The test of the shawl is one-dimensional, but so are most Aes Sedai. As you said, they don't have the OP skills that they could if it weren't for this test. But, I wonder... did they decide to keep this test after the Trolloc Wars because they wanted AS to be so similar, or is it just unintended consequence?
The Trolloc Wars were a three-century war, without a clear cut but rather a very dragged out finish, most likely.
After the trauma of that war, and no foreknowledge that this wouldn't come again sooner than later, it would make sense there were factions in the Tower that were adamant that this sort of testing should become the permanent norm by which the qualifications of a woman for the shawl were measured. Between the lines, it appears the White Tower was far from ready for the Trolloc Wars. They had just gone through five centuries of a sort of Renaissance, with near global peace and a rise in the Tower's standing in the world (the Covenant of Ten Nations was the work of the Grey Mabriam en Sheered). They may very well have become a bit complacement about the Shadow, a little too self-assured that a new Golden Age was right on the corner.
This ter'angreal would be put to much better use training sisters in the art of combat than for any testing... It would make sense for the Yellows with the proper personalities to go through this sort of training, so they could act as battlefield medics. For most Yellows, this is useless - very few Aes Sedai ever sees a battlefield in their life. It's not learning under threat they need, it's gaining the experience to perform healing even in difficult conditions.
As Nynaeve implied in her criticism, a great deal of the test was about putting her in situations where she should have made a judgement call whether she should help or not. except the universal answer was always she had to detach herself from everything, to go perform useless weaves. The thing is, the greater purpose for Nyaneve in most of these situations was to use her skills to help the people, not to abandon them!
What it looks to me is that this test was originally targeted at an ingrained mentality, an AOL revival during the Covenant, that Aes Sedai were to be servants of all whenever they could. With the Trolloc Wars, the Tower had to drill into the sisters and the recruits that they had to abandon this mentality because the decision had been made that the whole Tower's priority was to survive and fight the war and that for now that would be the only way in which the sisters would serve all. This test was good to determine which sisters and recruits were "hard" enough to cope with this. It's a fairly good test to separate those who would make good soldiers from those who wouldn't.
My hunch is that the "aloofness" of the Green Ajah dates back from the aftermath of the Trolloc Wars. I bet the Ajah was unready for the Trolloc Wars, and sort of promised themselves that in the future they would stand aside from the day-to-day fight with the Shadow (Blight etc.) to be ready for another general attack, be it another TW or Tarmon Gai'don. It maybe from this era that came the apparent mentality that a Green Sister ought to do not much else than train, get many warders, let them train and together "stand ready".
One problem with this is that most of the Tower post-TW seems to have adopted this mentality that Aes Sedai should "stand aside", instead of spreading out and be servants of all. They played the Shadow's game doing this. Over the centuries, this new mentality of a Tower frightened not to be ready for another Trolloc Warsand holding itself in reserve became detachement and aloofness and the loss of the service mentality. The Aes Sedai tend to now see themselves as too valuable for the world to serve the world. Today's AS tend to see what their AOL predecessors considered their duty and mission above all else as "menial jobs" below their standing. They don't build, they don't work at technological advances, they don't look for ways to bring progress or better the general living of anyone, they don't touch the weather or help with crops, have not tought of ways to bring Healing to the population at large etc. They even loath selling stuff they make - sheesh... in the AOL it looks like the AS never tired up of inventing new things to send into mass production!
Instead of using their skills to the utmost on a daily basis, they all "stood ready" for this once in an Age mission, and over the centuries ironically they even let themselves become completely unready to face that, Tarmon Gai'don. As their value to people in general got lower and lower (most people spend their whole life without seing even the shadow of a service rendered them by a channeller), they became more and more obsessed with the rulers and politics. The most visible actions from the Tower for millenia now are strictly diplomatic and political. They placed all their efforts not on service, but on maintaining and increasing their standing and power over the rulers, through politics. It's now how they maintain their dominion: if you can't gain the respect and love of the masses, control those who rule the people and they'll have no choice to follow. It's no wonder the regular folk neither respect nor like them very much now - and barely know anything true about them.
