Active Users:808 Time:15/11/2024 10:01:41 AM
These 3 women have nothing in common... CatherineSedai Send a noteboard - 24/09/2010 08:04:28 PM
In CoT, Elayne opined that Sumeko already outstripped Nyn in terms of Healing. There was also a discussion before about Samitsu's skill in regulating Spirit Air and Water in healing, which is as good as being Healed thru linking.

Q: Samitsu and Sumeko's Healing are purely on the Anatomy side or they can do what Nyn has done?


IIRC Smitsu and Sumeko were only "great healers" in terms of what the White Tower has been doing for millennium. The Spirit/Water/Air form of healing was "only the crudest, most hasty battlefield work". Nynaeve is the first Aes Sedai to heal with all 5 powers in nobody-knows-how-long.

Samitsu's Talent may be strong, but she has been limited, as novices have for so long, by learning what "can" and "cannot" be from women who are NOT her equals in healing. Everything we know about the One Power actually implies that the White Tower has been doing the wrong thing by not letting anyone experiment with new weaves and such, especially at a young age before they believe their restrictions. Remember the Asha'man who believed he couldn't affect anything from a distance, and so he couldn't? By teaching every woman who learns what "isn't possible" they have been negatively imacting innovation for their entire existence. Samitsu may be especially Talented at this "hasty battlefield work" but she doesn't have a patch on Nynaeve, and I don't think she could do Healing that isn't physical.

Now, Sumeko, having spent so much time with the Kin, hasn't been as impacted by the White Tower's regulations. She uses Healing very simliar to Nynaeve's, yes, but does she have the innovation with healing Nynaeve has? In one try (hours long, but her first attempt nonetheless) Nynaeve unraveled compulsion lain by one of the most talented "compulsors" from the Age of Legends. She healed severing by instinct, which has never been done in recorded history OR the AOL.

Each in their own way they are talented healers, but Nynaeve does by instinct things that "cannot be done". She seems the only one able to heal abstract or metaphysical injuries. Perhaps the others could be taught, but I don't think Elayne is the one to judge how good someone is at Healing (her own talents being just good enough to heal a black eye).

I always say, if you must mount the gallows, give a jest to the crowd, a coin to the hangman, and make the drop with a smile on your lips. ~Birgitte
Reply to message
Nyneave's Healing Ability - 24/09/2010 08:35:45 AM 875 Views
I'm not sure what you are asking. - 24/09/2010 07:50:48 PM 468 Views
These 3 women have nothing in common... - 24/09/2010 08:04:28 PM 574 Views

Reply to Message