So? Your comment was completely irrelevant to anything being discussed, I don't care if whatever it could have been relevant to was close or far, you were off target either way.



Okay?



Or it could be replaced by dinner. "Ah, a guest. Have you eaten, stranger? It will soon be time for dinner, and here all are welcome to take part." Or sleep. Or any number of things. Obviously if you replace it with something seasonal, it sounds seasonal, just as if you replace it with something that isn't, it doesn't. As someone in this thread once said, "You may REALLY REALLY want it to be true. But s a wise man once said, "Wish in one hand and crap in the other and see which one fills up first." Let's stick with the facts here."



Quite possible. Or perhaps not. It did have quite an effect on Rand's swordfigthting in The Great Hunt. Of course, it has nothing to do with the Da'shain, but it is an example of music having powers other than growing crops, assuming Rand's increased ability was in fact due to the Song.



You're the one assuming. Treesinging has been shown in the series, and its effect is to shape and strengthen wood, unlike seed singing which made plants grow faster and healthier. Treesinging can be performed by Ogier alone, seed singing needs Ogier, humans and Nym in combination. It is a fact that they are different. They might be related, but we don't know that. You just assume so to fit your preconceived conclusion that there is only one magical Song.



There is no evidence for any of this. Incidentally, I like how you ignored the example of Da'shain singing to enhance channeling.



You said "it was the seed song, plain and simple." If you are now retracting that statement and admitting that you don't know what they were singing, we are in agreement.




Again, I like how you're ignoring that the Da'shain Aiel's Singing is specifically mentioned to have enhanced channeling. I assume nothing. You are ignoring facts detrimental to your predetermined conclusion.



I am assuming nothing. I am speculating that given what we know, the Da'shain Singing might have had a variety of uses we do not know of. You, on the other hand, have decided that you already know everything there is to know on the subject - despite being evidently wrong - and are trying to shoehorn seed singing into situations that have absolutely nothing to do with crop growth.