You get the feeling that things were really different in the AOL. Aes Sedai were everywhere, and you could see tangible evidence of their service to society looking out of the window, or roasting your toasts in the morning. It's probably not LTT and the Hall that sought dominion during the war. Rather the people turned to the Aes Sedai, because they trusted them and found them the better equiped to lead the War. Not only that, but wartime calls for fast decisions and some sort of unique command, and no one was afraid to put the First Among the Servants in charge, and to let him supervise the politicians... LTT was not seen as a threat, political or otherwise.
In the New Era, few trust the AS, and few wants them in charge of anything - and all believe they will do their utmost to grab power and be in charge, and it's not altogether false... The mentality of today's AS is a complete travesty of their AOL counterparts', and yet they want all the respect and honour and influence that the people were freely granting the AS in LTT's times.
The Tower will need more and more sisters who think like Nynaeve and Elayne after TG, and could have used a revolution in this matter centuries ago... Even Egwene isn't seeing clearly enough what the Tower ought to be, or rather what the AS will need to do if they want to deserve the standing, power and respect Egwene wants to be theirs again. Among other things, it should include a gradual detachment from politics. The Tower should build up power not because the OP makes them powerful, but seek to increase its influence because they're so valuable to society it becomes unthinkable not to seek the opinion of the WT. The best way the WT could encourage peace isn't by playing politics with the rulers, it would be by providing invaluable services to every nation (Travelling, Healing, building, weather control, ter'angreal, agriculture... there's so much they could do) and make clear the WT will pull out all its Aes Sedai if a nation goes to war. Rulers would think twice before losing all this, crippling their economy and all by going to war, and that's where the Greys could come in to help settle conflicts peacefully. Etc. Of course, before the Tower could become such an organization, it needs to get the allegiance or an alliance with all the other channellers, or this will turn rapidly into pre-Empire Seanchan, with powerful channelers at war with one another and standing with different factions/nations. It's one of the main reason why the male and female channellers must become able to speak with one voice and belong to the same organization, and it's also important that Elayne's efforts to secure channellers for her nation and her nation alone be stopped and retought, before this escalates, with Tear or Illian making approaches to other groups, for instance the Asha'man, out of fear and jealousy of Andor.
Egwene really will have a lot on her plate post-TG.
Nynaeve's stupidity and the test for Aes Sedai
07/12/2010 08:27:05 PM
- 4289 Views
Way to totally misunderstand the chapter
07/12/2010 09:39:08 PM
- 1649 Views
I second this
07/12/2010 10:10:24 PM
- 1344 Views
your bold is stuck. *NM*
07/12/2010 10:21:22 PM
- 574 Views
On the whole, the test is innappropriate IMO
07/12/2010 09:40:08 PM
- 1468 Views
It's kind of a chicken and egg thing
07/12/2010 11:13:19 PM
- 1120 Views
Re: It's kind of a chicken and egg thing
08/12/2010 12:37:20 AM
- 1408 Views
nice post
08/12/2010 09:20:02 AM
- 1239 Views
Isn't it implied
08/12/2010 02:16:58 PM
- 1006 Views
no they were students together
08/12/2010 05:33:17 PM
- 956 Views
No, Lanfear was older than Lews
08/12/2010 07:21:45 PM
- 1179 Views
Where on earth did you get that from?
08/12/2010 08:41:16 PM
- 1108 Views
Re: Where on earth did you get that from?
09/12/2010 10:27:20 AM
- 1116 Views
Re: Where on earth did you get that from?
09/12/2010 03:56:32 PM
- 1190 Views
I always got the impression that they were together for quiet some time
09/12/2010 04:34:23 PM
- 1139 Views
Re: I always got the impression that they were together for quiet some time
09/12/2010 05:43:40 PM
- 1113 Views
I think skill with Saidar is easy enough to judge as it's a simple matter to see the skill
08/12/2010 05:37:27 PM
- 1039 Views
I think the greens should have been on Nynaeve's side as well
08/12/2010 06:18:16 PM
- 1158 Views
Problem is they are Aes Sedai and thus more likley to be political rather than rational! *NM*
08/12/2010 08:52:00 PM
- 809 Views
Re: nice post
09/12/2010 01:23:50 PM
- 1221 Views
On the matter of strength
09/12/2010 08:51:36 PM
- 1061 Views
Strength was "prized" in the AoL ... but lack of strength was not a negative
12/12/2010 01:41:08 AM
- 1022 Views
Yes. How dare she not conform with every other fucking mindless stupid WT Aes Sedai *NM*
07/12/2010 11:36:52 PM
- 656 Views
Status is not an end in itself. *NM*
07/12/2010 11:52:37 PM
- 528 Views
They're not really stupid...
