Active Users:444 Time:25/12/2024 07:25:07 PM
I think it's unavoidable - Edit 1

Before modification by Deadsy at 30/05/2010 10:33:33 AM

I reckon I will find some fault...


Even if RJ wrote every Mo part in the book, I'll wonder if that's how RJ would have written it, heh.


Like with tGS... I enjoyed the Elaida Egwene scenes a lot, but I felt like Elaida was too stupid. I know she was dumb in the past, I just felt like it was on an entirely new level in book 12. And I felt that it was just the difference in the authors, not a character development for Elaida. I wanted to see a battle of wills. I didn't want to see Egwene arguing with a 4 year old. So even if RJ wrote all those scenes, I wonder about it and probably always will.

It will be worse with Moiraine stuff because I care about her way more than I care about Elaida's character being correct.

Return to message