Active Users:1078 Time:22/11/2024 11:08:12 AM
Re: AOL training & Rand's powers as the DR are 2 different things IMHO RugbyPlayingAshaman Send a noteboard - 16/11/2010 10:42:06 PM
I had to go and re-read this.

First of all, Lanfear never had to walk through the camp as you say. She was already at the wagons. She used her disguise as Keille to go see Kadere. No one knew who she was so there was no fighting there. She only went berserk, when Kadere told her that Rand had had sex with Aviendha. This happened INSIDE Kaderes wagon btw. Infact once the fighting started, Lanfear barely moved at all. She only took a few steps backwards once Rand tried to move forward to attack her physically.

Second. While Lanfear does kill quite a few, it is nothing like what Rand did. There was no army there, only random Aiel walking around with no idea that there would be danger. Infact, most of them would have been gathering elsewhere for Rand's planned attack against Rahvin. I admit that yes, Lanfears attack was impressive. Lanfear does summon flame, and even creates arrows of it (perhaps the same weave that LTT used), but based on the description I doubt she kills all that many. Her attack is also easily dealt with by Rand who counters her quickly with a barrier that blocks her flames. I might be biased since I think what she did was far inferior to Rands attack, but the way it reads does not really seem to match the description of Rand destorying the trollocs. I would go so far infact to say that some of the stronger asha'man such as Logain could easily have done what she did.


Lanfear was near them, since Rand, Moiraine and Lan could run to where Kadere's wagon was. However the following section is at odds with your description - Lanfear had to move a couple of times (I misremembered her walking towards him); once to get towards Rand after throwing Lan and Moiraine aside and then to get to the wagon with the angreal in it, so she didn't move back so much as changed her position.

"Fire rolled over them in waves. Arrows of it pierced those who came on with their clothes in flames. It was not as if Lanfear battled theme, or even paid them any real mind. She might have been brushing aside gnats or bitemes. Those who fled burned as well as those who tried to fight. She moved towards Rand as if nothing existed. Heartbeats only...Bodies lay inside, too, mounds of charred cloth, some stirring feebly, moaning."

It seems to me that within a few moments, she had killed or lethally injured most of the crowd that stood around and between her. From the description of people rushing away from a busy area of a city, it could have been hundreds (probably not thousands). We even get a few throwaway references to many people running towards the city while dockhands and sailors desperately jumped onto the ship. There were a lot more people in this scene than a few dozen.

Perhaps some of the Ashaman could do what she did - but they cannot without training. As was noted countless times before, what the Forsaken make fun of the Aes Sedai before is not their range of strength per se, but their overall lack of training and mastery.

Third, You might be right about whether or not Lanfear had her angreal at the time. It is mentioned that Moiraine put it on the wagon of the doorway, but nowhere is it mentioned that she picks it up. She could have picked it up while she was going to see Kadere in her disguise, in which case she would have had it all the time. The fact that she was still able to dominate Rand so easily, despite the fact that Rand DID have his angreal all the time might be a clue that Lanfear already had hers. On the other hand, she might have picked it up during her fight with Rand, and it was simply not mentioned that she picked it up. The first time we see the angreal, is from Moiraines POV where she sees that Lanfear has the angreal, and thinks that Lanfear should be able to crush Rand easily unless he has his own angreal aswell.


Lanfear climbed the wagon bed to get the bracelet. No, we don't have a clear description of her reaching down to pick it up, but keeping in mind that Moiraine's foreknowledge is what lead her to leave it at the base of the ter'angreal in the first place, and it seems to me that Lanfears' Shields became stronger and faster after she climbed the wagon and was described as holding the angreal in her hand implies she saw drawing some strength from it.

Rand's POV: "
When had she (Lanfear) climbed into the open wagon bed?...yet she could spare time for chill smiles at a dark ivory bracelet...(her attempts) to Shield him did not slow, they grew faster, stronger. He could not believe she was so strong."


"
...Lanfear standing on the wagonbed, blazing bright as the sun with saidar...She (Lanfear) was turning a bracelet in her hands...Yesterday, she (Moiraine) had taken the bracelet from a sack of odds-and-ends and left it lying there at the foot of the doorframe.
"

My point was that an Age of Legends channeler would have knowledge of weaves and techniques that made them able to kill or destroy large groups of people very quickly.

