Which probably isn't really enough to comment properly but I really didn't like it. I have seen a few adaptations and this one just seemed to be lacking the subtlety that seems appropriate for Jane Austen. The way Mr Elton and Emma interacted was far too flirtatious (can't quite think of the right word but that will do) and his being totally uninterested in Harriet was just odd. I thought that Mr Elton's feelings weren't supposed to be at all obvious until much later in the story and that he was supposed to show interest in Harriet...otherwise Emma wouldn't have been so convinced that there was something there, right? I mean Emma is sneaky and quite mean at times but she's certainly not stupid. The way it was acted didn't seem in keeping with what I know of Jane Austen in that people were overly forward and not very reserved.
I dunno. As I said, that's what I got from watching not all of one episode when there are 4 in total? So yeah. Could be I caught a bit that doesn't represent the rest of the adaptation
I dunno. As I said, that's what I got from watching not all of one episode when there are 4 in total? So yeah. Could be I caught a bit that doesn't represent the rest of the adaptation
TOES
*MySmiley*
*MySmiley*
The new Emma on BBC
18/10/2009 04:21:48 PM
- 889 Views
There's a Hathaway version? Do you mean Paltrow?
18/10/2009 09:31:14 PM
- 610 Views
Isn't there an Anne Hathaway version that you rave about?
19/10/2009 08:47:19 AM
- 669 Views
I caught a bit of the latest episode...
19/10/2009 08:33:48 PM
- 913 Views
We're watching it for the silliness and Michael Gambon
19/10/2009 10:47:18 PM
- 675 Views
But but but!
20/10/2009 08:31:27 AM
- 571 Views
Bah, too refined
20/10/2009 11:18:09 AM
- 615 Views
Oh, that's fair enough.
20/10/2009 05:13:07 PM
- 622 Views