I cannot remember Semirhage's reference to a paralis net, but if she did do so, it is problematic...
Shannow Send a noteboard - 04/01/2011 07:31:24 AM
The paralis net is what unravels weaves similar to Mat's foxhead medallion. And it apparantly contains a small Well of the Power as well. Demandred never encountered this at the Cleansing.
I know Demandred commented on a single and specific ter'angreal among the collection, but my impression from Rand's comment (as he knows about the saidin/saidar detectors) was that ter'angreal detecting inverted weaves of saidin and saidar were likely part of a "paralis net", and that the gizmos Rand didn't recognize were more likely the same ones Cadsuane has no idea what they're supposed to do.
What he reasoned out was that Rand's party had a ter'angreal that detected reversed webs of saidin - something which was apparantly not yet in existence during the War of Power.
It sounds doubtful that the WOS paralis nets were solely a weavebreaker and a well, as the detection of reversed weaves are such a major component of the apparatus. That doesn't sound right somehow. It would, if Rand implied a paralis net was actually the name of a "weavebreaker", but he really implied it was an assortement of various defensive ter'angreal, including a well.
There's Aran'gar's utter surprise in Salidar at the fact Mat had a weavebreaker too - since they existed in his time - but I guess this falls under the same scathing remark Osan'gar made about her comment re: the AK having been destroyed.
On another note. I agree with your logic regarding Cyndane's vastly greater skillset to Alivia's. This allowed her to match a channeler 4 times her strength.
This is entirely feasible. What is NOT feasible, however, is Moghedien not being able to do the same with Nynaeve in tSR.
This at a time when Nynaeve only equalled Moghedien's strength, and when Nynaeve's channeling skill was still VASTLY inferior to that of even Alivia.
The Nynaeve/Moghedien encounter is simply utterly unrealistic. Especially when seen in the context of the Lanfear/Alivia battle.
This is entirely feasible. What is NOT feasible, however, is Moghedien not being able to do the same with Nynaeve in tSR.
This at a time when Nynaeve only equalled Moghedien's strength, and when Nynaeve's channeling skill was still VASTLY inferior to that of even Alivia.
The Nynaeve/Moghedien encounter is simply utterly unrealistic. Especially when seen in the context of the Lanfear/Alivia battle.
I agree. I don't find many of the early OP battles "realistic". The only way I could find to rationalize the way Moghedien handled Nynaeve is that:
- She was really surprised by her strength, when all the rumours she would have heard placed the current Age's AS way, way below that. That was apparently wrong, so in the heat of the moment she may have decided not to trust anymore her information about their skills either.
- Then, Moghedien may not have wanted to be the one to start using lethal weaves and reversed webs (the way any sensible Forsaken would have done in her place) in fear Nynaeve would immediately react by switching to those too.
But that's still weak... Even if she was completely inept in a face-off, Moghedien should have dealt with Nynaeve with ease. We know she can be fast when she wants. A few feint attacks then nasty reversed surprises or balefire should have done the deal easily.
I'm no more impressed with the performance of Asmodean against Rand, and what are we to believe about Aran'gar's skills after her absence of performance at the Eye of the World? The nasty fighter who could face a mixed gender circle and kill Eben is hardly recognizable in early Balthamel.
Be'lal was also incredibly idiotic, and no amount of AOL culture can really make it "realistic". Starting a blade duel, what was the idiot thinking of, really? Anyone even remotely sensible would have knocked Rand down then compelled him to take and give him Callandor, or put the hand of the inconscious Rand on Callandor.
Ishamael's mixed TP/TAR duel against Rand with Callandor was the first somewhat believable one (and I still believe Callandor cannot stop balefire and that's what caught the more and more exhausted Ishamael by surprise when it did... it did defeat his balefire because Rand was in TAR, and used the sword to splice the balefire... which by the force of his will it did. The way Perrin has done the same in TOM somewhat reinforced my old opinion. Balefire was a last ditch solution for Ishamael when he seemed clearly on the verge of defeat, as it would have reduced or eliminated the DO's opportunity for seizing Rand's soul).
The duel with Rahvin was OK, more or less. The one with Sammael was fairly poor, boring the minute they left Illian. On the whole I think the Cleansing was fine, and in part I think it's because Jordan opted for leaving most of the fighting to the readers' own imagination.
I sort of like the confrontations with Semirhage, especially now it's confirmed ordered her to make this attempt, and she was under death-threat style strict orders not to harm him, and accounting for the fact she had sul'dam she didn't control with her. Her plan always made perfect sense to me. She invited Rand to bring female channellers, because she wanted them to confirm the puny little girlish couldn't-harm-a-fly-even-if-she-wished-to Tuon could not channel. Clearly, she expected Rand to believe the sole threat were the damane, and agreed to let his people and the damane watch each other and the woodhouse in which Semirhage and Rand would "negotiate". She wanted to take Rand by surprise in the woodhouse and Skim or Travel (if she had secretely come to the place before to learn the grounds) with him right away. For the rest, her lack of information is typical of the Chosen. If she didn't face the weavebreakers at the Cleansing, it's not Demandred nor Cyndane who would have told her (nor Moridin) Rand's inner circle had some, nor of course would Semirhage have piped a word to Demandred about her mission.
