So there's a pretty intense discussion about the timeline issues in tGS and ToM over at Theoryland, and Peter Ahlstrom, Brandon's assistant, chipped in with this to say:
People unhappy about what they've seen of timeline issues in TGS and ToM so far are not going to be any happier once the book comes out. The best thing I can recommend about this is to ask Brandon on tour why certain decisions were made, if you want to know and can't figure it out. Harriet will be on the tour too, and Maria and Alan will be at the New York signing.
Alan's two main jobs on Team Jordan are keeping track of the timeline and advising with warfare issues. They have nailed down the timeline. But that does not mean that the chapters will necessarily occur in a linear order.
Thoughts?
People unhappy about what they've seen of timeline issues in TGS and ToM so far are not going to be any happier once the book comes out. The best thing I can recommend about this is to ask Brandon on tour why certain decisions were made, if you want to know and can't figure it out. Harriet will be on the tour too, and Maria and Alan will be at the New York signing.
Alan's two main jobs on Team Jordan are keeping track of the timeline and advising with warfare issues. They have nailed down the timeline. But that does not mean that the chapters will necessarily occur in a linear order.
Thoughts?
I guess I should be happy with the honesty. Personally, I think that any thematic grouping or trying to keep the climaxes near the end is outweighed by the clarity that is lost. Far worse is juggling the chapters to give the book a false sense of action by disjointedly going from chapter to chapter. It is not the be all and end all, though.
For the benefit of those who disagree, to me a linear time-line emphasizes the fact that the world is most important. (It is nice to know for instance that Verin's chat with Mat isn't occurring at the exact same time as Rand's chat with Fortuona.) It is significantly easier to see the world as a whole and in the big picture. It puts you in the world.
A chopped up storyline makes it clear that how the story is told is more important then the story itself. That, in my mind, is sad, but not the worst disaster that can happen. It won't destroy my enjoyment of the books.
Timeline: some news from Theoryland...
28/09/2010 02:12:49 AM
- 1732 Views
I couldn't care less about the timeline *NM*
28/09/2010 02:18:47 AM
- 311 Views
Agreed
28/09/2010 07:11:41 AM
- 766 Views
Re: Agreed
28/09/2010 01:02:16 PM
- 892 Views
I feel compelled to state that "DomA wins the thread". *Goes back to lurking* *NM*
01/10/2010 05:39:12 AM
- 290 Views
The people complaining about timeline issues need to seriously get a life. Sheesh!
28/09/2010 03:08:44 AM
- 705 Views
What's a little pettiness among mortal enemies who have never met? *NM*
28/09/2010 06:38:31 PM
- 280 Views
Is it possible for this Alan to publish the timeline between tGS and ToM when ToM comes out? *NM*
28/09/2010 03:39:32 AM
- 267 Views
thoughts? ....
28/09/2010 05:05:48 AM
- 784 Views
There was an easy solution to this - tell the readers each chapter!
28/09/2010 09:16:59 AM
- 668 Views
Maybe the entire book could just be a big calendar *NM*
28/09/2010 10:32:47 AM
- 275 Views
With subtexts to show what each character is doing relative to the other one *NM*
28/09/2010 11:53:15 AM
- 317 Views
Well.... one of my predictions was that...
28/09/2010 01:21:31 PM
- 819 Views
For the record, my mom didn't like it either, and she's a casual reader (has read each book once)
28/09/2010 06:12:45 PM
- 571 Views