I think it is possible that he was trying to avoid some of the problems that RJ ran into after book 6 by allowing too many separate story arcs to unflod simultaneously. It is true that there is something lost in all of this hacking up of the timeline. But perhaps he felt it was an unacceptable risk to have a book that pushes each story ark the same amount and winds up having not a thing happen in any of them.
I know that some people were able to enjoy the great amount of subtlety happening in books 8-10 even while the plot progressed so little. But most people, myself included, were simply bored to tears and frustrated. If TGS had come out and in the end nothing had been resolved, ie Egwene was still a prisoner in the tower, Rand was still angry and dark, Mat had not gotten Moiraine out of the tower, Lan is still just a solitary man traveling the blight, etc... then perhaps too much of the fanbase would have checked out permanently now that the old author had passed on and the new one was both a less brilliant writer AND just as boring..
I realize I have oversimplified things by saying that there would be nothing resolved. But perhaps Brandon (and Harriet) decided that an inherent flaw of the series as RJ was writing it was that in order to maintain the depth and subtlety, the plot had to progress far too slowly for most readers' tastes. Assuming that Tor would not let TGS be 1500 pages, perhaps Brandon felt he either had to obliterate the continuity in order to progress at least some characters' arcs, or do what RJ did and progress everybody's arcs too little for most people's tastes.
I for one enjoyed TGS more than I enjoyed books 7-11, and by a very large margin. If I have to choose between a hacked up timeline or another set of story arcs that drag on over multiple books (like Perrin rescuing Faile, Elayne very slowly becoming Queen, Egwene and her army plodding toward and attacking Tar Valon, Mat escaping with Tuon and eventually getting her back to her people, etc...)
Those storylines all developed so slowly over so many books, that many people didn't care anymore if RJ was subtle, deep, and layered. They just wanted him to get on with the story. RJ's style of writing exacts too high a price on plot progression when there are so many story arcs going on. He let the number of story lines get out of hand and the result of maintaining his writing standard while dealing with so many different story lines was resoundingly bad for perhaps the majority of the fan base.
Brandon and Harriet may have decided that the hacked up timeline was the better of two evils. They may have been right.
I know that some people were able to enjoy the great amount of subtlety happening in books 8-10 even while the plot progressed so little. But most people, myself included, were simply bored to tears and frustrated. If TGS had come out and in the end nothing had been resolved, ie Egwene was still a prisoner in the tower, Rand was still angry and dark, Mat had not gotten Moiraine out of the tower, Lan is still just a solitary man traveling the blight, etc... then perhaps too much of the fanbase would have checked out permanently now that the old author had passed on and the new one was both a less brilliant writer AND just as boring..
I realize I have oversimplified things by saying that there would be nothing resolved. But perhaps Brandon (and Harriet) decided that an inherent flaw of the series as RJ was writing it was that in order to maintain the depth and subtlety, the plot had to progress far too slowly for most readers' tastes. Assuming that Tor would not let TGS be 1500 pages, perhaps Brandon felt he either had to obliterate the continuity in order to progress at least some characters' arcs, or do what RJ did and progress everybody's arcs too little for most people's tastes.
I for one enjoyed TGS more than I enjoyed books 7-11, and by a very large margin. If I have to choose between a hacked up timeline or another set of story arcs that drag on over multiple books (like Perrin rescuing Faile, Elayne very slowly becoming Queen, Egwene and her army plodding toward and attacking Tar Valon, Mat escaping with Tuon and eventually getting her back to her people, etc...)
Those storylines all developed so slowly over so many books, that many people didn't care anymore if RJ was subtle, deep, and layered. They just wanted him to get on with the story. RJ's style of writing exacts too high a price on plot progression when there are so many story arcs going on. He let the number of story lines get out of hand and the result of maintaining his writing standard while dealing with so many different story lines was resoundingly bad for perhaps the majority of the fan base.
Brandon and Harriet may have decided that the hacked up timeline was the better of two evils. They may have been right.
A little learning is a dangerous thing.
