Trying to mask yet another Slayer killed Asmodean argument are we?
darius_sedai Send a noteboard - 21/07/2010 06:21:57 PM
RJ told in one of his Q&A a bit more about transmigration. Naturally there are time constraints to snatch the soul, especially considering balefire. However RJ also said: "there are a few other limits and constraints, but I won't go into them here, since I may want to use them in the books, and I would rather they come as a surprise if I do."
This RAFO concerning other unknown limits and constraints fits with what BS said on this topic at a signing:
Then BS still gave away, though, that the DO also couldn't transmigrate Sammael, because of Mashadar. So, this constraint doesn't seem to be one of the RAFO limits, which neither RJ nor BS specifically wanted to talk about.
Those RAFO limits and constraints, which are apparently other special circumstances of death, are still unknown (it could be linked to Asmo's death, because RJ cryptically said that Asmo couldn't be transmigrated because of how AND where he died).
I suggested that the DO usually might not be able to transmigrate a person, who dies in TAR, because the DO seems to have less power over TAR. An exception to this rule might be a close connection to the DO in TAR, at the moment of death, like Ishy had in the end of TDR.
Otherwise, the DO might also not be able to transmigrate a person, who dies in a stedding, since we know that the TP doesn't work in a stedding. Possibly, the DO also couldn't transmigrate Ogier, who seem to have souls, which aren't really connected to the WoT world (IIRC, Min never has Viewings around Ogier, and we know that Ogier never see any ghosts). Maybe the DO also can't transmigrate ta'veren or Heroes of the Horn, because they are too closely bound to the Wheel?
Do you have additonal ideas on the few other, possibly surprising limits and constraints or what circumstances of death (except for balefire) could prevent the DO from transmigrating someone?
This RAFO concerning other unknown limits and constraints fits with what BS said on this topic at a signing:
Q: Are there any circumstances of death that could prevent the Dark One from resurrecting someone (other than balefire)?
A: Yes, but I’m not going to tell you what.
A: Yes, but I’m not going to tell you what.
Then BS still gave away, though, that the DO also couldn't transmigrate Sammael, because of Mashadar. So, this constraint doesn't seem to be one of the RAFO limits, which neither RJ nor BS specifically wanted to talk about.
Those RAFO limits and constraints, which are apparently other special circumstances of death, are still unknown (it could be linked to Asmo's death, because RJ cryptically said that Asmo couldn't be transmigrated because of how AND where he died).
I suggested that the DO usually might not be able to transmigrate a person, who dies in TAR, because the DO seems to have less power over TAR. An exception to this rule might be a close connection to the DO in TAR, at the moment of death, like Ishy had in the end of TDR.
Otherwise, the DO might also not be able to transmigrate a person, who dies in a stedding, since we know that the TP doesn't work in a stedding. Possibly, the DO also couldn't transmigrate Ogier, who seem to have souls, which aren't really connected to the WoT world (IIRC, Min never has Viewings around Ogier, and we know that Ogier never see any ghosts). Maybe the DO also can't transmigrate ta'veren or Heroes of the Horn, because they are too closely bound to the Wheel?
Do you have additonal ideas on the few other, possibly surprising limits and constraints or what circumstances of death (except for balefire) could prevent the DO from transmigrating someone?
I agree with Rugby above that there is no evidence that the DO has less effect in TAR ... we've not seen anything that even hints to that idea.
Not to mention we have no idea if Slayer can carry something as large as another person into TAR. We know he doesn't actually create a gateway to enter himself in so I would think there are limits to how much mass he could take with him.
Domani Drag Queen in the White Tower ... Aran'gar watch out!
The limits of transmigration
21/07/2010 12:34:20 PM
- 1010 Views
The EXACT anwer is easy to provide...
21/07/2010 12:51:48 PM
- 645 Views
Can't be right
21/07/2010 01:09:36 PM
- 635 Views
I don't understand what you're saying here...
21/07/2010 01:19:13 PM
- 693 Views
I disagree...
21/07/2010 01:49:36 PM
- 555 Views
Re: The EXACT anwer is easy to provide...
21/07/2010 02:41:58 PM
- 556 Views
When I said distance, think of it as "radius" and the no. of threads within that radius...
21/07/2010 02:57:57 PM
- 609 Views
OK, I understand ...
21/07/2010 03:24:34 PM
- 581 Views
But as you said...
21/07/2010 03:01:50 PM
- 529 Views
Re: But as you said...
21/07/2010 03:35:51 PM
- 526 Views
I think it's absurd to think relative distance to SG is a factor:
21/07/2010 04:01:17 PM
- 722 Views
I don't think it was ever said that the DO had less Power in TAR
21/07/2010 03:01:31 PM
- 503 Views
The idea is...
21/07/2010 03:10:15 PM
- 573 Views
Hmmm, I'm not really sure if this holds true.
21/07/2010 03:25:55 PM
- 507 Views
Maybe death by the TP?
21/07/2010 03:48:16 PM
- 530 Views
Trying to mask yet another Slayer killed Asmodean argument are we?
21/07/2010 06:21:57 PM
- 587 Views