The instantaneous destruction BuddhaRand was pouring out reminded me of what Lanfear accomplished in a few heartbeats. His BuddhaRandDragonReborn powers never really came into it for me. My comment was more directed to the fact that Lanfear ignored the large crowd because she could easily weave enough things to destroy them. Rand did this on a much larger scale, but he also had more time. Once again, I'm not saying the two were identical, but if anything they were similar and Rand had the benefit of a multiplier.

Infact, the fact that according to the finns Lanfears angreal is virtually a sa'angreal, while Rand's angreal was pretty weak actually speaks pretty poorly of Lanfear here.


We don't know how much of the angreal Lanfear was drawing on. She was playing with Rand, so she could have just been using enough of the angreals' addition amplifier for him to feel harried but not enough to instantly Shield him and be done with it.

Oh sure, I agree that she killed dozens of people in only a second or so. The thing is, that is something any powerfull channeler could do. Just from the top of my head I can recall Rand believing that Taim could do much like Lanfear did, killing everyone around him if he wished. And since this was Rand's view, whether Taim is somehow linked to AoL or not is irrelevant.


The problem is Taim never did - from what we hear of his time as a False Dragon, he lead some Dragonsworn, defeated some Sisters, but neither he nor Logain decimated entire armies. Even Nynaeve and Egwene have trouble with fighting large groups of enemies, and the . Logain's performance at the manor argues my point - it was after he saw Rands' deathgates and started using them that he seemed to be most effective.

So that was my point - Age of Legends channelers had access to training that allowed them to use the full extent of their capability with minimal effort. Nothing more nothing less. And taken with nuggets from Westlands history, such as the example of Queen Eldrene who destroyed the remaining forces of an entire army of Shadowspawn presumably unaided before destroying herself, and it does seem as if this is an example of the lessened training and skills of this Ages' channelers.

Obviously you disagree, but IMHO Lanfear showed us what was possible for a strong channeler to do without even breathing hard, and Rand took it to an entirely different level because he is the Dragon Reborn.

I would disagree. The Asha'man are easily as lethal to the Shaido during Dumai's wells. Maybe even more so. Granted, there were several of them while Lanfear was alone. But the fact that Lanfear is very powerfull was never in question. I just don't believe that even Lanfears strength could have been sufficient to destroy a massive army like Rand did. An army that Ituralde says could not be stopped by anything they had and which would totally devastate Arad Doman. Lanfear was powerfull, but buddha!Rand is on another level entirely I think.


I never suggested that Lanfear is strong enough to destroy an army in as massive numbers as Rand did. And as you yourself admit, the Ashaman were working together while Lanfear was alone, so comparing a military force to a lone channeler is an unfair comparison. Any one Ashaman might not be able to do what Lanfear did in the same time period - and my point was that it was her training that gives her such lethality.


If Lanfear could be thought of as an Inter-Continental Ballistic Missile and Rand was an atom bomb, both are very destructive and powerful, but the latter is much more powerful. That doesn't make the former any less potent.

Except that Lanfear and LTT should be very close in ability, with LTT maybe having some edge. Lanfear was as powerfull as a woman could be, and apparently the strength advantage that LTT would have had would be countered by dexterity advantage of Lanfear as a woman. And yet, despite that, even you admit that the new Rand was much more powerfull. Which was ofcourse the point all along. Lanfear is extremely lethal, as are the other AoL forsaken. But Rand has become SO powerfull that he has jumped to another level entirely, somehow.


My issue with your counter-argument is that it's a bit of a straw horse. I never said that Lanfear was more powerful than BuddhaRand; his treatment of those troops reminded me of what Lanfear did (destroying large amounts of them without a moments' thought or breathing hard at the time). My other point was that his knowledge of weaving is now not limited to his experiences in this lifetime, so he is showing us what an Age of Legends channeler was capable of.


I disagree here too. Yes, she killed many more than just the empress, but again this would not have required anything truly spectacular. All Semirhage would have needed, would be the ability to travel which she had, the ability to kill quickly which any strong channeler can do and the locations of all the members of the imperial family, and given that there are darkfriends in Seanchan, and the fact that Semirhage is an expert interrogator, that would not be a problem.

Basically, all Semirhage would have needed to do was travel to the throneroom where the empress was using a reversed gateway, strike her down and leave. Then instantly open another gateway to where she knew the next member of the family was and repeat the process. Since the Seanchan back in their continent did not even KNOW what traveling was, Semirhage could have killed every single relative of the empress in very few moments. By the time the deathwatch guard recovered from the shock and even tried to arrange someekind of resistance, it would all be over. Rand actually plans to do something similar in tGS, traveling from place to place in rapid succession, striking instantly and then leaving before anyone had a chance to react. This kind of technique could have been used by anyone who knew the necessary weaves (traveling, reversing, information about locations).


