I think RJ was conflicted between the need to keep the story PG while also not wanting to minimize the horrors of war (since he was very familiar with that). I think he chose specifically not to focus on those aspects, but you can see that he's very aware.
You mentioned the Novices who very probably died in the White Tower conflict. And you're right, someone intent on showing the horrors of war would definitely have shown that. What Egwene said was a rationalization, the true reason for her destroying all the to'raken was not to spare the captives the horror of the a'dam, but to prevent the knowledge of Traveling reaching the Seanchan. I like to think that had RJ written this scene, the moral and emotional aspect of this would have been covered, if not the graphic details of the deaths.
On the other hand, we have seen children die on screen. The most obvious example being of the child that Rand tries to tragically bring back to life in tSR. While we don't really get all the details of her injuries (which is unnecessary, IMO), Rand's anguish is well captured, and his reaction spot on, IMO.
I think if someone translated WoT for the screen and stayed true to the books, they would inevitably have to show a lot of blood and gore. Jordan didn't describe those things much, but they are very much present.
You mentioned the Novices who very probably died in the White Tower conflict. And you're right, someone intent on showing the horrors of war would definitely have shown that. What Egwene said was a rationalization, the true reason for her destroying all the to'raken was not to spare the captives the horror of the a'dam, but to prevent the knowledge of Traveling reaching the Seanchan. I like to think that had RJ written this scene, the moral and emotional aspect of this would have been covered, if not the graphic details of the deaths.
On the other hand, we have seen children die on screen. The most obvious example being of the child that Rand tries to tragically bring back to life in tSR. While we don't really get all the details of her injuries (which is unnecessary, IMO), Rand's anguish is well captured, and his reaction spot on, IMO.
I think if someone translated WoT for the screen and stayed true to the books, they would inevitably have to show a lot of blood and gore. Jordan didn't describe those things much, but they are very much present.
Combat in the World of the Wheel
03/06/2011 04:34:02 AM
- 1572 Views
Well, Healing screws things up a bit. But Rand at the end of tGH comes to mind
03/06/2011 05:20:57 AM
- 966 Views
You mean tGH *NM*
03/06/2011 11:13:04 AM
- 516 Views
Of course I did! And that's what I typed
05/06/2011 09:12:45 AM
- 751 Views
I find all of the non-channeling related combat implausible and over-dramatic
03/06/2011 03:51:35 PM
- 1079 Views
Gotta diagree
03/06/2011 06:22:52 PM
- 822 Views
The aftermath - but I don't think he really showed the chaos on a battlefield that well
03/06/2011 07:19:20 PM
- 723 Views
That doesn't make them unrealistic...
03/06/2011 08:30:05 PM
- 724 Views
I think it does make them unrealistic. Stylistic choices determine how these scenes are conveyed.
03/06/2011 09:24:21 PM
- 924 Views
Ummm...
03/06/2011 09:55:46 PM
- 772 Views
Come to think of it...
04/06/2011 05:16:55 AM
- 940 Views
I think...
04/06/2011 06:31:17 AM
- 708 Views
WoT combat scenes are highly overrated. The non-OP fight scenes aresn't even scenes at all
11/06/2011 12:59:50 AM
- 724 Views