Active Users:535 Time:25/12/2024 02:11:52 AM
The logistics would be practically impossible, as even RJ stated (see quote below) darius_sedai Send a noteboard - 08/06/2010 01:41:03 PM
Train them and have them specialize in gateways and traveling.


Still going to take months if not longer, they are Aiel, to break these women to the collar.


2. Channeling for hours at a time exhausts people to the point of being useless so the Seanchan would need to have dedicated gateway holders who would take no part in the battles and the army would subsequently be trapped in the new location. In effect creating potential suicide missions.

3. It's sort of like crossing a river on a battle field too... open a Gateway too close and the enemy can feel it ... a crafty general lets about half your force come through then slaughters them.

This would be a problem for both large and small gateways.


Not really, with the huge gateways linked circles can create they tire less quickly and can move troops exponentially faster. What would take an hour for the Seanchan would take minutes for the Circle. You'd have thousands of men placed with only 13 women holding the Gateway, whereas the Seanchan would need 100 women to place these same men.

PoD
Beginnings

The light of saidar sprang up around the thirteen sisters near the Sitters, around all of them together, and a thick slash of silver appeared in the middle of the clearing, rotating into a gateway ten paces tall and a hundred wide.

a 30' tall x 600' wide door way created by 13 women dramatically larger than what 100 Damane could open up as individuals (cumulatively maybe 400' across). Even if every one of the Damane was strong as hell in the Power the largest gateway even Rand can manage is only 4 paces wide, and the odds of any Damane being able to match that are nil. The AS are likely able to move at least 2x as many men per second from just one circle! Now assume they have 5 circles or 10. It adds up quickly and these women won't be exhausted by the end of the trip either. 100 AS linked v. 100 Damane is no contest.



Nope. They would have to have one specialized unit of damane that would travel to wherever they were needed to do a mass transit. The damane within each Seanchan army would still know the gateway weaves and could act as auxilary.


That's not fixing the problem of having to completely change how all the regular troops move or the fact that they can't bring along the special animal troops, raken, to'raken, s'redit and torlm are all too big to go through a gateway. You're talking about retraining the entire Seanchan army now! These are troops that have spent year training in how troop movements and proper military order. This will all have to change for the Seanchan to use small gateways to move large numbers of troops.

And you keep thinking these women will have all this time to rest between, not going to be the case when you are facing a group that is also using Traveling! Sure for one big jump this would work, but we've seen what happens when you try to use Traveling continuously without links. The Channelers will hit the point of exhaustion rather quickly and then you are stuck. It just isn't the same with circles since they can accomplish so much more with so many fewer people.


Trying to move an army through one big gateway instead of many small gateways creates several problems;
1) staging area - a huge area will be need for both the entrance and exit points
2) confusion - with so many trying to cram into one large gateway you are going to have to be careful everyone doesn't get in everyone else's way which could really slow things down, as opposed to many small gateways with plenty of space between them
3) using that much OP to open a large gateway will give away your location easily, using many gateways spread out over an area will give a good chance of surprise.


1. Less of a problem from one bigger group than hundreds of smaller ones. Like any army I image they would send an advance team out to prep the area though so it's not really going to be dramatically different than normal army staging. Soldiers are much more used to this than appearing from 100 different areas and converging on a camp site.

2. You think this would be any different for the smaller ones? You've got to be kidding me! Smaller gateways would need far more coordination to not bottle neck from one soldier tripping and falling down!

3. using a Gateway of any size is going to alert your enemy unless you are smart enough to plan ahead and Travel to a place outside of their detection zone. Like Egwene did when she moved the rebels to TV. Smaller gateways are only going to give you an element of surprise if you suddenly start gating troops directly into a city. Bryne had plans to do just this to TV.

