This is entirely subjective and may not be representative of women in general, but the whole way Galad was portrayed felt wrong to me. It was like a man describing a stunningly gorgeous woman who happened to be a man.
I'm not saying that women aren't attracted to looks, of course we are, but it's not as important to us as I think it is to guys. Confidence, charisma and personality are moreso. A guy with 'ugly' features can still be attractive to women if he has those qualities. And what jarred with me was the fact that all the women who encountered Galad were swooning over him based on looks alone.
I would have a much easier time believing the universal attractiveness of someone like Rahvin - described as handsome and commanding - or even Logain, confident and dangerous, than I would Galad, who's just pretty.
I'm not saying that women aren't attracted to looks, of course we are, but it's not as important to us as I think it is to guys. Confidence, charisma and personality are moreso. A guy with 'ugly' features can still be attractive to women if he has those qualities. And what jarred with me was the fact that all the women who encountered Galad were swooning over him based on looks alone.
I would have a much easier time believing the universal attractiveness of someone like Rahvin - described as handsome and commanding - or even Logain, confident and dangerous, than I would Galad, who's just pretty.
Because unless you're like Birghitte and like ugly youre going to be atracted to what ammounts to the whole package. A incredible face is an incredible face even if you aren't used to those features. I will say there are "racial" features that might come into play but that's all a matter of exposure and even then those "features" can have a perfect representation. the perfect hawknose is just as good as the perfect button nose. clear complexion is clear complexion. Proportion is proportion
In fact because there does not seem to be any racism in Randland I would say that assigning unattractiveness to a regional feature like a wide nose or a high forehead could not exist
In fact because there does not seem to be any racism in Randland I would say that assigning unattractiveness to a regional feature like a wide nose or a high forehead could not exist
So, this business of Galad being described as so beautiful that women swoon over him at every turn. Quite literally, if they're female and not related to him, we're told that his smile will put butterflies in their stomachs, that they'll find yourself smiling back, helplessly. When he's in the room, they're half-hypnotised, they can't look away, other men fade into the background. Innocent country girls are dazzled. Happily married women have thoughts they shouldn't. He is just that good-looking.
Um, what? Do men like this actually exist? (or women, for that matter?) Surely no one is universally attractive, as Galad is described as being? Have you ever encountered anyone like this? What was RJ trying to achieve with it?
Um, what? Do men like this actually exist? (or women, for that matter?) Surely no one is universally attractive, as Galad is described as being? Have you ever encountered anyone like this? What was RJ trying to achieve with it?
Galad
- 05/10/2011 01:56:01 PM
1702 Views
to that degree, no
- 05/10/2011 03:38:44 PM
947 Views
Hugh Jackman is not sexy. *NM*
- 05/10/2011 10:13:48 PM
372 Views
Re: Hugh Jackman is not sexy. ??? You must be blind. *NM*
- 12/10/2011 10:24:41 PM
336 Views
He's very attractive in X-Men but otherwise not sexy (I'm not saying he's unattractive) *NM*
- 13/10/2011 12:48:12 AM
382 Views
*NM*
The man is sex on legs!!! *NM*
- 13/10/2011 05:45:55 PM
367 Views
*NM*
I think they exist
- 05/10/2011 07:09:20 PM
841 Views
Re: I think they exist
- 05/10/2011 11:28:26 PM
794 Views
You think Galad doesn't have confidence?
- 06/10/2011 02:11:25 AM
662 Views
Galad = Gary Stu
- 06/10/2011 04:35:55 PM
653 Views
I don't know.
- 06/10/2011 08:13:25 PM
743 Views
Yep. Rand, Mat, Perrin, Egwene, Elayne, Aviendha and Nynaeve are all members of the Stu species.
- 14/10/2011 03:35:23 PM
580 Views
It's meant to be funny
- 06/10/2011 11:40:51 PM
767 Views
Excellent points, hadn't really thought of that before. I agree. *NM*
- 07/10/2011 02:29:43 PM
311 Views
If he looked like this guy...
- 07/10/2011 12:31:49 AM
843 Views
I'm just curious as to whether any other culture's women have seen Galad.
- 12/10/2011 08:47:05 PM
635 Views
for some reason I have the feeling we've seen a Seanchan appraisal
- 13/10/2011 03:33:55 PM
675 Views
And I think Birgitte appraised him, as well, but wasn't falling all over herself due to her tastes *NM*
- 13/10/2011 03:57:51 PM
298 Views
Cars look both ways before he crosses the street. Alien abductors asked him to probe them. *NM*
- 13/10/2011 08:13:12 PM
315 Views