Active Users:1105 Time:22/11/2024 02:18:43 PM
Um. Nate Send a noteboard - 01/12/2010 08:49:35 PM
This is one of the most ridiculous "analyses" I have read in a very long time.

You have no problem with the fact that Basel Gill was turned towards Lugard weeks before Graendal even came into possession of the Dreamspike? You do realise that this makes Perrin's entire plot in ToM collapse? What about the plethora of other continuity errors?


I believe "weeks" is an exaggeration, but Graendal already knew where Perrin was at that time, she just hadn't told Moridin yet. She's a planner, we all know that. She had already come up with the plan to ambush and kill Perrin, and so she would have started working on it by turning Gill. She thought it would work without the dreamspike; she told Moridin about it with confidence before she knew he had it. The dreamspike was not part of her plan until Moridin gave it to her, but she had the plan long before she got the dreamspike and Slayer. The dreamspike just didn't go in place until after Tam left.

I cannot respond to the last question in that paragraph unless you specify what continuity errors you mean. But the one about Graendal is not a continuity error.

You have no problem with the juvenile, childlike and hamfisted prose BS delivers? The constant bombardment of ridiculous and senseless metaphors given by the narrator? The fact that characters like Galad and Rodel Ituralde are completely out of character?


Please specify some of this "juvenile, childlike and hamfisted prose", because I didn't notice any. I've enjoyed Sanderson's prose far more than any of the prose Jordan had written since A Crown of Swords.

Care to name any ridiculous and senseless metaphors?

How is Galad out of character? As for Ituralde, to be honest, Knife of Dreams bored me so much that I don't really recall how he was characterized in it, compared to how he was characterized here, but I was fine with him.

You have no problem with the fact that every single supporting character has lost 50 IQ points, thereby being reduced to idiots set up in order to make Egwene look intelligent?


I don't see this one either. The other Aes Sedai have always been idiots. Gawyn has always seemed like a bit of an idiot to me too. Nynaeve didn't seem like an idiot to me. Elayne seemed like much less of an idiot than she did as written by Jordan, and since she still did some pretty dumb things that's saying something. I can't think of any other important supporting characters who interacted with Egwene. Again, please specify.

If so, you are not a very discerning reader.


You're so cute.
Warder to starry_nite

Chapterfish — Nate's Writing Blog
http://chapterfish.wordpress.com
This message last edited by Nate on 01/12/2010 at 08:49:54 PM
Reply to message
/tGS: These are damned good books. - 27/11/2010 02:22:05 AM 1392 Views
OK. *NM* - 27/11/2010 02:35:06 AM 296 Views
meh. ToM sucked for me. after tGS, I had become a bit hopeful, but now I see ... - 27/11/2010 03:39:49 AM 763 Views
You keep trying to make that nickname stick... - 27/11/2010 08:47:52 PM 759 Views
yeah!!..... - 27/11/2010 08:55:37 PM 681 Views
meh. - 27/11/2010 09:31:30 PM 629 Views
Yeah, they are - 27/11/2010 06:03:59 AM 694 Views
Disagree strongly on the time line issue - TOM showed what a mistake splitting by 'clusters' was IMO - 27/11/2010 07:24:55 AM 729 Views
Re: Disagree strongly on the time line issue - TOM showed what a mistake splitting by 'clusters' was - 27/11/2010 05:59:47 PM 629 Views
I agree with this as well. - 27/11/2010 06:31:37 PM 740 Views
Splitting it this way was the only realistic choice - 29/11/2010 01:58:52 PM 595 Views
Disagree - plus COT lacked almost anything full stop - 30/11/2010 12:03:24 AM 770 Views
Re: Disagree - plus COT lacked almost anything full stop - 30/11/2010 12:18:57 AM 633 Views
It will be better than CoT, sure, but still not good enough to appease most fans - 30/11/2010 06:20:38 PM 765 Views
In any case you can see why RJ wanted one book - 01/12/2010 01:41:56 AM 633 Views
BS style - 27/11/2010 07:25:38 AM 821 Views
That's the thing! If it was in its normal, Jordan paced writing, ... - 27/11/2010 08:52:05 AM 683 Views
Re: That's the thing! If it was in its normal, Jordan paced writing, ... - 27/11/2010 11:57:22 PM 669 Views
And you know how RJ would've outlined the books from where? - 28/11/2010 05:07:31 AM 672 Views
BURN! *NM* - 29/11/2010 01:20:21 AM 307 Views
Re: And you know how RJ would've outlined the books from where? - 29/11/2010 08:16:12 AM 593 Views
so...you're guessing. - 30/11/2010 08:08:14 PM 644 Views
Re: so...you're guessing. - 01/12/2010 08:08:41 PM 561 Views
My only problems are Mats sudden drop in literacy and the timeline. *NM* - 27/11/2010 11:51:25 AM 313 Views
Not so much - 27/11/2010 09:52:23 PM 780 Views
I agree with this - 27/11/2010 10:37:08 PM 609 Views
Have some question - 28/11/2010 05:38:42 AM 687 Views
Re: Have some question - 28/11/2010 05:54:10 PM 625 Views
Re: Have some question - 28/11/2010 06:19:30 PM 602 Views
Re: Have some question - 28/11/2010 06:50:40 PM 580 Views
Re: Have some question - 28/11/2010 07:01:38 PM 738 Views
Re: Have some question - 29/11/2010 09:13:17 AM 581 Views
You stole my putters name, btw. - 29/11/2010 01:14:47 PM 701 Views
I had no problem following the jumps. - 29/11/2010 05:05:01 PM 598 Views
Yeah, anyone who found this bad clearly hasn't read Catch 22 - 30/11/2010 04:38:12 AM 567 Views
I didn't have any problems either. *NM* - 30/11/2010 04:40:24 AM 313 Views

Reply to Message