Newyorkersedai, this is really interesting and I am glad to see these kinds of topics discussed. I like the idea of light as weapon, but I think if it happens that way (and I am not yet convinced) that it would be more like Rand's sword of light that he used in EotW and TSR against the True Power conduits connecting to Ishy and Asmo. These were somehow visible in TAR, which makes me think that the battle will have to happen there.
As you said, we are in very speculative territory here, but we do have some guide posts to help us understand the cosmology of the WoT.
Early on in the series we learned that reality (even that not affected by the DO) is discontinuous and full of pockets and bubbles of difference. The Ways are continuous in themselves, but connect with the regular world in only a few places (waygates). Mirror Worlds and Parallel worlds likewise are coherent realities that are only partly overlapping. Mirror worlds are linked by Portal Stones and Parallel worlds are mostly separate except for the Finns' three points of contact with our world (the two doorways and the Tower of Ghenjei) and the Stedding, which are apparently disconnected pockets of the Ogier world. The Blight, Rhuidean, and the Eye are other examples of distinct areas that work with different physical laws than the main world. All of the areas I mentioned, moreover, (Finnland, Stedding, Rhuidean, the Blight, the Ways, (probably) the Eye) cannot be reached by TAR, at least not in the usual way. What all this means is certainly far from clear, but at least one relevant observation can be made. Discontinuous realities do not need some extra-Pattern barrier to remain separate. Without a third reality, for instance, Stedding remain distinct from the human world.
We also learned early on from Verin that there are three multiversal constants: the Dark One, the Creator, and TAR. This is why something that affects any of these three affects all possible worlds, even if the cause is specific to one world. I do not think that there is necessarily a different Bore for each world. What Mierin and co did probably affected all realities, but the Bore is specific to this world (or maybe not, but the solution must come from this world).
The world of the Finns certainly seems to be more vulnerable to the influence of Shai'tan than the human world, and this is a fact I believe to be incredibly important. Why should this be? Is it something they did or is it pure coincidence? The Stedding, on the other hand, appear to be less influenced by the Shadow than either human or Finn worlds. I have a pet theory that long long ago, perhaps in the First Age, that the Finns began exploring the parallel worlds and something went wrong, splitting their realm in two (Cyndane recalls being held in the realms--plural--of the Aelfinn and Eelfinn, and we have two separate doorways). It might be this fracture that makes the Finnlands more susceptible to the Dark One. I think that in order to secure their reality, or perhaps as part of the initial crisis, the Ogier world was "splintered" by merging parts of it with different parallel worlds (that is why the Stedding are not physically connected to each other, but still have the same natural laws). I think that either the Ogier volunteered for this universe saving task or were forced into it, but that there was some intentionality because of the existence of the Book of Translation. I think this object will reunite or help coordinate the reuinion of all the pieces of the Ogier world (from all dimension or maybe just the human one). That it exists suggests that someone once thought there would be a reason to reverse the Stedding merger (perhaps this is one of the things that will have to happen to fully reseal the Bore and eliminate the Thinness).
FInally, I think there is good evidence that the True Source is the Creator itself, just as the True Power is the Dark One itself. The Creator drives the Wheel, but does not steer it. The Dark One is either trying to steal/reinvent or destroy the Pattern (I lean towards destroy).
That still leaves the third constant, Tel'aran'rhiod, unaccounted for. We are told it forms or fills the spaces between or around the threads of the Pattern. It links all worlds and all threads and I am pretty certain it will play a crucial role in the Last Battle and the resealing/healing of the Bore. The Pit of Doom operates much like TAR and a battle of wills seems more likely than a battle of power. It doesn't seem that the One Power will be the primary solution against the Dark One. Rand destroyed the Choedan Kal, saidin already failed and RJ said that if saidar had been used it too would have been tainted, and TP-OP interactions are shown to be unpredictable.
Just a lot of rambling speculation, but I love this stuff!
LoialT
As you said, we are in very speculative territory here, but we do have some guide posts to help us understand the cosmology of the WoT.
Early on in the series we learned that reality (even that not affected by the DO) is discontinuous and full of pockets and bubbles of difference. The Ways are continuous in themselves, but connect with the regular world in only a few places (waygates). Mirror Worlds and Parallel worlds likewise are coherent realities that are only partly overlapping. Mirror worlds are linked by Portal Stones and Parallel worlds are mostly separate except for the Finns' three points of contact with our world (the two doorways and the Tower of Ghenjei) and the Stedding, which are apparently disconnected pockets of the Ogier world. The Blight, Rhuidean, and the Eye are other examples of distinct areas that work with different physical laws than the main world. All of the areas I mentioned, moreover, (Finnland, Stedding, Rhuidean, the Blight, the Ways, (probably) the Eye) cannot be reached by TAR, at least not in the usual way. What all this means is certainly far from clear, but at least one relevant observation can be made. Discontinuous realities do not need some extra-Pattern barrier to remain separate. Without a third reality, for instance, Stedding remain distinct from the human world.
We also learned early on from Verin that there are three multiversal constants: the Dark One, the Creator, and TAR. This is why something that affects any of these three affects all possible worlds, even if the cause is specific to one world. I do not think that there is necessarily a different Bore for each world. What Mierin and co did probably affected all realities, but the Bore is specific to this world (or maybe not, but the solution must come from this world).