Jason's review... Looks like DomA was right (Review is now removed)
25/09/2010 05:40:18 AM
- 3412 Views
Re: Jason's review (spoilerish thoughts from me, so BEWARE!). Looks like DomA was right
25/09/2010 06:00:46 AM
- 1237 Views
Everyone seems to think Rand will talk to Egwene, but a male channeler also makes sense
25/09/2010 10:44:18 PM
- 982 Views
No Elayne hopefully, but again it looks like Egwene has everything fall in her lap
25/09/2010 08:10:54 AM
- 1153 Views
No Elayne hopefully, but again it looks like Egwene has everything fall in her lap
25/09/2010 08:11:37 AM
- 878 Views
Perrin will probably gather the wolves...
25/09/2010 09:57:06 AM
- 1061 Views
this "we like it because it's family" stuff is worrisome
25/09/2010 10:18:22 AM
- 1030 Views
After his COT review, a less then gushing review isn't great
25/09/2010 11:42:39 AM
- 976 Views
But he is specifically trying to avoid being overly fanboyish BECAUSE of that CoT review. *NM*
27/09/2010 04:19:21 PM
- 495 Views
Damn, his COT review was infinitely more enthusiastic. What could it all mean? *NM*
25/09/2010 01:06:00 PM
- 510 Views
But his CoT review was also more enthusiastic than his KoD and TGS reviews *NM*
25/09/2010 01:07:15 PM
- 516 Views
Hmm, interesting point. Could a guilty conscience be setting in? *NM*
25/09/2010 01:26:30 PM
- 472 Views
I'm guessing Olver will sacrifice his Snakes and Foxes game his father made for him *NM*
25/09/2010 06:09:10 PM
- 648 Views
I haven't read the review but...
25/09/2010 07:22:48 PM
- 1493 Views
That's not what I meant...
25/09/2010 08:25:42 PM
- 1090 Views
It's odd, I didn't see any reference to Rand descending from DM in his review.
25/09/2010 08:39:33 PM
- 923 Views
It was the very last line...
25/09/2010 08:55:49 PM
- 1031 Views
Re: It was the very last line...
25/09/2010 09:03:14 PM
- 915 Views
Re: It was the very last line...
25/09/2010 10:09:58 PM
- 1160 Views
I blame JordanCon too.
26/09/2010 02:17:50 AM
- 1052 Views
Regarding the WOTFAQ, Tam,
26/09/2010 10:04:40 PM
- 969 Views
Regarding Brandon's messing up of the timelines...
25/09/2010 11:34:06 PM
- 1059 Views
To me it's two different things
26/09/2010 01:48:13 AM
- 1148 Views
I remember the timeline was discussed much at TL prior to TGS release.
26/09/2010 03:04:24 AM
- 980 Views
Re: I remember the timeline was discussed much at TL prior to TGS release.
26/09/2010 08:31:00 PM
- 1069 Views
KOD and TOM show where TGS could have been 'fixed'
26/09/2010 10:27:04 AM
- 952 Views
The review is back up...
27/09/2010 01:59:50 AM
- 931 Views
It wasn't quite identical... It was missing the line about Rand walking down from DM
27/09/2010 06:42:47 AM
- 929 Views
The line about Rand wasn't there when I read the review Saturday morning either. *NM*
27/09/2010 01:57:00 PM
- 423 Views
It was...
27/09/2010 04:22:24 PM
- 782 Views
I must have missed it then. It does fit with Tor's not releasing Chapter 1 early. *NM*
27/09/2010 05:06:36 PM
- 431 Views
What do you mean?
27/09/2010 11:33:15 PM
- 839 Views
I read somewhere that they'd release two different chapters this time. Could well be wrong though. *NM*
28/09/2010 02:15:28 AM
- 450 Views
Olver
27/09/2010 11:34:40 AM
- 1078 Views
doubt he'll die. Jason's review is too much of a spoiler if he actually dies *NM*
27/09/2010 11:46:16 AM
- 473 Views
One problem with the idea of a Rand-Egwene meeting in Chapter 1 beyond timeline issues
27/09/2010 10:29:15 PM
- 862 Views
Not true...
28/09/2010 01:00:40 AM
- 851 Views
Good call. I assumed, and still do, that the two events are one in the same.
28/09/2010 01:10:13 AM
- 926 Views
Not true indeed... and....
28/09/2010 02:24:00 AM
- 1087 Views