I think the obvious issue is time and information. Would Semirhage know exactly where every member of the royal family is at a any given time? The way we were told this information was that it was a sudden attack, and that everyone was wiped out about the same time. The obvious thing to me would be that she wiped them all out at one time, which would imply she killed them all while they were in one place or at least in the same palace - given what we saw Lanfear do, it would be easy to imagine Semirhage doing the same to the nobles, their attendants and their guards.

It was actually LTT in Rand's head that did the channeling in the mansion, and he used weaves and techniques that Rand did NOT know. And infact, Rand uses some of the same things (deathgates) during the trolloc attack, implying that LTT at the time used nearly all of his skill. And Naeff would have seen it. And yet he still thinks that what buddha!Rand does is something else completely.


No, remember that Rand was suffering from his psychotic issues at that point in time. That was Rand tapping into some of his old memories without meaning to. LTT didn't exist - it was just Rand's way of dealing with being the Dragon Reborn and what that implied. So this is the same deal as when Rand created the weave that searched for and destroyed the Shadowspawn in the Stone - Rand did something incredibly powerful that in hindsight was formed of instinctual remembrances of his past lives.

It simply makes little logical sense that the shadow would be breeding this massively huge army of trollocs to counter the light, if the forsaken could so easily match Rand's feat and singlehandedly blow up all of the lights forces. It is not a case of forsaken being weak, its just that something has caused Rand to grow into something beyond an ordinary channeler.


You are definitely missing my point here. I never said the Forsaken could match Rand's feat - that was why I call him BuddhaRand.

Note that I never said Lanfear could do what BuddhaRand did. The only thing I even talked about was that a channeler from the AOL had enough training to be incredibly destructive using Lanfear and Semirhage as examples, and that Rand used this knowledge to amplify what he was capable of to a new level.

Oh I don't deny that Rand's LTT knowledge from AoL helped, I just don't think that that knowledge ALONE would have allowed him to do what he did.


I didn't say that the knowledge alone did it. I said that his connection to the Creator gave him the ability to exceed what he could do alone; I would suggest that he fed off of the determination of the warriors to fight for their homeland to do what he did.

Which is the point. Rand did something beyond ordinary channeling. Something unique that only he could now do, something even LTT could not have done in the AoL. We don't know what it was exactly. Ituralde mentions that Rand's attack left all the fortifications unharmed so maybe Rand somehow imbued his attacks with somekind of light-based anti-shadow attacks which were extremely deadly only to the trollocs. Or maybe Rand now has some bizarre connection to the OP that others lack. It just occurred to me that Rand's children with Aviendha have something like that, in her vision. We don't know what was going on exactly, but it WAS something more than just merely LTT being skilled.


But I never said it was "merely" LTT's skills that enabled him to do that.
"Those who think they have no time for bodily exercise will sooner or later have to find time for illness."
Reply to message
A thought Re Rands sudden new strength in the Power - 14/11/2010 04:53:33 AM 1452 Views
There could be something to that. - 14/11/2010 05:51:57 AM 824 Views
Re: There could be something to that. - 14/11/2010 08:39:18 AM 810 Views
I think Rand must have been referring to the TP. - 14/11/2010 12:44:08 PM 776 Views
Re: A thought Re Rands sudden new strength in the Power - 14/11/2010 07:30:21 AM 938 Views
Agreed. OP belongs to the Creator. Theory follows: - 28/11/2010 01:53:29 PM 691 Views
OP == CP - 14/11/2010 04:42:59 PM 774 Views
Yes. And I honestly just thought that this was b/c Rand had access to Lews Therins' training & skill - 15/11/2010 03:43:04 PM 838 Views
Re: Yes. And I honestly just thought that this was b/c Rand had access to Lews Therins' training - 15/11/2010 10:14:43 PM 626 Views
AOL training & Rand's powers as the DR are 2 different things IMHO - 16/11/2010 04:06:26 PM 663 Views
Re: AOL training & Rand's powers as the DR are 2 different things IMHO - 16/11/2010 07:19:19 PM 664 Views
Re: AOL training & Rand's powers as the DR are 2 different things IMHO - 16/11/2010 10:42:06 PM 607 Views
My first thought was that he had a Sa' angreal. Simple easy answer. *NM* - 14/11/2010 06:23:12 PM 291 Views
This is certainly a possibility, - 28/11/2010 02:26:06 PM 531 Views

Reply to Message