In the end it gets down to the AS have the huge advantage because they can link. Using far less energy to achieve the task.
Domani Drag Queen in the White Tower ... Aran'gar watch out!
Reply to message
Signing reports - 06/06/2010 07:30:37 PM 2015 Views
Interesting - 06/06/2010 07:41:56 PM 1087 Views
BS said Demandred's identity is the greatest secret in the story, and will pay off in the end... - 06/06/2010 08:05:51 PM 1301 Views
militarily perhaps, but not a duel - 07/06/2010 04:56:55 AM 1076 Views
Re: militarily perhaps, but not a duel - 07/06/2010 01:34:04 PM 873 Views
Re: militarily perhaps, but not a duel - 07/06/2010 04:17:26 PM 947 Views
Oh I like the villains to lose everything before they die - 07/06/2010 04:18:43 PM 855 Views
Bah - 07/06/2010 04:38:36 PM 954 Views
Oh no Lanfear will go down in a mouth foaming insane moment - 07/06/2010 07:04:23 PM 8872 Views
Skilled Rand would be nice. - 07/06/2010 09:24:56 PM 786 Views
I'd rather see Aviendha and Elayne link and take her out - 07/06/2010 09:41:47 PM 783 Views
Re: I'd rather see Aviendha and Elayne link and take her out - 07/06/2010 10:00:44 PM 915 Views
You are quite right, I should have said "kill all the remaining FS" - 07/06/2010 10:08:49 PM 939 Views
Re: You are quite right, I should have said "kill all the remaining FS" - 07/06/2010 10:22:11 PM 835 Views
Moridin IMO will be all Rand's to deal with - 07/06/2010 10:56:28 PM 768 Views
Moridin vs Rand will likely not be an OP fight. - 07/06/2010 11:06:16 PM 836 Views
I think it'll be OP v.TP - 07/06/2010 11:59:38 PM 848 Views
Nice thinking - 07/06/2010 06:16:15 PM 968 Views
I think Demandred might be... - 07/06/2010 09:48:29 AM 891 Views
I favor the Roederan theory - 07/06/2010 01:35:37 PM 904 Views
Murandy would certainly make the most sense... - 07/06/2010 02:06:34 PM 778 Views
Not sure about Masema, but the rest I think is likely - 07/06/2010 02:11:32 PM 992 Views
I have this feeling that Elaida is going to surprise us, and Demandred is in Caemlyn... - 06/06/2010 08:33:16 PM 1051 Views
Meh. I think Elaida will end up like other women in the series who sucked - 06/06/2010 10:56:47 PM 943 Views
While Traveling is certainly a tactical advantage, I think the Seanchan won't be able to use it. - 06/06/2010 11:15:56 PM 840 Views
A hundred gateways next to each other is as good as one giant gateway... - 06/06/2010 11:36:48 PM 948 Views
but no carts or wagons. - 07/06/2010 12:15:29 AM 954 Views
Fully supplied armies could be moved - 07/06/2010 02:45:15 AM 936 Views
you are missing the point that this would create several major problems - 07/06/2010 01:49:08 PM 903 Views
Advantages and Disadvantages to both large and small gateways - 08/06/2010 03:04:28 AM 900 Views
The logistics would be practically impossible, as even RJ stated (see quote below) - 08/06/2010 01:41:03 PM 887 Views
But the Seanchan have an advantage the Perrin did not... - 07/06/2010 02:45:26 AM 951 Views
Re: But the Seanchan have an advantage the Perrin did not... - 07/06/2010 01:52:40 PM 918 Views
Re: But the Seanchan have an advantage the Perrin did not... - 07/06/2010 06:55:59 PM 757 Views
Re: But the Seanchan have an advantage the Perrin did not... - 07/06/2010 07:03:29 PM 860 Views
Re: But the Seanchan have an advantage the Perrin did not... - 07/06/2010 07:48:01 PM 777 Views
Re: But the Seanchan have an advantage the Perrin did not... - 07/06/2010 08:22:23 PM 902 Views
Double Post -Sorry - NM! *NM* - 07/06/2010 08:22:23 PM 394 Views
We have no clue if Damane can tie off weaves - 07/06/2010 08:28:08 PM 861 Views
Re: We have no clue if Damane can tie off weaves - 07/06/2010 09:22:24 PM 914 Views
One disagreement - 07/06/2010 09:33:09 PM 886 Views
I agree...but - 07/06/2010 09:44:54 PM 814 Views
That's just it ... Egwene, Elayne and Rand have already thought of it and considered the uses - 07/06/2010 10:04:50 PM 916 Views
Egwene to pass information? You're joking, right? - 07/06/2010 10:59:25 PM 959 Views
He did say it was unlikely - 07/06/2010 11:23:20 PM 996 Views
Thanks! - 08/06/2010 12:02:27 AM 834 Views
Not to mention... - 07/06/2010 09:26:28 PM 866 Views
Re: Not to mention... - 07/06/2010 09:38:31 PM 803 Views
Something from RJ - 07/06/2010 09:43:16 PM 814 Views
NICE! - 07/06/2010 09:55:03 PM 671 Views
If they get Traveling, I hope we read the first time the Seanchan move their "creatures" through - 07/06/2010 06:22:47 PM 745 Views
Re: If they get Traveling, I hope we read the first time the Seanchan move their "creatures" through - 07/06/2010 11:03:22 PM 868 Views
That's a good point - 08/06/2010 12:05:30 AM 858 Views
The little thing is Rand's angreal IMO - 07/06/2010 04:52:17 AM 811 Views
Rand has a powerful sa'angreal though. - 07/06/2010 08:35:06 AM 833 Views
But this was often suggested - 07/06/2010 10:30:17 AM 874 Views
I think the thing from books 4-6 has to do with dreaming/TAR abilities. - 08/06/2010 12:09:53 AM 807 Views
I think BS has inadvertently given away a massive clue regarding Demandred's identity... - 06/06/2010 09:12:58 PM 1008 Views
What's to prevent him from hiding as a female? *NM* - 06/06/2010 10:30:08 PM 383 Views
Forgive me if I don't give that possibility serious consideration. - 06/06/2010 10:36:20 PM 819 Views
Bc it's clearly way too dissatisfying. And Demmy's certainly too proud to hide as a woman! *NM* - 07/06/2010 01:01:52 AM 452 Views
Not entirely... if he's Egwene that explains a lot - 07/06/2010 02:17:56 AM 851 Views
You misread, IMO - 07/06/2010 12:59:58 AM 956 Views
Thank you yet again, Etzel - 07/06/2010 01:07:02 AM 721 Views
Well. Galgan, then. *NM* - 07/06/2010 04:05:57 PM 442 Views
*NM* *NM* - 07/06/2010 04:06:38 PM 430 Views
Can't be Galgan - 07/06/2010 04:37:36 PM 781 Views
See we can agree on stuff *NM* - 07/06/2010 06:35:52 PM 367 Views
Of course, we can. *NM* - 07/06/2010 07:26:00 PM 378 Views
galgan's out, but maybe... - 07/06/2010 07:01:12 PM 767 Views
Or... - 08/06/2010 09:37:21 AM 787 Views
I doubt the new Taraboner king is involved - 08/06/2010 12:52:45 PM 1109 Views
As I said, I think... - 08/06/2010 01:30:39 PM 782 Views
I'm not disagreeing with most of it - 08/06/2010 01:49:54 PM 773 Views
look above, you guys agreed on stuff for 19 hours. New record? *NM* - 08/06/2010 04:12:47 PM 375 Views
LMAO - 08/06/2010 11:01:57 PM 1046 Views

Reply to Message