Galad's ethical obsessions would make him hard to compel lightly, he would need something heavy to make him go against his beliefs. HIs "compass" would also tend to make him fight ithe compulsion, like Morgase.
But it comes down to what happened. Graendal spoke of her hidden asset, then Byar tried to kill Perrin, it failed and he got killed, and Graendal cursed the idiot WC who failed. It seems straightforward enough. Brandon is nowhere as subtle or devious or convoluted as RJ (who wasn't as much as many think, anyway) .
I agree Byar didn't really need pushing to do what he did, it's one reason why I believe Brandon added Graendal in a plot arc where RJ might not have used her. In RJ's version, I think as Perrin saved the WC from the Shadow, Byar simply snapped and tried to kill him. Adding Graendal as the puppet master made the threat appear bigger. RJ would not have needed that, in a book where the four storylines would have run in parallel. It doesn't sound much like RJ's style to have a Forsaken confrontation, then the villain escapes, turns around and goes straight into another plot that concludes a bunch of chapters later.
Adding Graendal into the mix didn't change much. She still ended up punsihed, and Byar still ended up trying to kill Perrin. It just added a layer of drama, because the way RJ had plotted AMOL, it seems most of that was to come from Rand and Egwene. Mat was rather stuck and delayed, and so was Perrin, with his past coming back at him and preventing him to go forward, figuratively and literally. With the book split, and Rand's epiphany already a foregone conclusion, hese two storylines needed some added punch.
My hunch is that Brandon also moved on the timeline Mesaana's demise, and the remaining bloodknives. I'm pretty sure this was all to be solved at the same time as Egwene's victory. This needed to be pushed forward, to add some punch to her transition chapters toward the meeting, and to the "second book" in general.
We know Brandon moved events on the timeline and tweaked others, so he could make the book split work. He has said so.
But it comes down to what happened. Graendal spoke of her hidden asset, then Byar tried to kill Perrin, it failed and he got killed, and Graendal cursed the idiot WC who failed. It seems straightforward enough. Brandon is nowhere as subtle or devious or convoluted as RJ (who wasn't as much as many think, anyway) .
I agree Byar didn't really need pushing to do what he did, it's one reason why I believe Brandon added Graendal in a plot arc where RJ might not have used her. In RJ's version, I think as Perrin saved the WC from the Shadow, Byar simply snapped and tried to kill him. Adding Graendal as the puppet master made the threat appear bigger. RJ would not have needed that, in a book where the four storylines would have run in parallel. It doesn't sound much like RJ's style to have a Forsaken confrontation, then the villain escapes, turns around and goes straight into another plot that concludes a bunch of chapters later.
Adding Graendal into the mix didn't change much. She still ended up punsihed, and Byar still ended up trying to kill Perrin. It just added a layer of drama, because the way RJ had plotted AMOL, it seems most of that was to come from Rand and Egwene. Mat was rather stuck and delayed, and so was Perrin, with his past coming back at him and preventing him to go forward, figuratively and literally. With the book split, and Rand's epiphany already a foregone conclusion, hese two storylines needed some added punch.
My hunch is that Brandon also moved on the timeline Mesaana's demise, and the remaining bloodknives. I'm pretty sure this was all to be solved at the same time as Egwene's victory. This needed to be pushed forward, to add some punch to her transition chapters toward the meeting, and to the "second book" in general.
We know Brandon moved events on the timeline and tweaked others, so he could make the book split work. He has said so.
So, what was the point of survival?
11/11/2010 08:03:59 AM
- 1826 Views
RtdB!
11/11/2010 08:37:50 AM
- 1149 Views
I don't know if that would make it better or worse.
11/11/2010 09:09:06 AM
- 1179 Views
Re: I don't know if that would make it better or worse.
11/11/2010 07:11:45 PM
- 935 Views
Re: I don't know if that would make it better or worse.
11/11/2010 08:12:52 PM
- 955 Views
Why Galad?
12/11/2010 12:10:56 AM
- 974 Views
No clue. Slayer could have done it on Moridin's orders. Not like Moridin hasn't failed before *NM*
11/11/2010 08:47:55 AM
- 398 Views
Maybe she got cocky after reading the Dark Prophecy.
11/11/2010 03:32:19 PM
- 861 Views
Although I agree with the survival being stupid, I think sanderson used it ...
11/11/2010 05:02:01 PM
- 823 Views
To make it possible for Sanderson to reveal Asmodean's killer outside the Glossary *NM*
11/11/2010 05:28:06 PM
- 405 Views
I don't understand protests like this
11/11/2010 05:33:12 PM
- 884 Views
Because we are told that this was her plot, but we are never shown.
11/11/2010 07:09:48 PM
- 956 Views
Why having other Forsaken at all? Slayer and Moridin should've been enough. *NM*
11/11/2010 11:33:04 PM
- 457 Views
She might be the Tower that crumbles and regrows
12/11/2010 03:48:13 AM
- 816 Views
That pretty much assuredly refers to Moridin.
12/11/2010 03:55:48 AM
- 768 Views
Aren't dreams about the future? Moridin's death and rise have already happened. *NM*
12/11/2010 04:10:34 AM
- 405 Views