I got the part about the Nym from a sub thread in this post. One you commented on. Keep up man.
Mjolner Send a noteboard - 11/05/2010 05:42:14 AM
Fortellings are capitalized but channeling is not. Everything that is "magical" isn't always capitalized in Jordan's work. I think the reason the Voice and Singing is capitalized while seed singing is not, is the same reason that channeling is not but Forelling and Travelling are. They are common words that are representing extremey special and rare abilities. The capitalization is to differentiate. The seed singing is an festival, so it is not capitalized.
As for darkmookster's example... What proof is there? They sang a ritual song that would have been symbolic of their former way of life to a man who had forgotten it. That doesn't mean it was a different song. Are we assuming the Aiel who believed in the way of the leaf, complete passivity, would have a song to detain, or defend or attack an Aes Sedai? Not bloody likely. They sang the seed song, pure and simple.
What we have proof on is there is a Voice and Singing. We know of ONE song for sure. It is the seed song. Anything else is pure conjecture. You may REALLY REALLY want it to be true. But s a wise man once said, "Wish in one hand and crap in the other and see which one fills up first." Let's stick with the facts here. To use an Randland example. The Seanchan are obsessed with finding the "secret weapon" the Aes Sedai used to blow up a huge area, when all it was, was Aviendha having trouble untying a gateway weave(if I am not mistaken). The point is when you guess beyond the facts, you get out on a limb. I suggest we work with what we know.
I can't say whether or not the song will be found or if more nym will be found/made. I can say, I believe there is one song. The only one named in the whole book. Heck, we don't even know the Aiel outside the city gates weren't singing the latest Lady gaga song. Obviously they weren't, but since they didn't specify, we are just guessing what the song was. While my, intentionally silly, guess(lady gaga) is obviously wrong, it doesn't involve introducing a whole new series of powers and abilities to the novels. Yours does.
Lastly, I was a science major in school. This seems like a great time for Occam's Razor. All things being equal, the simplest one is true. (the one that doesn't involve a myriad of songs when we only know for a fact ONE exists) or as they say in medical school, "when you hear hoofbeats: think horse, not zebra"
That is all.
As for darkmookster's example... What proof is there? They sang a ritual song that would have been symbolic of their former way of life to a man who had forgotten it. That doesn't mean it was a different song. Are we assuming the Aiel who believed in the way of the leaf, complete passivity, would have a song to detain, or defend or attack an Aes Sedai? Not bloody likely. They sang the seed song, pure and simple.
What we have proof on is there is a Voice and Singing. We know of ONE song for sure. It is the seed song. Anything else is pure conjecture. You may REALLY REALLY want it to be true. But s a wise man once said, "Wish in one hand and crap in the other and see which one fills up first." Let's stick with the facts here. To use an Randland example. The Seanchan are obsessed with finding the "secret weapon" the Aes Sedai used to blow up a huge area, when all it was, was Aviendha having trouble untying a gateway weave(if I am not mistaken). The point is when you guess beyond the facts, you get out on a limb. I suggest we work with what we know.
I can't say whether or not the song will be found or if more nym will be found/made. I can say, I believe there is one song. The only one named in the whole book. Heck, we don't even know the Aiel outside the city gates weren't singing the latest Lady gaga song. Obviously they weren't, but since they didn't specify, we are just guessing what the song was. While my, intentionally silly, guess(lady gaga) is obviously wrong, it doesn't involve introducing a whole new series of powers and abilities to the novels. Yours does.
Lastly, I was a science major in school. This seems like a great time for Occam's Razor. All things being equal, the simplest one is true. (the one that doesn't involve a myriad of songs when we only know for a fact ONE exists) or as they say in medical school, "when you hear hoofbeats: think horse, not zebra"
That is all.
The Song--how it worked and why it was lost--OGIERS ARE NOT ARTIFICIAL
06/05/2010 03:25:18 AM
- 1834 Views
there is no Song. None. Nada. Zippo. Zilch. Bupkis.
06/05/2010 04:22:38 AM
- 1145 Views
There is a song, and maybe Rand will return it to them.
12/05/2010 07:31:32 AM
- 971 Views
I don't feel like going into the Song nonsense again. As for the Tinkers/Jenn...
12/05/2010 11:51:34 PM
- 1094 Views
They DID fail the Aes Sedai; at least in their own eyes.
16/05/2010 04:59:38 AM
- 3606 Views
it seems more likely that the sin is giving up the Way of the Leaf
19/05/2010 11:14:38 PM
- 1009 Views
because Rand was the very first person ever to see that at Rhuidan?
13/05/2010 05:04:40 AM
- 879 Views
I'm quite sure the Ogier are not artificial
06/05/2010 11:32:17 AM
- 1035 Views
I thought RJ said something about the Ogier being from another planet?
06/05/2010 02:44:21 PM
- 962 Views
This can be inferred from discussion of the Book of Translation *NM*
10/05/2010 10:04:05 PM
- 497 Views
The song was "Hey Soul Sister" by Train. It was lost when the last ter'angreal Ipod broke.
06/05/2010 02:41:42 PM
- 935 Views
According To The Big Book Of Bad Art
07/05/2010 11:25:20 PM
- 1980 Views
Re: According To The Big Book Of Bad Art
08/05/2010 08:29:39 PM
- 917 Views
Re: According To The Big Book Of Bad Art
09/05/2010 01:48:49 AM
- 1602 Views
--Ogier--artificially constructed and clearly bad--killing/violence .....
08/05/2010 03:07:55 AM
- 991 Views
Re: --Ogier--artificially constructed and clearly bad--killing/violence .....
10/05/2010 09:59:42 PM
- 929 Views
How is there "No Song?"
09/05/2010 12:44:22 AM
- 973 Views
Re: How is there "No Song?"
09/05/2010 01:38:36 AM
- 1065 Views
Oh, ok. But...
09/05/2010 05:26:54 AM
- 869 Views
I doubt it.
09/05/2010 06:38:39 PM
- 978 Views
LTT asked it because he was bonkers
10/05/2010 05:22:06 AM
- 930 Views
I agree.
11/05/2010 12:35:43 AM
- 951 Views
That's not how his insanity was portrayed.
11/05/2010 02:23:08 AM
- 905 Views
If it weren't a Seed Song, why're the Nym needed? if not needed why did they forget how to sing?
11/05/2010 04:48:12 AM
- 859 Views
From where did you get the idea that Nym were needed?
11/05/2010 05:11:15 AM
- 906 Views
I got the part about the Nym from a sub thread in this post. One you commented on. Keep up man.
11/05/2010 05:42:14 AM
- 941 Views
My only post in other subthreads is a joke response to File Leader, I think?
11/05/2010 06:52:22 AM
- 958 Views
The Voice is a talent like travelling for Aes Sedai. The capitalized Sing is for Aiel.
11/05/2010 01:41:10 PM
- 794 Views
Re: The Voice is a talent like travelling for Aes Sedai. The capitalized Sing is for Aiel.
11/05/2010 07:49:02 PM
- 887 Views