Like I said, you make a very good point, and I think that it would have been really good if they had combined the two, but, at least for me, it wouldn't have been as good as the original.
To each his own. I've tried to split the paragraphs, and personally I think it worked really awesomely, added a whole new "cosmic" dimension to the scene, as if nature itself, reality itself, was waiting on Rand's decision to go on or unravel. You had Perrin as witness to the possible end of the world, and shared this perspective on Rand with him. His description of the surroundings, with the vortex, the killing winds and the stones flying completed Rand's of the fire and smoke of Dragonmount. The whole scene felt even more epic and apocalyptic, and Rand's inner struggle was even more impressive at the end.
Beyond that we'd have many divergences of opinion, as I don't rate TGS nearly as high as you do. I though one of its problems was precisely how much it felt like one of the early books - and so late it the series it seemed too simple, the lack of secondary storylines reducing the scope when the story should at this point have gotten more and more epic and grand. In hindsight this was completely artificial, following the decision by Brandon to divide the books as he did: RJ never intended that return to the style of the early series. With the TOM content added to TGS, early AMOL would have read like a much darker, much more dramatic KOD. With Rand's epiphany coming as it should have only 2/3 into the final book, the first and second acts would have been very dark and oppressive, which on the eve of the LB would have been majestic. Only the Mat/Elayne storyline would have relieved that a bit.
Most of the darkness was saved in TGS, because the two storylines that were to be the core of acts 1-2 were told in there. Perrin's, Mat's, Aviendha's, the BT's were to add to this gloom and despair. Even Moiraine's rescue, on purpose frustrating delayed in Caemlyn by the Verin letter device, would have contributed, thanks to the red herring that she was badly, badly needed by Rand. Now it TOM, this suspense around Moiraine is ruined - you know going into the book that Min's Viewing has nothing to do with saving Rand from his growing, perhaps soon fatal darkness. That quite reduced the feeling of frustation caused by the delays in Caemlyn, and after you tell right at the beginning that Rand is preparing a crucial meeting... all that was left was the suspense of the episode of the rescue itself - all the urgency was gone. Instead of contributing to suspense and gloom, Verin's letter just became a device to delay the rescue until the climax of the book. Following RJ's chronology, it should have been a lot more dramatic than that, as until the epiphany you really should have been expecting Moiraine's crucial role to have something to do with helping Rand. The set up for this was even there... early in TGS Rand was speaking of Moiraine as the only AS he could trust.
Aviendha's visions in Rhuidean, also occuring before the epiphany timeline wise, were not as effective when told after super-Rand is around. A lot of things weren't.
Sure, TGS on the whole worked as faster paced book, but dividing the books this way brought massive changes to RJ's intents for the finale. It completely changed how we were supposed to perceive this part of the ending. It's really a big change, even though it probably had all the events planned by RJ. As I said elsewhere on this topic, a novel/story is much more than the sum of episodes/chapters. I've realized only with TOM how deeply the decision to tell acts 1-2 of AMOL by dividing them following storylines rather than chronology and themes has changed the whole thing, and as this is one aspects I used to enjoy massively when RJ was at the helm, despite pacing flaws and all, I'm really underwhelmed by the result.
Of course, I understand perfectly that people who long had problems with RJ's writing and the later books actually could prefer things this way, but I hope they understand too how frustrating it can be for someone who was enjoying the later books, especially KOD, and would have preferred Brandon to remain more respectful, or perhaps I should just say more faithful, to the series's style. In my perspective, it's very fundamental changes he's made by altering the structure. I had worries after TGS despite all that satisfied me in it, and TOM was kind of a surprise, a bad one, in how worse the book split had made things than I thought. I never quite expected to end up so frustrated at the whole thing, to be honest. Brandon in interviews and such spoke as if he was aware of some of the flaws in TGS and intended to remedy to that in the next book. He didn't. Some of those flaws, in the timelines, in editing, were much worse.
Whats with all the hate?
05/12/2010 03:46:29 PM
- 1871 Views
well it's a fan-site so we're nit-picky
05/12/2010 04:14:34 PM
- 1100 Views
Re: well it's a fan-site so we're nit-picky
05/12/2010 04:18:15 PM
- 955 Views
Sanderson just makes him too much of a clown for me
05/12/2010 04:21:34 PM
- 1099 Views
Re: Sanderson just makes him too much of a clown for me
05/12/2010 11:23:37 PM
- 982 Views
Yup, Sanderson has no subtly, or at least assumes that his readers have an IQ of 6.
06/12/2010 01:04:44 AM
- 895 Views
hater gotta hate! *strikes a pose* *NM*
05/12/2010 06:31:03 PM
- 444 Views
and lovers gotta love? Uncritically? *NM* *NM*
05/12/2010 08:22:13 PM
- 467 Views
Lovers can love and still be critical.
05/12/2010 08:46:40 PM
- 866 Views
This.
05/12/2010 09:19:24 PM
- 1105 Views
exactly. ToM had it's flaws, but it was still satisfying
05/12/2010 10:39:58 PM
- 860 Views
Re: exactly. ToM had it's flaws, but it was still satisfying
05/12/2010 11:15:46 PM
- 950 Views
If you don't find it acceptable, fine, but I do. reading is not objective.
05/12/2010 11:58:50 PM
- 941 Views
Re: If you don't find it acceptable, fine, but I do. reading is not objective.
06/12/2010 07:17:03 AM
- 1017 Views
Re: If you don't find it acceptable, fine, but I do. reading is not objective.
06/12/2010 12:10:30 PM
- 924 Views
Hate is such a strong word....
05/12/2010 07:35:04 PM
- 1195 Views
Re: Hate is such a strong word....
05/12/2010 08:25:23 PM
- 1074 Views
Re: Hate is such a strong word....
05/12/2010 09:07:27 PM
- 1263 Views
I agree with you on just about everything, but have you considered ...
05/12/2010 10:59:50 PM
- 962 Views
I'd love to see a re-edit of ToM and TGS
06/12/2010 01:10:00 AM
- 926 Views
Personally I don't get it. If I wanted to read Shakespeare I would've picked up Hamlet.
05/12/2010 08:24:04 PM
- 861 Views
Re: Personally I don't get it. If I wanted to read Shakespeare I would've picked up Hamlet.
05/12/2010 08:28:09 PM
- 974 Views
Yeah, what's wrong with the Hobbit?
05/12/2010 09:22:38 PM
- 1077 Views
*lol* You can still agree but not on everything!
05/12/2010 11:36:55 PM
- 971 Views
I liked the book alright, but I tend to talk about the good and exciting things first
06/12/2010 04:44:54 AM
- 939 Views
Hitler told the Jews ahead of time what he had planned for them: why are they so bitter?
06/12/2010 12:52:08 PM
- 1140 Views
Wow. I had no idea people felt this way.
07/12/2010 03:30:08 AM
- 1036 Views