Her capture of Rand was cool.
I didn't like Mesaana's demise too much, because I think the dialogue between Egwene and Mesaana destroyed its realism. That Egwene would explain to Mesaana about the a'dam etc. just didn't work for me, and felt almost comedic, where the villain or hero start talking to his foe and gets foiled. It would have worked much better had Egwene simply realized this in her head and struck without warning. The whole episode left me a bit cold. I didn't really liked how in Brandon's hands Egwene seemed to regress in her TAR skills, though I start to get the feeling that in Jordan's mind she and the WO were not meant to be TAR super-fighters, that the lethal TAR killers he had in mind are to be Perrin and the wolves (and that dead wolves are in TAR as guardians/hunters). Egwene and the WO's real skills are in other areas. I also get more and more the feeling that some revelation is coming about the real speculated purpose of TAR in the cosmologt. I think it's more and more obvious a dreamwalker or Dreamer is meant to be onobstrusive, and that there are several things which are "unethical" to do in TAR, in the sense that it interferes with the Wheel or the real purpose of TAR. Entering in the flesh as if it were the real world seems to be one of those, and tampering with people's dreams in harmful ways, creating mass nightmares, killing people or animals in TAR etc. are all "evil". The wolves seem to think this way: they could hunt, but they should not kill in TAR. Egwene's skills (and the WO) seems to come from passivity/receptivity/contemplation/introspection, and more and more I wonder if holding to a non-obstrusive/ethical attitude in their interaction with TAR doesn't play a big role in a Dreamer's skills, a kind of sine qua non condition to increasing your oracular skills.
Oh well... the door is wide open for some exposition regarding TAR soon. Not only there's the dreamspike's working to explain at some point down the line (and how exactly does TAR relate to the Pattern and to Gateways) and Rand knows Egwene is a dreamwalker, and she's bound to make a big deal of her Dream about the Seals soon, likely it's the big ace in her sleeve she intends to bring up in public at the meeting. It will be interesting to see if any of the WO Dreamer has had corroborating or contradicting Dream since, and if Min will or won't have related Viewings during the reunion. LTT is bound to have opinions about TAR, and Dreaming that might challenge what Third Agers and by extension us believe about TAR.... but well... LTT is bound to have opinions and knowledge about a whole load of things we would wish to know but there won't be place or time to fit in the last book. But TAR? I wouldn't bet on it. We know the Da'shain Aiel women's ties to Dreaming go all the way back to the AOL (as the Da'shain leader asks his wife about the Dream in one of the flashback scenes, or she comments to him about the Dream, I don't recall) and the issue of the Da'shain Aiel and LTT is one certain to surface before the end. His real relationship to the Da'shain, and why they were the CoD and all that if one of the big remaining back story mysteries. Rhuidean didn't reveal to the Aiel this part of their past - merely that they were once bound to LTT somehow, but LTT knows what it's really all about. Rand is also bound to do something about the Tinkers around Ebou Dar. He wasn't brought to shelter among them, and receive a cloak as a gift before his epiphany from Leafers for no reason. Symbolically, the Tinkers have dressed up Rand in his "true colours", and he's decided to keep wearing that cloak, and now things grow around him where he walks and he keeps saying he will guide but the LB isn't his battle. It's rather obvious LTT has been reminded of something by the Leafers, something he understood after his epiphany. Behind all this hide the reasons why the Da'shain were called the Children of the Dragon, and why Rand chose to keep the cloak they gave him. Rand's not done with the Tinkers, but this is probably waiting for Aviendha's return and her devastating vision of the future of the Aiel (which may take some time before it reaches Rand's ears... I expect her and the WO to keep this secret a while) to surface.
If Semirhage did make reference to a weave unravelling ter'angreal that existed during the War of Power, then we have Lanfear (a one Power researcher) and Balthamel never having heard of it while Semirhage and Lews Therin had heard of it before.
Strange. Where did she make this reference? Was it during her captivity in tGS?
How did Cyndane defeat Alivia?
31/12/2010 08:03:39 PM
- 3474 Views
As RJ said, Cyndane knows a LOT more about the OP
31/12/2010 08:33:47 PM
- 1559 Views
Re: As RJ said, Cyndane knows a LOT more about the OP
31/12/2010 11:54:57 PM
- 1317 Views
RJ said this .. Go look at his quotes *NM*
01/01/2011 05:59:37 AM
- 843 Views
Re: RJ said this .. Go look at his quotes
01/01/2011 06:43:09 AM
- 1163 Views
Dude, he calls it out specifically. Cyndane beat Alivia because of her skill
01/01/2011 03:22:48 PM
- 1177 Views
Search for "Alivia"
01/01/2011 05:58:53 PM
- 1106 Views
nothing on either url *NM*
01/01/2011 11:02:05 PM
- 515 Views
Try spelling it correctly then
02/01/2011 01:30:23 AM
- 1056 Views
Here are few other quotes establishing how little Alivia knows of the OP
02/01/2011 07:39:36 PM
- 1123 Views
Damane don't know about reversed weaves
31/12/2010 09:56:51 PM
- 1218 Views
How did *Alivia* survive?
