybe the Wise Ones catching on and stepping in.
Otherwise, I prefer the idea of Birgitte being involved instead of the Wise Ones to make it 3 on 3 and give her a chance for revenge on Moghedien.
Egwene will face a Forsaken
25/09/2009 01:58:34 PM
- 965 Views
Yes, I agree with your idea
25/09/2009 02:17:39 PM
- 543 Views
Those 3 Forsaken would
25/09/2009 04:29:18 PM
- 524 Views
I don't agree
25/09/2009 04:34:22 PM
- 514 Views
Since when in this series has someone admitted they are inferior
26/09/2009 03:27:12 AM
- 430 Views
Egwene stands lower than Moggy?
26/09/2009 05:18:42 AM
- 473 Views
Re: Egwene stands lower than Moggy?
27/09/2009 03:42:01 AM
- 420 Views
In tSR, Lanfear offered to Rand to frighten the Wise Ones out of TAR permanently...
26/09/2009 07:44:06 AM
- 754 Views
Re: In tSR, Lanfear offered to Rand to frighten the Wise Ones out of TAR permanently...
26/09/2009 03:37:37 PM
- 438 Views