08/12/2010 01:00:20 AM
- 1137 Views
Not saying they are. It's just that most AS that we've come across
08/12/2010 02:20:05 AM
- 838 Views
They're constantly outsmarted by a teenage girl that has spent most of her life in a damn farm.
08/12/2010 10:32:50 AM
- 1122 Views
Bah...
09/12/2010 10:56:24 AM
- 1158 Views
I did not say all Aes Sedai are stupid, I said all WT Aes Sedai are stupid.
10/12/2010 09:19:52 AM
- 1120 Views
You are not only wrong in your call,
08/12/2010 04:39:44 AM
- 1335 Views
Re: You are not only wrong in your call,
08/12/2010 09:13:37 AM
- 1352 Views
if that is the purpose of the test
08/12/2010 01:34:45 PM
- 1061 Views
minor disagreement
08/12/2010 05:27:51 PM
- 1136 Views
Yes, but you can be not-panicked and not calm of body
08/12/2010 06:38:56 PM
- 960 Views
not really the same thing as what the AS are getting at though
08/12/2010 09:02:05 PM
- 1610 Views
that's retarded, imo
09/12/2010 12:21:27 AM
- 1086 Views
Oh it's totally stupid!
09/12/2010 04:37:14 PM
- 1107 Views
No I know why she took the job. I just don't understand why she got it
09/12/2010 04:52:34 PM
- 1049 Views
I think Elaida just smarmed up at the right time, Morgase was very young then
09/12/2010 05:52:29 PM
- 1098 Views
Oh. Well, I'm sorry then.
08/12/2010 06:48:50 PM
- 1109 Views
I think it has already been established that the purpose of the test is to ensure that
08/12/2010 09:59:18 PM
- 854 Views
Yeah, but how does that work?
08/12/2010 10:24:35 PM
- 1015 Views
Somewhere in the sub-conscious they know what they're doing is important to them.
09/12/2010 12:20:47 AM
- 1125 Views
Even so, it wouldn't work.
09/12/2010 03:32:55 AM
- 1038 Views
I think if this thread has established anything it's that the test is severely flawed. *NM*
09/12/2010 09:24:48 PM
- 501 Views
Another headless chicken example.
09/12/2010 12:30:02 AM
- 1021 Views
the headless chicken is just such a lovely metaphor for panic *NM*
09/12/2010 04:48:11 AM
- 459 Views
Re: Oh. Well, I'm sorry then.
09/12/2010 12:07:15 PM
- 1110 Views
You seem to have no grasp of the difference between "politic" and "right"
09/12/2010 02:59:50 AM
- 1165 Views
Re: You seem to have no grasp of the difference between "politic" and "right"
09/12/2010 09:26:21 AM
- 1073 Views
That's not the dilema
09/12/2010 05:23:19 PM
- 1261 Views
One of those few times where I completely agree with Cannoli. Give over Sidious. You're wrong.
09/12/2010 09:55:20 PM
- 1052 Views
That's not what it's really about
10/12/2010 05:44:12 AM
- 1018 Views
This test, even by its usual abysmal standards, was idiotic. It bordered on being evil.
09/12/2010 03:46:31 AM
- 1019 Views
Re: This test, even by its usual abysmal standards, was idiotic. It bordered on being evil.
09/12/2010 09:40:09 AM
- 1112 Views
Re: This test, even by its usual abysmal standards, was idiotic. It bordered on being evil.
09/12/2010 02:04:02 PM
- 1418 Views
Re: This test, even by its usual abysmal standards, was idiotic. It bordered on being evil.
09/12/2010 11:26:40 AM
- 1142 Views
One of those few times where I completely agree with fionwe1987. Give over Sidious. You're wrong.
10/12/2010 03:53:25 PM
- 1121 Views