Please distinguish between the publisher's hopes and Jordan's intent. You ignore RJ's character too.
newyorkersedai Send a noteboard - 14/03/2011 10:46:58 PM
The publishing house, Tor, may have wanted to reissue the first six books and add new material and make lots of cash. I'm sure they'd love to have WoT plushies and bobbleheads and spin-off books written by Timothy Zahn, also.
You confuse the goals of a profit-minded corporation with those of Jordan, however. This doesn't seem right at all, conflating them both as if you were saying that Robert Rodriguez had the same goals for making a movie as the Weinstein brothers and Miramax (when they owned that studio). The last example involves 3, maybe 2, players, all of whom might have different agendas/intentions/etc.
More importantly, though, you ignore everything we know about RJ. You could say that his WoT material doesn't necessarily reflect his ethics, but the man also wrote a lot of Q&A and other material, and his attitude and world-view come across neatly in *those* writings...
You could tell by the way RJ expressly limited the number of "outrigger" books he intended to write. He specifically disclaimed writing about the AoL because he felt he'd already said everything he wanted to say about it. A money-grubber, like George Lucas, for example, would not have been satisfied in that way. There would've been the WoT version of "Yo Da Man" cups at Burger King...
Simply put, RJ was not in any way the sort of person who would stretch out a series just to make more cash. Even putting aside my (and others' sense of his character as a person and an author, you can look at other factors:
(a) RJ had already made a mint off this series, so he didn't need to scrounge for more; (b) RJ already had at least one further series in the planning stages, and he was eager to move on to it when he could; (c) RJ was the sort of writer who would not have seen any advantage, from a quality perspective, to making his series longer just to sell more books.
In fact, on point (c) alone, RJ might have stood firm - stretching it out for any other reason than telling the story "properly" would have been deemed wasteful and probably harmful.
You confuse the goals of a profit-minded corporation with those of Jordan, however. This doesn't seem right at all, conflating them both as if you were saying that Robert Rodriguez had the same goals for making a movie as the Weinstein brothers and Miramax (when they owned that studio). The last example involves 3, maybe 2, players, all of whom might have different agendas/intentions/etc.
More importantly, though, you ignore everything we know about RJ. You could say that his WoT material doesn't necessarily reflect his ethics, but the man also wrote a lot of Q&A and other material, and his attitude and world-view come across neatly in *those* writings...
You could tell by the way RJ expressly limited the number of "outrigger" books he intended to write. He specifically disclaimed writing about the AoL because he felt he'd already said everything he wanted to say about it. A money-grubber, like George Lucas, for example, would not have been satisfied in that way. There would've been the WoT version of "Yo Da Man" cups at Burger King...
Simply put, RJ was not in any way the sort of person who would stretch out a series just to make more cash. Even putting aside my (and others' sense of his character as a person and an author, you can look at other factors:
(a) RJ had already made a mint off this series, so he didn't need to scrounge for more; (b) RJ already had at least one further series in the planning stages, and he was eager to move on to it when he could; (c) RJ was the sort of writer who would not have seen any advantage, from a quality perspective, to making his series longer just to sell more books.
In fact, on point (c) alone, RJ might have stood firm - stretching it out for any other reason than telling the story "properly" would have been deemed wasteful and probably harmful.
How Many Books Would AMoL Have Been If Jordan Had Not Passed Away?
11/03/2011 01:06:18 PM
- 1943 Views
5, but I enjoy the series so much that 15 would have been fine with me. *NM*
11/03/2011 03:24:32 PM
- 349 Views
One, he said it himself every time.
11/03/2011 11:03:00 PM
- 940 Views
I think he only said that bc he knew his health was failing *NM*
22/03/2011 04:43:49 PM
- 345 Views
No, he had other projects he wanted to do. He wanted to warp it up and move on. *NM*
22/03/2011 05:00:53 PM
- 332 Views
If Jordan had not gotten sick in the first place or just if he hadn't died?
11/03/2011 11:11:26 PM
- 951 Views
Not in a million years...
12/03/2011 07:33:53 PM
- 1042 Views
Why do you persist in this fiction?
13/03/2011 01:48:06 AM
- 884 Views
Me? It's you who's built up a fiction
13/03/2011 07:43:16 PM
- 931 Views
No. Once again, accelerating the pace is not the same as finishing in one more book.
14/03/2011 03:02:46 PM
- 789 Views
Please distinguish between the publisher's hopes and Jordan's intent. You ignore RJ's character too.
14/03/2011 10:46:58 PM
- 793 Views
Re: Not in a million years...
15/03/2011 10:27:12 AM
- 914 Views