The world of the Finns certainly seems to be more vulnerable to the influence of Shai'tan than the human world, and this is a fact I believe to be incredibly important. Why should this be? Is it something they did or is it pure coincidence? The Stedding, on the other hand, appear to be less influenced by the Shadow than either human or Finn worlds. I have a pet theory that long long ago, perhaps in the First Age, that the Finns began exploring the parallel worlds and something went wrong, splitting their realm in two (Cyndane recalls being held in the realms--plural--of the Aelfinn and Eelfinn, and we have two separate doorways). It might be this fracture that makes the Finnlands more susceptible to the Dark One. I think that in order to secure their reality, or perhaps as part of the initial crisis, the Ogier world was "splintered" by merging parts of it with different parallel worlds (that is why the Stedding are not physically connected to each other, but still have the same natural laws). I think that either the Ogier volunteered for this universe saving task or were forced into it, but that there was some intentionality because of the existence of the Book of Translation. I think this object will reunite or help coordinate the reuinion of all the pieces of the Ogier world (from all dimension or maybe just the human one). That it exists suggests that someone once thought there would be a reason to reverse the Stedding merger (perhaps this is one of the things that will have to happen to fully reseal the Bore and eliminate the Thinness).
FInally, I think there is good evidence that the True Source is the Creator itself, just as the True Power is the Dark One itself. The Creator drives the Wheel, but does not steer it. The Dark One is either trying to steal/reinvent or destroy the Pattern (I lean towards destroy).
That still leaves the third constant, Tel'aran'rhiod, unaccounted for. We are told it forms or fills the spaces between or around the threads of the Pattern. It links all worlds and all threads and I am pretty certain it will play a crucial role in the Last Battle and the resealing/healing of the Bore. The Pit of Doom operates much like TAR and a battle of wills seems more likely than a battle of power. It doesn't seem that the One Power will be the primary solution against the Dark One. Rand destroyed the Choedan Kal, saidin already failed and RJ said that if saidar had been used it too would have been tainted, and TP-OP interactions are shown to be unpredictable.
Just a lot of rambling speculation, but I love this stuff!
LoialT
How can Rand repair the bore? More importantly, what forms the boundary of the Wheel itself?
25/06/2010 01:00:35 AM
- 1505 Views
Re: How can Rand repair the bore? More importantly, what forms the boundary of the Wheel itself?
25/06/2010 04:18:42 AM
- 824 Views
Mierin thought they had found a new source of power, not of THE power.
25/06/2010 05:40:27 PM
- 855 Views
Re: Mierin thought they had found a new source of power, not of THE power.
30/06/2010 03:18:32 AM
- 783 Views
Why can't the Pattern be the Prison?
25/06/2010 05:52:31 AM
- 889 Views
Here's a theory I had posted on wotmania
25/06/2010 06:16:07 AM
- 916 Views
I told you this about 4 years ago, but your nickname is AWESOME *NM*
25/06/2010 01:21:24 PM
- 420 Views
Aiel Reluctance to Enter T'A'R in the flesh
25/06/2010 02:12:01 PM
- 824 Views
The Aiel's insistance is not baseless. They know why they say it is evil.
25/06/2010 06:01:08 PM
- 819 Views
You might be right, but the other idea is far more interesting. *NM*
25/06/2010 10:18:37 PM
- 395 Views
Slayer seems quite inhuman and he's been in TAR in the flesh a lot
26/06/2010 04:29:24 AM
- 652 Views
true, but he's also be transformed in some unknown way. Not sure he really counts as human
26/06/2010 05:46:46 PM
- 861 Views
My idea
25/06/2010 09:37:32 AM
- 776 Views
Re: My idea
25/06/2010 06:44:31 PM
- 798 Views
The very name "Bore"...
26/06/2010 07:25:22 AM
- 753 Views
Actually I think he pretty much backed DomA's opinion
26/06/2010 08:30:42 AM
- 676 Views
Well, as said, I disagree.
26/06/2010 08:43:40 AM
- 731 Views
Well here's what I think
26/06/2010 11:18:33 AM
- 982 Views
Look...
26/06/2010 11:43:25 AM
- 703 Views
Re: Look...
26/06/2010 01:04:53 PM
- 807 Views
That's wrong...
26/06/2010 01:26:25 PM
- 889 Views
You're ignoring basic facts
26/06/2010 02:44:38 PM
- 743 Views
Again...
26/06/2010 02:53:05 PM
- 759 Views
Re: Again...
26/06/2010 03:30:20 PM
- 768 Views
No, the Bore was drilled through that specific thinness in the Pattern.
26/06/2010 03:54:51 PM
- 782 Views
Yeah....
26/06/2010 04:54:50 PM
- 783 Views
After reading through the back and forth, I am convinced of this:
26/06/2010 05:33:21 PM
- 871 Views
Re: After reading through the back and forth, I am convinced of this:
27/06/2010 06:20:32 PM
- 922 Views
Maybe they can plug the Bore with garbage like British Petroleum. *NM*
25/06/2010 05:43:41 PM
- 428 Views
Re: How can Rand repair the bore? More importantly, what forms the boundary of the Wheel itself?
25/06/2010 05:59:38 PM
- 818 Views
Re: How can Rand repair the bore? More importantly, what forms the boundary of the Wheel itself?
25/06/2010 06:55:28 PM
- 746 Views
me too !
25/06/2010 10:34:41 PM
- 773 Views
It sounds similar to one of the noisy environmental problem in RJ's time
27/06/2010 02:22:27 AM
- 745 Views
Re: How can Rand repair the bore? More importantly, what forms the boundary of the Wheel itself?
25/06/2010 11:27:18 PM
- 705 Views
I always figured Egwene and Rand would have to work together.
29/06/2010 08:26:45 PM
- 812 Views
Re: I always figured Egwene and Rand would have to work together.
29/06/2010 10:17:59 PM
- 639 Views
Maybe saidar and saidin, woven together properly, form something else?
01/07/2010 11:50:40 PM
- 689 Views