01/01/2011 12:45:29 AM
- 1362 Views
Re: How did *Alivia* survive?
01/01/2011 01:26:09 AM
- 1162 Views
Yes, odd.
01/01/2011 01:45:01 AM
- 1095 Views
Nicola wasn't the dragon reborn with the pattern bending around her
02/01/2011 12:24:50 PM
- 976 Views
Not really ... Rand has had LTT knowledge leaking into his head for a long time
02/01/2011 07:13:41 PM
- 985 Views
reversed weaves are only useful when dealing with someone who doesn't know they exist.
03/01/2011 07:51:01 PM
- 902 Views
Depends on the circumstances really
04/01/2011 02:17:29 PM
- 1038 Views
but why would she have any idea that Nynaeve would be able to resist her.
10/01/2011 07:30:49 PM
- 1010 Views
Well she did get attacked right off the bat... Pretty indicative that Nyn resist her compulsion
11/01/2011 12:56:51 AM
- 966 Views
Exactly. which is why she didn't have time to do any "fancy" and time consuming reversing.
11/01/2011 03:23:50 PM
- 1113 Views
It would be these memories, his t'a'veren nature & sheer luck/plot necessity that gave him the edge
03/01/2011 10:32:43 PM
- 1024 Views
Well that was always going to happen
03/01/2011 11:41:22 PM
- 970 Views
Yes. As I said, it would have been a very different series. Thanks for going into detail !
04/01/2011 04:47:51 PM
- 933 Views
Small correction - It has not been established that Alivia is stronger than Cyndane unaided...
02/01/2011 06:02:53 PM
- 966 Views
Alivia has little experience fighting channellers, unlike Lanfear (most likely)...
03/01/2011 12:56:43 AM
- 1317 Views
Demandred wasn't commenting on Cadsuane's paralis net, but on her little bird saidin detector...
03/01/2011 07:01:08 AM
- 1102 Views
Where do you get this idea? *NM*
03/01/2011 07:19:50 PM
- 581 Views
Well, he's definitely right he was commenting on one of the specific ter'angreal in her "net".
03/01/2011 10:51:09 PM
- 1047 Views
I'm thinking there are 2 items that break webs in different ways
04/01/2011 07:51:46 PM
- 1003 Views
Very interesting point. I never noticed that before...
05/01/2011 08:02:52 AM
- 959 Views
Cadsuane has two types of weavebreakers...
05/01/2011 12:51:38 PM
- 879 Views
inconclusive ... the ornament may be the same one she used to disrupt Semirhage
05/01/2011 04:09:39 PM
- 952 Views
I'm confused...
05/01/2011 06:15:06 PM
- 929 Views
Why should Cadsuane's "distance" unraveler not also go cold at nearby channeling?
05/01/2011 06:51:49 PM
- 928 Views
I'd buy this.
05/01/2011 07:12:50 PM
- 893 Views
Except Cyndane had never heard of a ter'angreal that can unravel weaves...
05/01/2011 07:18:58 PM
- 836 Views
Not necessarily.
05/01/2011 09:26:49 PM
- 945 Views
I doubt it since LTT claims they created the "first" ones in the AOL
08/01/2011 05:23:53 PM
- 894 Views
The first paralis nets, not necessarily the first weave breakers.
09/01/2011 09:53:56 PM
- 946 Views
Maybe, but that's getting really convoluted
10/01/2011 03:36:17 AM
- 818 Views
Agreed
10/01/2011 05:14:45 PM
- 904 Views
I don't remember if the AS Symbol was used prior to the AOL ... if so then it's possible *NM*
10/01/2011 05:55:38 PM
- 522 Views
Because Demandred said so...
04/01/2011 07:28:56 AM
- 969 Views
Re: Because Demandred said so...
04/01/2011 08:45:38 AM
- 1000 Views
Well there you have it, then...
04/01/2011 09:24:38 AM
- 867 Views
Contortions
04/01/2011 09:56:11 AM
- 7826 Views
If anyone made a mistake, it was Sanderson, not RJ.
04/01/2011 10:07:30 AM
- 859 Views
Re: If anyone made a mistake, it was Sanderson, not RJ.
04/01/2011 10:35:45 AM
- 1045 Views
I don't think Rand is referring to the system as an indivisible whole.
04/01/2011 10:45:24 AM
- 978 Views
Besides, he knew of the Well from their previous visit to Far Madding...
04/01/2011 11:18:39 AM
- 968 Views
It's also possible that a Paralis Net is simply a name for any personal system
04/01/2011 09:23:18 PM
- 1100 Views
Re: Demandred wasn't commenting on Cadsuane's paralis net, but on her little bird saidin detector...
03/01/2011 10:01:00 PM
- 998 Views
I cannot remember Semirhage's reference to a paralis net, but if she did do so, it is problematic...
04/01/2011 07:31:24 AM
- 925 Views
I had the opposite view of the WO Dreamwalkers vs the Wolves in the Wolf-dream
04/01/2011 05:07:56 PM
- 1019 Views