Active Users:1179 Time:22/11/2024 10:31:22 PM
Don't blame you (and, thanks, now I don't have to sweat spoilers--and neither do you). Joel Send a noteboard - 29/11/2010 01:49:21 PM
I did think about that though as I read his post. I'm cool with that though, since I never liked Graendal anyway (*couWHOREgh* ). The deliberate deception of the fans is what wrankles with me.


Was Byar the whitecloack the hidden knife that would take Perrin by surprise?? And I'm not sure why she'd leave that dreamspike for so long in the same place. It wasn't like she needed it to keep Perrin in place while the whitecloacks still held hostages or were having his trial.

That's my take on Byar, yeah. Although it COULD still be Dain; both of them spent far too much time with Fain for me to ever be entirely comfortable with either, but Fain was a free agent by then so it's unlikely Graendal could use either of them much. Of course, we can always play the "we don't see the characters unless the author shows them" game and say Graendal did something to either or both of them off camera. Still seems kinda cheap, but I'm at a loss to explain how Graendal could've used any of the Whitecloacks otherwise unless she decided Galad was too pretty not to enslave (and serve him right, F--KING AVATAR111 )

The dreamspike is easier to explain: Graendal's a Forsaken, and might have thought the hostages insufficient to paralyze Perrin. After all, this is Perrin: As long as he can get Faile out all the soldiers and Aiel who followed him into battle, the people he grew up with, Rands dad etc. are very expendable. He as much as said he'd forfeit the Last Battle to save Faile, which isn't so much romantic as disturbing and ignorant (if the DO gets free there won't BE a Faile or anything else, idiot).
Could her appearance have been a retcon? I could buy her staging her death by careful planning, the Chosen are supposed to excel in such intricate plans. But making someone else do the weaves for her just because, stretches credibility, particularly since we're supposed to believe that an ordinary (black) Aes Sedai is able to weave Compulsion weaves complex enough to fool Nynaeve who had some experience with these weaves.

It COULD be a retcon, though it would be an odd one since Sanderson's following RJs notes with Harriet and Doherty looking over his shoulder. No, I think it was intentional, which makes it incredibly annoying for precisely the reason you say. I mean, really, the whole point of Compulsion is to control someone elses mind without notice: Why on Earth would you farm that out to someone else? It makes perfect narrative sense in light of what follows, but for Graendal, in the moment? We're told her supposed motive: "Graendal needed to lay him a false trail, delay him--hence her requirement that Delana create a thick Compulsion with strange provisions in it. " That's all well and good, and explains why she wanted Balthamel to supply some saidin Compulsion, but it does NOTHING to explain why she couldn't have laid down the saidar Compulsion herself sense she only realizes at the last minute what Rand intends. That's setting aside the fact that either Balthamel or Delana could Compel Ramshalan to kill her at the first opportunity.

The main thing it does is remind us all that we're reading a story, shattering verisimilitude, and that's a very bad thing.
Honorbound and honored to be Bonded to Mahtaliel Sedai
Last First in wotmania Chat
Slightly better than chocolate.

Love still can't be coerced.
Please Don't Eat the Newbies!

LoL. Be well, RAFOlk.
Reply to message
I was right! In your face. - 24/11/2010 06:57:21 AM 1057 Views
relax big guys. *NM* - 24/11/2010 01:48:58 PM 192 Views
Yeah, we gloated about this weeks ago! *NM* - 24/11/2010 02:12:50 PM 188 Views
I still call shenanigans, but... whatever - 24/11/2010 02:36:44 PM 503 Views
+1 - 26/11/2010 08:43:23 AM 572 Views
spoor of the moment? - 24/11/2010 05:44:11 PM 533 Views
She was in a hurry. And scared. *NM* - 25/11/2010 03:46:16 PM 178 Views
Live and learn! - 29/11/2010 05:48:18 AM 399 Views
No, you guys were really wrong. - 24/11/2010 08:52:15 PM 509 Views
That kind of thing always annoys me. - 25/11/2010 02:52:03 PM 441 Views
I didn't mind she lived. I only minded that she was worthless afterward and nothing came of it *NM* - 25/11/2010 03:42:40 PM 187 Views
What he gets for posting ToM threads when he's only read a few chapters, I reckon. - 25/11/2010 05:11:17 PM 415 Views
I'm still scratching my head over this. (I've finished the book) - 29/11/2010 05:44:20 AM 407 Views
Don't blame you (and, thanks, now I don't have to sweat spoilers--and neither do you). - 29/11/2010 01:49:21 PM 512 Views
No reason for Rand to think so - 27/11/2010 01:14:29 AM 401 Views
Outwitted? Really? - 26/11/2010 08:40:28 AM 402 Views

Reply to Message