Re: What's the point of existing if the existence is a miserable one?
moratcorlm Send a noteboard - 27/11/2010 01:03:41 AM
Well, that's the point; for most people the existence isn't miserable. Certainly not suicidally miserable.
Perhaps you refer to the Seekers/Listeners when you say this, but really any modern civilian police force looks positively totalitarian compared to the most intricate of premodern secret polices. DNA fingerprinting? Chemical analysis? Photography? Yes, the Seekers might be advanced by the standards of the bumbling town guards in most places, but they're by no means as controlling as the KGB, or the Gestapo, or the CIA, or any number of agencies today that can record every word written or spoken that's sent over a communications network.
As for backstabbing in upper government, it's all-pervasive. In Cairhien. In Tear. In Andor. In Tarabon. In Arad Doman. Among the Shaido. In Altara before the Seanchan. Even among the Malkieri diaspora; in New Spring Lan frickin' Mandragoran was worrying Edeyn might have him assassinated. Literally every national government of which we've seen any degree of the workings has been consumed with backstabbing, distrust, and extreme self-interest in the higher ranks.
The Seanchan Empire in the vision was not one of stability - it was one of extreme control. To the degree that the Dark One is an "uber-control freak", the society fashioned by the Seanchan carries the risk of becoming just like the world under the DO's rule (non-existence aside).
Now that's exaggeration. But even dealing with your first point, it isn't one of extreme control. Commoners go about their everyday lives without even noticing the difference; they have to step lightly around the nobles, but that's always been the case. The only real difference is that they'll bow lower.Perhaps you refer to the Seekers/Listeners when you say this, but really any modern civilian police force looks positively totalitarian compared to the most intricate of premodern secret polices. DNA fingerprinting? Chemical analysis? Photography? Yes, the Seekers might be advanced by the standards of the bumbling town guards in most places, but they're by no means as controlling as the KGB, or the Gestapo, or the CIA, or any number of agencies today that can record every word written or spoken that's sent over a communications network.
The stability and justice the common folk experience in their lands is a good thing, but slavery coupled with the backstabbing and distrust in their upper ranks does not bode well for them being a good government in the future.
The form of slavery they have does not seem to be overly confining. This is not the brutal American chattel slavery, but a pseudo-Ottoman style that doesn't seem to be much more restraining on social mobility than the political systems in most of Randland. Andor is an exception, certainly, and possibly the Borderlands, but we're getting a skewed perspective because our POVs are mostly those of a) heroes, who get an exemption for being ta'veren or b) Aes Sedai, who are rigidly egalitarian, at least with respect to non-Aes Sedai. The clues are there in certain passages. So, I don't disagree that the Seanchan social order is due to be shaken up, although its meritocratic aspects might moderate the degree of upheaval, but the entire world as we know it is due for the same thing. I wouldn't want to be a Tairen High Lord once every peasant can put his hands on a flintlock rifle.As for backstabbing in upper government, it's all-pervasive. In Cairhien. In Tear. In Andor. In Tarabon. In Arad Doman. Among the Shaido. In Altara before the Seanchan. Even among the Malkieri diaspora; in New Spring Lan frickin' Mandragoran was worrying Edeyn might have him assassinated. Literally every national government of which we've seen any degree of the workings has been consumed with backstabbing, distrust, and extreme self-interest in the higher ranks.
Provisional calendar for Towers of Midnight: https://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=0ApFWTyzG9G_UdHZCUjQzVGNLeUJyMkUycXkzQlExSFE&output=html
Tuon and Mat
22/11/2010 12:05:12 AM
- 1563 Views
The Seanchan are actually more worrisome to me than the DO.
23/11/2010 02:45:27 AM
- 849 Views
Modernity scares you more than non-existence? *NM*
23/11/2010 05:47:05 AM
- 412 Views
uhm, no.
23/11/2010 06:22:44 AM
- 883 Views
Nothing worse than anyone else has
23/11/2010 07:07:59 AM
- 816 Views
What's the point of existing if the existence is a miserable one?
26/11/2010 09:38:56 AM
- 697 Views
Re: What's the point of existing if the existence is a miserable one?
27/11/2010 01:03:41 AM
- 823 Views
I agree. The Seanchan represent a world order based upon all the principles of evil.
23/11/2010 06:37:13 PM
- 733 Views
Agreed.
24/11/2010 01:14:59 AM
- 718 Views
Personally, I'm rooting for the Seanchan to take over Randland.
24/11/2010 02:09:15 AM
- 773 Views
it's easy to ignore treaties when those that made them are dead.
24/11/2010 05:19:19 PM
- 646 Views
who on earth sympathizes with zealous racist colonizers in this day and age?
27/11/2010 08:12:46 AM
- 767 Views
"rigidly hierarchical oligarchy" How the fuck is Randland any different?
30/11/2010 09:54:13 AM
- 795 Views